Player ratings (11 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Eh ? Can't even argue with this its nonsensical
Grendel
Well-Known Member
No one dislikes anyone - cuffey is poor
Grendel
Well-Known Member
If we were two ahead and then delivered the first half performance in the second it would have felt like a defeat and ratings would be negative
Sorry Cuffey is useless regardless
stupot07
Well-Known Member
I don't dislike him, I don't rate him. That said when he has played well I have given him praise, like I did when I gave him 8. Today he was poor until the last 15 minutes, and I have marked him as such.
Why don't you put your rating up so the rest of us can critique them like you do to everyone else?.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
OK don't rate , dislike .. it's the same thing when we talk about ability
stupot07
Well-Known Member
Sorry Rob, I agree. I shouldn't bite, and am going to leave it here. As I said in an earlier post, I'm starting to not enjoy this forum for that very reason.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Bite or not , you've been a huge godden critic since his arrival .. you get called out on it and cry a bit .. thought you muted me ?
The threads there it's in black and white BTW
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
Can't be bothered to do it myself, but would be interesting to see the 3-3 Swansea ratings in comparison with today's.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
He hasn’t - you come across as his rejected boyfriend - just stop
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
I've already linked the thread grendel , no I won't fucking stop ya fud
you don't stop with your vendettas with DOD or PVA so stay the fuck out of itThe thread was linked where stu has talked openly about how he'd prefer biamou to start , he doesn't see what godden had over baka etc ...
Boosh
Well-Known Member
Ratings vs Swansea
Difficult one to mark, as we played like Jekyll & Hyde. Wilson: 6 - Did a couple of decent saves, and cleared it well to set up one of the goals, but also seemed to flap a bit when the game turned. Burroughs: 5.5 - Played well first half, but stopped going forwards at 3-0. Was right to be taken...
www.skybluestalk.co.uk
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Ratings vs Swansea
Difficult one to mark, as we played like Jekyll & Hyde. Wilson: 6 - Did a couple of decent saves, and cleared it well to set up one of the goals, but also seemed to flap a bit when the game turned. Burroughs: 5.5 - Played well first half, but stopped going forwards at 3-0. Was right to be taken...
Evo is buried
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Elaborate
Grendel
Well-Known Member
the OP entirely rated on the last 20 minutes and no one else bothered
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
So .. I'm not buried ? What on earth is this to do with my opinion of today's game
D
Deleted member 9744
Guest
Can't imagine what you'd be like if you did dislike a player. Today it even extended to being the only person who didn't think it was a clear penalty.
Boosh
Well-Known Member
My mind is clear , I'm literally arguing on behalf of our players against people who just want to put them down constantly ... I'm good
You’re one of the best posters on here, don’t let it get to you
Grendel
Well-Known Member
He isn’t good enough and you’ve bigged him up from day one - he’s been a joke signing
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Listen I'm not arsed if I'm good or shit or what , several posters on here sit near me and speak to me on match days .. they will tell you what I'm like ... not many bigger city fans around .. full stop ✋️ go to the end of the earth to watch them if I'm / my family is fit and well
And I'm not arsed what a few people on here might think of my Internet persona
Boosh
Well-Known Member
Where abouts do you sit? The people by me are insufferable. One lad wants Wilson Esbrand to ‘fuck off back to Arsenal’. I reminded him to treat people with kindness of course
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Block 16 as you come up the concourse I'm the one with the big fat head with his 2 daughters
Nuskyblue
Well-Known Member
and that he is from Man City, it would be deeply unkind to send the poor kid back to Manchester
stupot07
Well-Known Member
It's the way he went down awkwardly, I thought it looked a bit like what Ashley Young used to do like here
But on the replay it looks a definite pen, although initial contact looks just outside the area. Robins thought it would have been soft.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
Block 16 as you come up the concourse I'm the one with the big fat head with his 2 daughters
Do you drink vodka and Jaeger?
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
We can still make the song work, if you drank one but not the other it could have been problematic!
ccfc1234
Well-Known Member
Given some of the nonsense being said on here by some, it's intresting to see the manager singling both out for specific praise. JWE was noticeably very accomplished on the ball.
“Brooke [Norton-Cuffy] and Josh [Wilson-
Esbrand] had really good games, so that’s fantastic.”
“Brooke [Norton-Cuffy] and Josh [Wilson-
Esbrand] had really good games, so that’s fantastic.”
Terry_dactyl
Well-Known Member
Just got back…Wilson-Esbrand was great. Credit to Norton-Cuffy, best I’ve seen him play in the 2nd half.
Godden keeps going…lovely finish.
Vik is such a handful and bullied their fullback…so frustrating that he didn’t send Hamer through, after a brilliant bit of play. As the bloke next to me said, “he’s forgotten how to pass”.
Godden keeps going…lovely finish.
Vik is such a handful and bullied their fullback…so frustrating that he didn’t send Hamer through, after a brilliant bit of play. As the bloke next to me said, “he’s forgotten how to pass”.
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Sky_Blue_Dreamer
Well-Known Member
Wilson - 6.5 Can't be blamed for the two goals and did everything else tidy enough.
CB's - 6 Iffy first half and caught out a few times. Fadz unlucky to be booked IMO and was coaching JWE positionally almost all game.
BNC - 6 Awful up to the point we equalised. Positionally drifted inside too much, didn't offer an attacking outlet when needed and too often just let his man drift past him without tracking. Static. Improved when we were on top and got at them more.
JWE - 6.5 Again not good until we got in the ascendancy, but was involved more than BNC. First half wasn't getting into the space on the flank. One ball Gyo left for him to run on to and he just hadn't even tried to get forward. Looks very slow for a wing back. Much better after we equalised.
Eccles - 6.5 Good defensive brain. Not so much attacking.
Sheaf - 7.5 Lynchpin of the midfield and got a goal
Hamer - 6.5 Still our most creative option in midfield but played a few terrible passes. With no proper AM and two up front wish he'd play ahead of Sheaf and Eccles a bit to offer a better link to the forwards. We went long too often at times today.
Godden - 7 Pretty much how people expect Godden to be. Seemingly quiet and barely involved (though was running into channels possibly to try and give Vik space) then scores a great goal out of nowhere (and I still swear it was going wide). That totally changed the momentum of the game.
Gyo - 6.5 Fought and troubled their defence a few times but far too greedy at times. Not passing to Hmer and shooting from 25 yards was just a terrible choice.
CB's - 6 Iffy first half and caught out a few times. Fadz unlucky to be booked IMO and was coaching JWE positionally almost all game.
BNC - 6 Awful up to the point we equalised. Positionally drifted inside too much, didn't offer an attacking outlet when needed and too often just let his man drift past him without tracking. Static. Improved when we were on top and got at them more.
JWE - 6.5 Again not good until we got in the ascendancy, but was involved more than BNC. First half wasn't getting into the space on the flank. One ball Gyo left for him to run on to and he just hadn't even tried to get forward. Looks very slow for a wing back. Much better after we equalised.
Eccles - 6.5 Good defensive brain. Not so much attacking.
Sheaf - 7.5 Lynchpin of the midfield and got a goal
Hamer - 6.5 Still our most creative option in midfield but played a few terrible passes. With no proper AM and two up front wish he'd play ahead of Sheaf and Eccles a bit to offer a better link to the forwards. We went long too often at times today.
Godden - 7 Pretty much how people expect Godden to be. Seemingly quiet and barely involved (though was running into channels possibly to try and give Vik space) then scores a great goal out of nowhere (and I still swear it was going wide). That totally changed the momentum of the game.
Gyo - 6.5 Fought and troubled their defence a few times but far too greedy at times. Not passing to Hmer and shooting from 25 yards was just a terrible choice.