Luton ratings (15 Viewers)

[fernandopartridge]

Why would you have to remove the WBA appearance?

It's patently obvious he's more attack minded than Bidwell.

That's not a criticism of Bidwell, they're two totally different players.

And the original point was that with the signing of JWE and attempted signing of Dasilva, MR was looking for more attacking intent from LWB.

Tell me why you wouldn't?

 

---

[PVA]

Tell me why you wouldn't?

You could just answer my question.

 

[fernandopartridge]

You could just answer my question.

Because he was brought on with us chasing the game after being behind, with clear instruction to push up

 

[PVA]

Because he was brought on with us chasing the game after being behind, with clear instruction to push up

I thought it was going to be that

In that case we'll have to go through all of Bidwells stats and remove any games where we were chasing a win as well, and then exclude all the games where we sat back and were holding on!

 

[fernandopartridge]

I thought it was going to be that

In that case we'll have to go through all of Bidwells stats and remove any games where we were chasing a win as well, and then exclude all the games where we sat back and were holding on!

I simply compared the last two home games, even allowing for the fact we were chasing the Luton game from the beginning there isn't much to show that JWE is a more attacking player.

 

[PVA]

I simply compared the last two home games, even allowing for the fact we were chasing the Luton game from the beginning there isn't much to show that JWE is a more attacking player.

The sample size is absolutely tiny, I think we both agree on that.

To me I think it's quite obvious that JWE is a more attacking player and I think the stats will show that in time. Please note I said more attacking, not better.

 

[stevefloyd]

Not saying the Bidwell to Birmingham rumour definitely didn't happen and it has been mentioned from a few sources on here, but it seems very strange imo.
He's made 30 appearances so far this season and has been one of the mainstays in defence, so not sure why all of a sudden Robins would ship him out? Unless there was a fee involved?

second hand cars are worth a lot more these days