Transfer Shouts (44 Viewers)

Forums New posts
SlowerThanPlatt

SlowerThanPlatt

Well-Known Member
SeaSeeEffCee said:
Would be mental to start an 18 year old who signed this week over a player with 200+ games at this level under their belt.
Click to expand...

Depends what’s in the loan agreement, I did find it strange was reported we put the best case forward…games!
 
Hobo

Hobo

Well-Known Member
slowpoke said:
See what you are saying but we had agreed a deal with JCS which as we know didn’t happen although we have snapped up a couple of loans since id think most of the JCS wage will still be available.
Click to expand...

Well it should soon be 3 loans. What if the JCS deal was done with the anticipation of players going out of the club who haven't? Talking to the board suggests it is a budgetary issue. We also don't know what else is in the pipeline or what contingency budget there might be? It could even be just a player coming available in a position we haven't previously ear marked to strengthen and therefore not been in the budget plan?
 
Hobo

Hobo

Well-Known Member
SlowerThanPlatt said:
Depends what’s in the loan agreement, I did find it strange was reported we put the best case forward…games!
Click to expand...

It could also be about managing his game time and not playing a young player into the ground - which could be detremental to his development. Also our track record of coaches working and bringing on young players would have been considered.
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
Hobo said:
We know the budget is tight, certainly until one or maybe two go out. So bringing anyone in that takes us over budget, even temporarily would have to be discussed and rattified regardless of their wage.
Click to expand...
Yeah tbf in his circumstance going from not playing at all, to playing some at a goodlevel is probably sufficient.
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
Even if you don't rate Bidwell particularly, he was obviously signed partly to give us some extra know-how at this level. Sure, Hyam and Rose have an extra year's experience now, but McFadzean's age always lends some doubt how much he'll play (watch it be 46 games now) and given Dabo's injury record ain't great the past couple of seasons, potentially we end up with a back 5 of Eccles, Hyam, Panzo, Doyle, Adaramola... which lacks something in experience bar Hyam!
 
SkyblueDad

SkyblueDad

Well-Known Member
There are 8 fixtures until the transfer/loan window closes, 7 league, 1 cup-tie, that’s a lot, certain Robins will keep some budget back suss out where we are at, apart from Todd Kane one or two may well go on loan thinking Walker or Waghorn their freed up wages or part of them may be very usEful going to be interesting what our squad looks like come October.
 
Briles

Briles

Well-Known Member
Torquay Sky Blue said:
Adaramola seems a strange signing . 18 with no league experience at any level. Must be very highly thought of. Surely Palace would only send him here for games.
Click to expand...

They say he's the next wan bissaka so take from that what you will
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
SleepyGinger said:
If he’s better than Bidwell it doesn’t matter how old he is or what experience he’s had. I’d expect Bidwell to start the season at LWB but I wouldn’t be surprised if Adaromola takes his place.
Click to expand...

Based on what?
 
Hobo

Hobo

Well-Known Member
SleepyGinger said:
Based on the rave reviews from Palace fans, he might brilliant he might be way off it. Maatsen was hardly experienced last season and I think most of us would of played him over Bidwell.
Click to expand...

Most our fans want players playing who arent in the side because they havent made mistakes. Hence the regular comment "Robins needs to make at least 4 substitutions at halftime" and he clearly didn't because we went on to win. 😁 The debate is why play and debute a 18 year old with no experience over a very experienced player who has done well in pre season? The answer is Robins won't. Bidwell will start unless he gets injured before Sunday.
 
Last edited:
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
slowpoke said:
McCallum and Maatsen both had decent seasons with us as 18 olds so no issues with me about playing the Palace lad if it’s him as long as MR deems he is good enough.
Click to expand...
Did I miss Maatsen being with us when he was 18?!?
 
SleepyGinger

SleepyGinger

Well-Known Member
Hobo said:
Most our fans want players playing who arent in the side because they havent made mistakes. Hence the regular comment "Robins needs to make at least 4 substitutions at halftime" and he clearly didn't because we went on to win. 😁 The debate is why play and debute a 18 year old with no experience over a very experienced player who has done well in pre season? The answer is Robins won't. Bidwell will start unless he gets injured before Sunday.
Click to expand...
Yes I agree Bidwell starts Sunday and probably for the first couple of months of the season
 
L

long way home

Well-Known Member
A young player is not going to have the knowledge that a pro who has played 200 games in the championship has. But that means nothing if the younger player is as good and has different abilities that suit the formation or style of play.

I think if he is better then age doesnt mean nothing, he will learn fast and training with a prem 1st team will of done him well. We also don't know if MR wants to be more defensive away and more attacking at home, which means different players who do different roles. And this kid and Bidwell are at different ends of the scale

Im all for it, comes from a good place, top coaching great environment snd has seen top players on a day to day basis perform. He sounds like a level head, wants a career and has assets that make him a good option. The fact he is as fast as a gazelle really helps us as we are a side that breaks fast. Depth in talent is never a bad thing and long may it continue.
 
L

long way home

Well-Known Member
If Bidwell performs great its his shirt to lose, if he thinks its his shirt just because he played in the championship we will be in the shit.

Every player has to play with fear of not playing, u build internal competition which drives on others. Im struggling to see why bringing in young hungry players has a downside. This should even push Burroughs to demand what he needs to do to improve. Long season we will need depth in all positions due to fixtures and injuries. Bidwell will not be scared of seeing a bright young kid, he should and i for one hopes he loves the challenge.
 
Palace Fan 1

Palace Fan 1

Active Member
Deleted member 5849 said:
It's without reason isn't it. He might be the second coming, but I suspect not even Robins or Viera know that yet - hence a loan to the likes of us!
Click to expand...

Having watched him play extensively for our U18s, U23s and first team, it's pretty obvious he's a serious talent and there were probably discussions internally as to whether to keep him and have him play for our first team or send him out on loan as he's rated that highly.

He's our best first team prospect.

I'd say right now he's as good as any Premier League wingback going forward, extremely quick, great dribbler, good passer, great energy to get up and down and has the ability to pick people out with crosses.

His defending still needs some work. he lets crosses at times a bit too easily, needs to be better at defending the back post from crosses on the other side and his awareness needs to be better at tracking runners but having said that he was up against Salah for 10 minutes last week and completely neutralised him so hopefully he's improved in that regard.

If we were relegated last season I have no doubt he'd be starting for us in the Championship.

He's a good kid and will make watching Coventry a lot of fun, I'm sure there will be lots of Palace fans tuning in to see him play.
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
Palace Fan 1 said:
Having watched him play extensively for our U18s, U23s and first team, it's pretty obvious he's a serious talent and there were probably discussions internally as to whether to keep him and have him play for our first team or send him out on loan as he's rated that highly.

He's our best first team prospect.

I'd say right now he's as good as any Premier League wingback going forward, extremely quick, great dribbler, good passer, great energy to get up and down and has the ability to pick people out with crosses.

His defending still needs some work. he lets crosses at times a bit too easily, needs to be better at defending the back post from crosses on the other side and his awareness needs to be better at tracking runners but having said that he was up against Salah for 10 minutes last week and completely neutralised him so hopefully he's improved in that regard.

If we were relegated last season I have no doubt he'd be starting for us in the Championship.

He's a good kid and will make watching Coventry a lot of fun, I'm sure there will be lots of Palace fans tuning in to see him play.
Click to expand...
That's good to know although lets face it, until he actually plays mens' football, none of us really know how he'll adapt to it.
 
Tea & Busquets

Tea & Busquets

Well-Known Member
Palace Fan 1 said:
Having watched him play extensively for our U18s, U23s and first team, it's pretty obvious he's a serious talent and there were probably discussions internally as to whether to keep him and have him play for our first team or send him out on loan as he's rated that highly.

He's our best first team prospect.

I'd say right now he's as good as any Premier League wingback going forward, extremely quick, great dribbler, good passer, great energy to get up and down and has the ability to pick people out with crosses.

His defending still needs some work. he lets crosses at times a bit too easily, needs to be better at defending the back post from crosses on the other side and his awareness needs to be better at tracking runners but having said that he was up against Salah for 10 minutes last week and completely neutralised him so hopefully he's improved in that regard.

If we were relegated last season I have no doubt he'd be starting for us in the Championship.

He's a good kid and will make watching Coventry a lot of fun, I'm sure there will be lots of Palace fans tuning in to see him play.
Click to expand...
hope you’re right mate. seems like good contrast then, Tayo more attacking and Bidwell a bit more solid at the back.
 
SlowerThanPlatt

SlowerThanPlatt

Well-Known Member
Palace Fan 1 said:
Having watched him play extensively for our U18s, U23s and first team, it's pretty obvious he's a serious talent and there were probably discussions internally as to whether to keep him and have him play for our first team or send him out on loan as he's rated that highly.

He's our best first team prospect.

I'd say right now he's as good as any Premier League wingback going forward, extremely quick, great dribbler, good passer, great energy to get up and down and has the ability to pick people out with crosses.

His defending still needs some work. he lets crosses at times a bit too easily, needs to be better at defending the back post from crosses on the other side and his awareness needs to be better at tracking runners but having said that he was up against Salah for 10 minutes last week and completely neutralised him so hopefully he's improved in that regard.

If we were relegated last season I have no doubt he'd be starting for us in the Championship.

He's a good kid and will make watching Coventry a lot of fun, I'm sure there will be lots of Palace fans tuning in to see him play.
Click to expand...

Fair play to Palace, invested lots into your youth system, opened a new £20m site too I think? Something we should have done when had some money!
 
L

Legia Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
With 5 subs to use this season he will get plenty of game time whether he starts or not. Initially Bidwell will start, and deservedly so as he seems to have had a good pre season. Off the bench with 20 minutes to go against tiring defences sounds to be a perfect introduction for the Palace lad though. Thereafter much will probably depend on the opposition as it sounds like Bidwell will be the more solid of the two and Adamarola the more adventurous.
 
Palace Fan 1

Palace Fan 1

Active Member
Deleted member 5849 said:
That's good to know although lets face it, until he actually plays mens' football, none of us really know how he'll adapt to it.
Click to expand...

He's already started against Stoke in the FA Cup last season and performed well and had minutes against Man U and Liverpool on the pre-season tour as well.

The only reason he might struggle is he's still only 18 and moving away from home might be difficult for him.

Ultimately he's absolutely rapid, so it doesn't really matter if he's up against boys or men he will just run past them.

I've never seen anyone able to track his runs off the ball runs so providing your midfielders can pick him out he'll be away.
 
shmmeee

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Palace Fan 1 said:
He's already started against Stoke in the FA Cup last season and performed well and had minutes against Man U and Liverpool on the pre-season tour as well.

The only reason he might struggle is he's still only 18 and moving away from home might be difficult for him.

Ultimately he's absolutely rapid, so it doesn't really matter if he's up against boys or men he will just run past them.

I've never seen anyone able to track his runs off the ball runs so providing your midfielders can pick him out he'll be away.
Click to expand...

Sounds like just what we need. Looking forward to seeing him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 45 (members: 0, guests: 45)
Top