Do you want to discuss boring politics? (81 Viewers)

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
But was there a genuine need for a high speed rail project that shaves minutes off “on train” journey time, but adds significantly in terms of time to a train access point, in such a relatively small country? Was it really a priority over the investments in societal benefit that I mentioned? No country can afford to do everything.

Yes. Train delays hurt productivity. Our Ancient transport infrastructure is a huge part of the issues we have as a country being so much poorer than comparable nations
 

MalcSB

Well-Known Member
Yes. Train delays hurt productivity. Our Ancient transport infrastructure is a huge part of the issues we have as a country being so much poorer than comparable nations
Train delays? What has that got to do with HS2? Ensuring drivers are in the right place at the right time, modernising working practices across the rail network by discontinuing ancient Spanish practices and train drivers who earn more than junior doctors not striking would help quite a lot.
 

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
This doesn't seem to get mentioned anywhere near as often as us being told Starmer won't be able to change anything as there's no money. Where the fuck is it all going?


Was in Sweden a few months back and got talking to the locals and the general opinion seemed to be that high taxes weren't really considered an issue by most people because things just work. A new school or hospital is needed is just gets built, roads need building or repairing it just gets sorted. We seem to have the worst of both worlds, a high tax burden and not much to show for it
It's also helpful when you have a fairer, more equal society, as everyone feels like they're contributing equally.

Here with massive inequality the rich think they're shouldering too much of the tax burden and why should they pay for stuff they don't use while the poor are just lazy scroungers, while the poor think the rich should be contributing a lot more. So you get huge roadblocks and, due to money buying influence, those that can pay are largely exempted from doing so.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
So by definition we become a backwood state here in Coventry?

We should really be part of Birmingham economically. As in it should be easy and quick to commute via train or tram to Birmingham. Getting to London is only important because that’s where all the economic activity is.

Not popular in Coventry but probably true. I only work in London cos there’s fuck all decent jobs in Brum.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Train delays? What has that got to do with HS2? Ensuring drivers are in the right place at the right time, modernising working practices across the rail network by discontinuing ancient Spanish practices and train drivers who earn more than junior doctors not striking would help quite a lot.

Delays happen for a multitude of reasons capacity being one of them.

Put it this way: Is there anything you would build?
 

chiefdave

Well-Known Member
You assume everyone can get a full time NMW job. The stats don’t back that up. Illness, precarious work, not being able to get the hours, etc all impact.
When I was working from home I was shocked at how many people were about in the day and clearly didn't work. Did a quick google and it looks like around 1 in 4 people of working age don't work, for a variety of reasons.


NGL it can be hard not to turn into a stereotypical Daily Mail type 'they've got a flatscreen TV' when you see the house a few doors down, a couple similarly aged to me neither of whom work, having new windows, kitchen etc while I'm working 50 - 60 hours a week, and so stressed with work it recently put me in hospital, with a kitchen that's literally falling apart wondering how I'm ever going to afford to replace it.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
When I was working from home I was shocked at how many people were about in the day and clearly didn't work. Did a quick google and it looks like around 1 in 4 people of working age don't work, for a variety of reasons.


NGL it can be hard not to turn into a stereotypical Daily Mail type 'they've got a flatscreen TV' when you see the house a few doors down, a couple similarly aged to me neither of whom work, having new windows, kitchen etc while I'm working 50 - 60 hours a week, and so stressed with work it recently put me in hospital, with a kitchen that's literally falling apart wondering how I'm ever going to afford to replace it.

 

Liquid Gold

Well-Known Member
The new A30 expansion is nearly finished in Cornwall meaning more traffic and pollution down there.

If only we just put a high speed rail link from Paddington to Penzance so that journey didn't take over 5 hours.
 

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member

If only someone had some policy around making the rest of the country as productive as London. We could give it a cute videogame based name, Up a Level or something

I think public spending per head e.g. on transport of 8 times other regions is probably one reason.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
I have said what I would invest in which would require some building,

I just think it all needs doing. We’re so far behind most similar nations on every transport metric: HS lines, electrification, trams, undergrounds, etc.
 

MalcSB

Well-Known Member
We should really be part of Birmingham economically. As in it should be easy and quick to commute via train or tram to Birmingham. Getting to London is only important because that’s where all the economic activity is.

Not popular in Coventry but probably true. I only work in London cos there’s fuck all decent jobs in Brum.
You could always support your own policy and increase London population density by moving there.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
You could always support your own policy and increase London population density by moving there.

I like my kids I’m afraid.

But also why should everyone have to move to London for a decent job and the rest of the country just rot?
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
More from this tax guy on CGT, he posts some interesting financial analysis that isn’t just “give the rich more money and it’ll trickle down” or “money isn’t real spend as much as you like”

 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
So invest in moving jobs out of London, not in making it quicker (LOL) to get there.



Yes. That’s what I said. Improve local links, which is done by moving national links off the local network. You were the one complaining it won’t be quicker to get from Coventry to London, I was explaining why that wasn’t the intention.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
What the anti-HS2 zealots have actually achieved is cancelling it in the North and only serving London really. While claiming they don’t care about London. Genius.
 

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member

Didn't the Tories already try this? I remember it happening in Greater Manchester, there was a mayor led 'spatial framework' where each of the GM authorities had to assign spaces for housing developments. It's taken years to get it approved:

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top