Tyler walker (38 Viewers)

[Sky Blue Pete]

He dropped him when he scored in consecutive games - not a confidence builder really

Come on he’s a professional athlete not an u11 player

 

---

[SkyblueDad]

He dropped him when he scored in consecutive games - not a confidence builder really

If you are going back to the games at Blackburn and Preston last season I was at both and you are correct in saying Walker scored goals in each game the one at Preston was a well taken effort and he was denied a clear cut penalty too but other than those goals he was poor and it’s a sign of strong good management to see the overall situation and make correct and brave decisions.
Doubt if Kenny Jackett would have done that.

 

[Evo1883]

I've just looked at a thread in question and 1 poster says godden isn't any better than baka , hiwula and biamou , and he won't do it In the championship
Same poster still gives him 5 ot 6 out of 10 no matter what most weeks
In that thread the same arguments about godden are being used here still ..

Over 3 years old that thread

 

[clint van damme]

I've just looked at a thread in question and 1 poster says godden isn't any better than baka , hiwula and biamou , and he won't do it In the championship
Same poster still gives him 5 ot 6 out of 10 no matter what most weeks
In that thread the same arguments about godden are being used here still ..

Over 3 years old that thread

Name and shame (unless it's me)

 

[Evo1883]

Name and shame (unless it's me)

No point .

 

[Deleted member 9744]

If you are going back to the games at Blackburn and Preston last season I was at both and you are correct in saying Walker scored goals in each game the one at Preston was a well taken effort and he was denied a clear cut penalty too but other than those goals he was poor and it’s a sign of strong good management to see the overall situation and make correct and brave decisions.
Doubt if Kenny Jackett would have done that.

And more importantly Godden was only not playing because he was suspended. In the match before the suspension he and Gyokeres had destroyed top of the table Fulham. It would have been totally irrational to leave out Gyokeres or Godden for Walker.

 

[Deleted member 9744]

No point .

I think I could guess who they would be. It's so odd their random dislike of certain players.

 

[Deleted member 5849]

No point .

If it's me I can take it

(Although fairly sure it's not - I like a ludicrous opinion, but would plead drunkenness if that was mine!)

 

[Evo1883]

If it's me I can take it

(Although fairly sure it's not - I like a ludicrous opinion, but would plead drunkenness if that was mine!)

Not you , doesn't matter as opinions aren't binary , except this opinion definitely is still the same

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Not you , doesn't matter as opinions aren't binary , except this opinion definitely is still the same

They're not, which is where sometimes you windmill in a bit deciding everyone who wants Walker to play ahead of Godden because of current form automatically thinks Godden's shit

FWIW, Godden deserves enough space to have a rough patch now and again, and that doesn't mean he's finished. My main concern is how much he gets injured rather than if he can contribute to the squad when fit - pretty similar to Dabo really.

 

[Evo1883]

They're not, which is where sometimes you windmill in a bit deciding everyone who wants Walker to play ahead of Godden because of current form automatically thinks Godden's shit

FWIW, Godden deserves enough space to have a rough patch now and again, and that doesn't mean he's finished. My main concern is how much he gets injured rather than if he can contribute to the squad when fit - pretty similar to Dabo really.

Dabo gets a rough ride too on here

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Dabo gets a rough ride too on here

He does. Again though, often when he probably shouldn't be playing, but puts himself / is put in the firing line to be shot at.

 

[Flying Fokker]

I've had these arguments with people about godden since the day he arrived ..

Think about that for a second , I've had to defend a striker that fired us to promotion , when I was told by some pretty big posters on here that still give godden a 5 out of 10 no matter what he does , that biamou is better .

Season after season , its only penalties , its only tap ins , he only chases down defenders , he works hard but only completed 18 passes ..

I've had these arguments with people for his entire time here ..FACT

Some of our fans have NEVER liked him

And if I might say, people can be wrong! I don’t recall myself dissing Godden or Walker.

The main comments about Godden seem to have been compounded by his absences through injury. Walker‘s injuries haven’t helped either. We’ve never seen him string a few games together.

Jones seems to have been a class player. Never read much about how crap he could be.

 

[Flying Fokker]

Dabo gets a rough ride too on here

Injuries again. It is all too easy to knock someone when they have bad games post injury. Sheaf is another.

 

[SkyblueDad]

And if I might say, people can be wrong! I don’t recall myself dissing Godden or Walker.

The main comments about Godden seem to have been compounded by his absences through injury. Walker‘s injuries haven’t helped either. We’ve never seen him string a few games together.

Jones seems to have been a class player. Never read much about how crap he could be.

Remember one long term absence was illness (appendicitis) 9 matches I believe, that’s not injury and another what was described by Robins as a rare difficult to treat injury to the sole of his foot. This injury prone label is a bit much imo.

 

[Ashdown]

Whatever happens with Vik I sincerely hope we are not left relying on the likes of Godden or Walker .

 

[Evo1883]

Whatever happens with Vik I sincerely hope we are not left relying on the likes of Godden or Walker .

We undoubtedly will need a new main man

 

[Samo]

I think if Godden were to read this thread he could be forgiven for thinking we are a bunch of ungrateful pricks with short memories.

 

[Evo1883]

I think if Godden were to read this thread he could be forgiven for thinking we a bunch of ungrateful pricks with short memories.

Some of us atleast

 

[SBT]

Feels like I’m losing my mind reading this, I thought Godden was extremely popular with our fans? Singing his name as he left the pitch yesterday, as seems to happen most games…

 

[Tommo1993]

As Evo said, the best striker in the league has raised the bar ridiculously. If he is reading this, I love you Matty!

 

[Evo1883]

Feels like I’m losing my mind reading this, I thought Godden was extremely popular with our fans? Singing his name as he left the pitch yesterday, as seems to happen most games…

I'm part of that mob , and I do appreciate him

 

[PVA]

The disrespect Godden gets

 

[RegTheDonk]

MR doesn't have many options other than starting with one of them, or bringing one/both of them on at some point. On past performances, I'd take a fit Godden myself and this is presumably why MR goes with him. Tyler did score back to back but we're not privvy to what goes on in training, so maybe there is a reason why he wasn't the preferred choice - and why he went out on loan. He didn't shine there either which is unfortunate for him and us. Great team performance yesterday but a tap in and (finally) some emotion to the crowd doesn't cut it for me, sorry.

 

[fernandopartridge]

The disrespect Godden gets

It isn't disrespectful to say he's been pretty anonymous starting games, some of it isn't even really down to him. I would bet he's pretty pissed off at his lack of involvement in the penalty area given the type of player he is.

 

[rob9872]

I'm not wumming, I'd honestly prefer Max who has done nothing since being let go.

He offers so little when he doesn't score and doesn't score enough. He's worse than Baka and I'm amazed he's anywhere near the squad. The season he was joint top scorer it was with 7 goals in 31, days more about us as a side. Since then he's 2 in 30.

Not good enough and a waste of a wage.

First time I've criticised one of our own in so long but I do find him frustrating. Serves me right though as I'm quick enough to moan at the rest of you having a go at our players, so I'm pleased my little pep talk worked

 

[JonesBob]

Feels like I’m losing my mind reading this, I thought Godden was extremely popular with our fans? Singing his name as he left the pitch yesterday, as seems to happen most games…

Having a few egocentrics on here spouting out their drizzle does not mean the majority of fans, who do not read these threads, think the same way. If technology had been around 40 years ago, when Hatton Hospital was here, a fair few would be patients there by now.

 

[Sick Boy]

It isn't disrespectful to say he's been pretty anonymous starting games, some of it isn't even really down to him. I would bet he's pretty pissed off at his lack of involvement in the penalty area given the type of player he is.

It’s quite a bizarre take.

 

[stupot07]

It isn't disrespectful to say he's been pretty anonymous starting games, some of it isn't even really down to him. I would bet he's pretty pissed off at his lack of involvement in the penalty area given the type of player he is.

He didn't have a single shot against Preston, and only had 1 speculative effort from 20 yards that was blocked by the defender yesterday. That's 1 blocked shot from 20 yards in 130 minutes of football in his last 2 starts.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

 

[PVA]

It isn't disrespectful to say he's been pretty anonymous starting games, some of it isn't even really down to him. I would bet he's pretty pissed off at his lack of involvement in the penalty area given the type of player he is.

I'm not referring to recent performances I'm talking about his overall contribution to the club where some people still don't rate him and seem to think Walker is better. It's nuts.

 

[Sick Boy]

I'm not referring to recent performances I'm talking about his overall contribution to the club where some people still don't rate him and seem to think Walker is better. It's nuts.

Can you point out where that's been said?

 

[clint van damme]

I'm not referring to recent performances I'm talking about his overall contribution to the club where some people still don't rate him and seem to think Walker is better. It's nuts.

It's nuts that questioning his contribution in the last few games is seen as somehow calling in to question his whole sky blue career.

 

[PVA]

It's nuts that questioning his contribution in the last few games is seen as somehow calling in to question his whole sky blue career.

But that is what's happening. I can't be bothered to repeat what @Evo1883 has been saying throughout the thread but Godden gets so much shit for not contributing throughout his time here.

Apparently he's not contributed in the last few games... Yet set up the winning goal in the previous game despite only being on for 10 mins

 

[clint van damme]

But that is what's happening. I can't be bothered to repeat what @Evo1883 has been saying throughout the thread but Godden gets so much shit for not contributing throughout his time here.

Apparently he's not contributed in the last few games... Yet set up the winning goal in the previous game despite only being on for 10 mins

For several of us that's exactly what we've done

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Where are these multitude of posts and posters on this thread calling into question Godden's whole career with us?