Summer transfer window 2024 (46 Viewers)

[Hobo]

It's a fair point from Robins, experience isn't an innate feature of any player so buying a player purely to bring it can be short sighted. That said, that wasn't the only reason we were interested in Browne. I think his message is looking for players like one of the centre backs to step up and provide a bit more leadership.

Yes I agree, I would add Sheaf and Eccles to that. I remember Coventry signing Terry Yorath who was a leader and an obvious Captain. At the time he was a similar age to Sheaf with a similar amount of appearances.

Age isn't the only measure of experience. Drive and maturity are also important attributes.

 

---

[Ccfcisparks]

I don't think anyone was expecting much outside of a few more signings:

GK,
CB,
ST,
CM

and we will be grand.

 

[hamil99]

I don't think anyone was expecting much outside of a few more signings:

GK,
CB,
ST,
CM

and we will be grand.

I'd be happy with GK and a DM. The rest would be a bonus! Getting the GK in is the main priority in my eyes.

 

[Deity]

I'd be happy with GK and a DM. The rest would be a bonus! Getting the GK in is the main priority in my eyes.

We have to get a replacement for Godden too

 

[fernandopartridge]

Keeper is a less a priority than any of the other positions imo. Good to have but we definitely need another striking option.

 

[Ccfcisparks]

We have to get a replacement for Godden too

Yes agree with this totally.

CB we could go without but thats with the assumption Bobby plays majority of games with Lati coming in when desperate.

 

[Perennial Lurker]

I'd be happy with GK and a DM. The rest would be a bonus! Getting the GK in is the main priority in my eyes.

Why do we need a DM?

 

[BlueSkiesForever]

He's a dependable 7/10 player who does the simple stuff well. Yes, he may not get you off your seat, score or assist loads of goals and his set pieces would be bettered by a one-legged blind Oompah Loompah but you need someone in your squad who can play that no nonsense role.

You’re really not selling it to me

 

[oakey]

Can't believe some are happy to start the season with 2 strikers, one who usually plays wide left.
One more is bare minimum.
If we were serious about promotion it would be two.
The squad is no bigger than we had in League 1 currently.

 

[Deity]

Why do we need a DM?

We only have one in Sheaf unless you consider Lati to be a CDM which I don’t.

It’s too crucial a position to risk having no cover for a sheaf injury, suspension or late transfer

 

[Calista]

Can't believe some are happy to start the season with 2 strikers, one who usually plays wide left.
One more is bare minimum.

Yes, replacing Godden is an absolute must.

 

[Kingokings204]

I think a lot of posters are overlooking the loan market. How good could a premier league loan be for the striker to replace godden? Easier to convince and not such a big outlay in fees.

 

[Ccfcisparks]

Can't believe some are happy to start the season with 2 strikers, one who usually plays wide left.
One more is bare minimum.
If we were serious about promotion it would be two.
The squad is no bigger than we had in League 1 currently.

There is absolutely no way we need 2.

In the scenario Simms gets injured then the replacement Striker can go there
if he gets injured then wright will go there.

If it got that bad which imo is extremely unlikely then we would loan someone in come january.

 

[SkyB]

Can't believe some are happy to start the season with 2 strikers, one who usually plays wide left.
One more is bare minimum.
If we were serious about promotion it would be two.
The squad is no bigger than we had in League 1 currently.

Maybe he sees Obikwa as the backup now?

Wouldn't put to much weight behind it but in the unseen his 'team' won the mini games shooting drill by a fair margin.

Maybe Burroughs is the RB backup, Howley the new CM and Obikwu the Godden replacement.

 

[BlueSkiesForever]

Robins – who has been extremely tight-lipped about transfer business in recent months – said: “I think we have to wait and see. We have a profile and we have to go with that because that’s a club-wide thing not just a personal preference.

“I think we probably need a bit more experience but then those players who were with us last year have got another year on their backs, so they have been there for 12 months and know what things are about. And hopefully they will benefit from that experience, and I am looking for people to step up and step into roles that have been vacated by others.

“But the dressing room is different, it’s a bit younger but there are some really good and talented players in there and you expect someone to step into any void that’s left, expect that vacuum to be filled and it will be because there are some really good characters in there. When things don’t go so well you are looking for those leaders to have that experience to rely on.”

Right, now can I start panicking??

If it’s all true (and he’s not just trying to word things nicely for the lads in the squad) then it is pretty concerning that we’ll have no proper backup RB, no decent GK, no backup ST, no new CM or backup to Sheaf and no new LB.

We’ll basically have the same squad as last season just with Rudoni swapped in for O’Hare and some new cover on the wings, that’s a very minor improvement imo. If that’s all we get then that basically means the exact same issues of transition from defence to attack and no cover for players like Sheaf or MVE if they get injured, not to mention the fact we’ll have a lovely choice between Collins and Wilson in goal…

 

[Deleted member 162]

Right, now can I start panicking??

If it’s all true (and he’s not just trying to word things nicely for the lads in the squad) then it is pretty concerning that we’ll have no proper backup RB, no decent GK, no backup ST, no new CM or backup to Sheaf and no new LB.

We’ll basically have the same squad as last season just with Rudoni swapped in for O’Hare and some new cover on the wings, that’s a very minor improvement imo. If that’s all we get then that basically means the exact same issues of transition from defence to attack and no cover for players like Sheaf or MVE if they get injured, not to mention the fact we’ll have a lovely choice between Collins and Wilson in goal…

Given the transfer window doesn't close until the 30th August and it's currently the 12th of July, no you can't start panicking.

 

[Tomh111]

Well if you invest a lot in a recruitment department you would expect them to do the lion's share of the work.

I would imagine Robin's outlines what he wants, then comes back in at the end of the process and final interview. King will obviously have a big say on the financial side. That's how all the bigger well run club's operate.

It's this, you don't have a manager dictating.

The most successful clubs all flow downwards from a clear direction, that a manager is part of but not totally responsible for.

You set a playing strategy, around how you want or think you win games of football. You then highlight traits and skills that the players within that system require, the recruitment team then try and find players who fit that.

I.e. if your right back doesn't need to track back because you cover him with 2 cm's, but you need him to fire diagonal balls in. You find a Trent Alexander Arnold akin.

That department then presents a list of players who fit the design to a group, that discuss commercial viability and at that point the manager is involved, because maybe you need to discuss intangibles/character etc etc



Sent from my SM-S911B using Tapatalk

 

[BlueSkiesForever]

Given the transfer window doesn't close until the 30th August and it's currently the 12th of July, no you can't start panicking.

Owww, I wanted to start panicking

 

[Calista]

Maybe Burroughs is the RB backup, Howley the new CM and Obikwu the Godden rereplacement.

BlueSkiesForever has just choked on his Haribo mix

 

[fatso]

I’m really going to try and watch Eccles intently this season, I don’t know what people see in him but there must be something in it, I personally don’t see it at all but there’s too many rave reviews for it to not be true

He's the absolute engine of the team.
Does ALL the dirty stuff so Sheaf can look majestic pinging passes here there and everywhere.

Eccles breaks up the opposition play, wins back possession, protects the back four, makes numerous interceptions and blocks, , and gets the ball to our "flair" players so we can then attack.

We've got adequate cover for most positions, but no one can cover Eccles.
Just look at how poor we are when Eccles isn't it the midfield. Lats certainly isn't as good as Eccles in the middle of the park.

And Dasilva on the other hand just makes the coffee at half time!

 

[BlueSkiesForever]

BlueSkiesForever has just choked on his Haribo mix

After it looking like we’re not gonna sign any more “exotic” players I think I’ll need some whiskey in my coffee this morning

 

[Deleted member 9744]

We only have one in Sheaf unless you consider Lati to be a CDM which I don’t.

It’s too crucial a position to risk having no cover for a sheaf injury, suspension or late transfer

Is this just a wind up?

 

[Perennial Lurker]

We only have one in Sheaf unless you consider Lati to be a CDM which I don’t.

It’s too crucial a position to risk having no cover for a sheaf injury, suspension or late transfer

Eccles is a DM surely?

 

[rexo87]

Wouldn't have thought the fee was the issue, it was probably the add-ons

Right, now can I start panicking??

If it’s all true (and he’s not just trying to word things nicely for the lads in the squad) then it is pretty concerning that we’ll have no proper backup RB, no decent GK, no backup ST, no new CM or backup to Sheaf and no new LB.

We’ll basically have the same squad as last season just with Rudoni swapped in for O’Hare and some new cover on the wings, that’s a very minor improvement imo. If that’s all we get then that basically means the exact same issues of transition from defence to attack and no cover for players like Sheaf or MVE if they get injured, not to mention the fact we’ll have a lovely choice between Collins and Wilson in goal…

Wtf - at no point did he say we wouldn’t be making more signings

 

[Ccfcisparks]

Right, now can I start panicking??

If it’s all true (and he’s not just trying to word things nicely for the lads in the squad) then it is pretty concerning that we’ll have no proper backup RB, no decent GK, no backup ST, no new CM or backup to Sheaf and no new LB.

We’ll basically have the same squad as last season just with Rudoni swapped in for O’Hare and some new cover on the wings, that’s a very minor improvement imo. If that’s all we get then that basically means the exact same issues of transition from defence to attack and no cover for players like Sheaf or MVE if they get injured, not to mention the fact we’ll have a lovely choice between Collins and Wilson in goal…

Yeah youre finally going on ignore.

 

[Trueskyblue20]

Eccles is a DM surely?

Exactly, only yesterday a lot of people were saying we needed a ball carrying type of box to box midfielder and that Eccles is too similar to Sheaf so would he not be considered a DM?

Thinking about the experience argument, I would actually say a midfield of Sheaf and Eccles has a lot of experience now and even if you add Rudoni to that, he’s been playing in the Championship for a number of years now. Robins makes a great point that we have the majority of the same team, all who have a minimum of a year playing together in the Championship which will be a great foundation to build on.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[BlueSkiesForever]

Yeah youre finally going on ignore.

Finally! Works for me, won’t get half as many emojis on my comments now

 

[fatso]

Right, now can I start panicking??

If it’s all true (and he’s not just trying to word things nicely for the lads in the squad) then it is pretty concerning that we’ll have no proper backup RB, no decent GK, no backup ST, no new CM or backup to Sheaf and no new LB.

We’ll basically have the same squad as last season just with Rudoni swapped in for O’Hare and some new cover on the wings, that’s a very minor improvement imo. If that’s all we get then that basically means the exact same issues of transition from defence to attack and no cover for players like Sheaf or MVE if they get injured, not to mention the fact we’ll have a lovely choice between Collins and Wilson in goal…

Relax .... there's a long way to go, and if needed we can exploit the loan market.

Compared to the last quarter of last season, we've only lost O'hare of any real note.
And we've brought in EMC and Rudoni who look to be top quality, we've got Sakamoto back to fitness and we won't be waiting half a season for Wright and Simms to find their feet.

We will start the season with a settled back 4 that actually know each other and won't need to change formation half way through the season, and we could even have an international keeper on board.

I'm confident that we will replace Godden with a striker that's actually mobile and can run faster than a granny with a zimmer frame, and for a change our bench will have some genuine quality and options on it rather than crap players and kids.

So keep calm and trust in the process !

 

[BlueSkiesForever]

Wtf - at no point did he say we wouldn’t be making more signings

I sort of thought it was implied from what he was saying that there wouldn’t be many more signings, meaning like 1 or 2 max I assume?

 

[rexo87]

I sort of thought it was implied from what he was saying that there wouldn’t be many more signings, meaning like 1 or 2 max I assume?

He was talking about current players stepping up into the leadership role that Fadz and Kelly had. He implied there wouldn’t be many experienced players coming in but nothing about players in general

 

[hamil99]

We have to get a replacement for Godden too

I'm one of the few who thinks Tavares can step up in that place, with Dausch and Obikwu stepping up in his place. So personally striker isn't a concern for me.

 

[hamil99]

Why do we need a DM?

A proper replacement for Kelly, I feel it's what we were missing last year and one of the reasons (along with the keeper) that we shipped so many goals.

 

[Deleted member 9744]

I'm one of the few who thinks Tavares can step up in that place, with Dausch and Obikwu stepping up in his place. So personally striker isn't a concern for me.

I tend to agree. I can't think any ambitious striker would want to come here and sit on the bench watching Simms and Wright. They won't get many games.

Goalkeeper and left back are the areas of concern but the problem is we have two contracted players in both positions.

 

[hamil99]

I tend to agree. I can't think any ambitious striker would want to come here and sit on the bench watching Simms and Wright. They won't get many games.

Goalkeeper and left back are the areas of concern but the problem is we have two contracted players in both positions.

I think that's why we haven't made a move for Burrows this window, to the surprise of the Peterborough owner, because we have players there who would be hard to shift. Goalkeeper on the other hand I think we would accept a nominal fee for Wilson, and somebody would take him up.

 

[Perennial Lurker]

A proper replacement for Kelly, I feel it's what we were missing last year and one of the reasons (along with the keeper) that we shipped so many goals.

We didn't ship so many goals though