Brizzle ratings (7 Viewers)
- Thread starter Brighton Sky Blue
- Start date
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Just over 1 in 4 for Simms at the moment. Deserves a run IMO. If Godden is going to spit his dummy let him.
SkyblueDad
Well-Known Member
It was 1-1 when Simms came on
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Simms started the Sheff Wed game
stupot07
Well-Known Member
TomRad85
Well-Known Member
If we aren't going to bring another striker in we need one of our current ones to take off a bit and Simms is the more likely to do that. He should be starting every game where possible now.
Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Eccles was better than 5 just about but agree otherwise.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
hinckley cov
Well-Known Member
Godden was more like a 3
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Actually thought Godden was better than recently, won more in the air and his link up play is better than Simms who still looks like he’s being controlled by an invisible puppeteer. But his lack of pace and seemingly recent inability to get into positions and actually score are just deal breakers.
SkyblueDad
Well-Known Member
It was a 6 out of 10 performance all round and including our manager, why he didn’t replace Sheaf with Torp a mystery to me, think when he came on our midfield looked better all round, but we got a draw when it looked like we wouldn’t
Was going to have go at goalkeeper Collins thought he was poor tonight he’s having a bit of a wobble form wise but that save at the death was almost a worldly so I’ll keep stum.
The one positive tonight is we need better quality if we want to stay in the top 6 and be good enough to be successful especially up front two days to get them in so over to you Doug & Mark.
Was going to have go at goalkeeper Collins thought he was poor tonight he’s having a bit of a wobble form wise but that save at the death was almost a worldly so I’ll keep stum.
The one positive tonight is we need better quality if we want to stay in the top 6 and be good enough to be successful especially up front two days to get them in so over to you Doug & Mark.
False9
Well-Known Member
Collins 6 dreadful distribution but quality reaction save
MVE 6 quiet first half and a lot of bad touches by his standards. Did put some great crosses in.
Thomas 6 point down for the goal
Kitching 7
Bidwell 6.5 involved in saka goal and solid
Sheaf 6
Eccles 5 was all over the shop at times
Palmer 5.5 poor really but a few moments
COH 6 worked really hard but nothing came off
Godden 4 waste of time
Saka 8 MOTM just a great player.
Subs
Torp 6.5 some nice turns, passes astray but positive. Slightly off pace in some instances but it will all come.
Simms 7 put himself about, strikers finish for the goal. Things happen around him and impacts the game a lot more than godden
Wright 6 some nice touches but he should have been more positive and ran the full back
Lati 5 said it before, don't like him in midfield
MVE 6 quiet first half and a lot of bad touches by his standards. Did put some great crosses in.
Thomas 6 point down for the goal
Kitching 7
Bidwell 6.5 involved in saka goal and solid
Sheaf 6
Eccles 5 was all over the shop at times
Palmer 5.5 poor really but a few moments
COH 6 worked really hard but nothing came off
Godden 4 waste of time
Saka 8 MOTM just a great player.
Subs
Torp 6.5 some nice turns, passes astray but positive. Slightly off pace in some instances but it will all come.
Simms 7 put himself about, strikers finish for the goal. Things happen around him and impacts the game a lot more than godden
Wright 6 some nice touches but he should have been more positive and ran the full back
Lati 5 said it before, don't like him in midfield
Nick
Administrator
Not sure he links up better than simms
SkyblueDad
Well-Known Member
I think getting on Goddens back is poor to be honest. we know he’s not pacy but some of our passing to him over the top and down the channels & not to his feet was rubbish.
False9
Well-Known Member
That's a good point, his aerial ability is his one obvious weakness.
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
Brilliant one in the first half. The one he put in for Simms in the second was also great. Defender did well to flick it away.
olderskyblue
Well-Known Member
Collins was a 5 at best. One great save doesn’t make up for all his dithering and panicky hoofs into touch. Looked nervous every time they broke forward. Awful performance.
Martin180
Well-Known Member
So we should slow down our play to accommodate him?
SkyblueDad
Well-Known Member
So!
Martin180
Well-Known Member
Absolute nonsense
TomRad85
Well-Known Member
Martin180
Well-Known Member
Found Ben Wilsons login
Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk
olderskyblue
Well-Known Member
Ah, you didn’t go then…
Martin180
Well-Known Member
And didn’t notice the worldy
TomRad85
Well-Known Member
Agreed. Since he's come in the team he's maybe at fault for 1 goal against Swansea where he made a dodgy wall and he got absolutely hammered for it. Quality keeper. Very different from the start of the season with the professional dodgeball player in goal.
Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk
Martin180
Well-Known Member
Getting some hammer on the match thread weirdly
TomRad85
Well-Known Member
His kicking was a bit off tonight which is odd as it's usually decent, but tbh I'd argue quite a few of the outfields kicking was a bit off tonight too.
Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk
olderskyblue
Well-Known Member
I judged him on tonight’s game, and he was like a different keeper tonight. I’ve been impressed with him this season, but tonight he was awful, except for that save.
id also like it if he caught a ball every now and again from a shot. His go to is to double hand punch seemingly every time.
But…. Up until tonight, I’d agree with you. Let’s hope it a one off.
Martin180
Well-Known Member
Was a very nervous performance tonight once Sheaf went off
Martin180
Well-Known Member
We’ve bought him on potential , like most of our squad they aren’t going to perform every game but I’m way happier with him than Wilson
rob9872
Well-Known Member
Decent pedigree from Chelsea ranks and 26 nowhere near his peak for a keeper. Getting used to the level and still lots of improvement in him. As much as I hope we go up this season, the summer will be enhancing rather than full surgery and I can only see us getting really strong next season.
Think Collins is getting off lightly. Great reaction save at the end boosting scores which I understand.
But his distribution was bloody awful. He may be calmer on the ball than Wilson but when you give yourself ten minutes to release it no wonder. Needs to move it quicker, looked very uncomfortable with their press tonight.
But his distribution was bloody awful. He may be calmer on the ball than Wilson but when you give yourself ten minutes to release it no wonder. Needs to move it quicker, looked very uncomfortable with their press tonight.
Mild-Mannered Janitor
Kindest Bloke on CCFC / Maker of CCFC Dreams
I admit he is the best keeper we have but his distribution and decision making tonight was the worst we have seen all season, no need to defend it, it is what it was. Fantastic save at the end and would still have him in goal but he looked shaky tonight for some reason.
MVE - brilliant player again but was slightly off compared to his usual high standards
just felt like a performance from one of the first 10 games of the year where we didn’t connect with each other as well as we know they can.
take the point when many were not as good as they can be
MVE - brilliant player again but was slightly off compared to his usual high standards
just felt like a performance from one of the first 10 games of the year where we didn’t connect with each other as well as we know they can.
take the point when many were not as good as they can be
Collins 6 Would’ve been a 5 but for the great save at the end, kicking is awful
MVE 6 Very good going forward but poor defensively and in possession
Thomas 6 Worryingly relaxed on the ball at times
Kitching 7 Love it when he ventures forward
Bidwell 6 Struggled to get forward enough but fine defensively
Sheaf NA We would have thrashed them if he’d stayed on
Eccles 5 A very poor Sheaf imitation, he needs a rest
O’Hare 6 Everything came through him once Sheaf went off
Sakamoto 7 MOTM Well taken goal and reliably fun to watch
Godden 5 A passenger, good crosses from MVE were wasted on him
Palmer 6 Moments of quality but faded badly as usual
Latibeaudiere 5 Out of his depth at CM, his frustration with himself was obvious
Simms 6 Glad he got a goal but he refuses to play with fire
Wright 6 Never found room to worry their defence, his lack of defensive work left Bidwell badly isolated
Torp 6 Very promising intro, unusual frame for a CM but scans well and can turn out of danger
MVE 6 Very good going forward but poor defensively and in possession
Thomas 6 Worryingly relaxed on the ball at times
Kitching 7 Love it when he ventures forward
Bidwell 6 Struggled to get forward enough but fine defensively
Sheaf NA We would have thrashed them if he’d stayed on
Eccles 5 A very poor Sheaf imitation, he needs a rest
O’Hare 6 Everything came through him once Sheaf went off
Sakamoto 7 MOTM Well taken goal and reliably fun to watch
Godden 5 A passenger, good crosses from MVE were wasted on him
Palmer 6 Moments of quality but faded badly as usual
Latibeaudiere 5 Out of his depth at CM, his frustration with himself was obvious
Simms 6 Glad he got a goal but he refuses to play with fire
Wright 6 Never found room to worry their defence, his lack of defensive work left Bidwell badly isolated
Torp 6 Very promising intro, unusual frame for a CM but scans well and can turn out of danger