Higgs vs CCFC Court Row (10 Viewers)

[olderskyblue]

I'm not sure I understand. Who says that SISU were not told? SISU ?

 

---

[DazzleTommyDazzle]

I'm not sure I understand. Who says that SISU were not told? SISU ?

I was wondering about that. Has West confirmed that to Harris?

 

[wingy]

Marilyn K-H on the stand now.

Is that his MRS?

 

[letsallsingtogether]

No just the usual believers.:thinking about:

I'm not sure I understand. Who says that SISU were not told? SISU ?

 

[chiefdave]

I'm not sure I understand. Who says that SISU were not told? SISU ?

I think so far SISU have said they weren't told and Higgs have said they were told by CCC that SISU had been told.

I don't think CCC have said anything one way or the other yet.

Of course we still need to establish if SISU were legally required to be told.

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

As an aside, this thread is just over 20 pages from equalising with the Pompey epic...

 

[SkyBlueCharlie]

I also assume you are outraged at a councillor lying to a charity? Yes?

Which councillor is that then, I thought West was an Officer not a councillor?

 

[torchomatic]

Big bomb (not literally!) just dropped.

Paul Harris just said that Chris West had told him that Sisu had been notified of change in direction re: bank loan, ie just bipartate approach to bank. In fact Sisu never informed.

PH wanted confirmation due to ethics.

He says he had to take CW as an ACL director on his word.

Wow.

No just the usual believers.:thinking about:

 

[oldskyblue58]

Chris West is an officer of the council not a councillor

There may of course be a reasonable explanation for what has been said when CW is allowed to have his say. Quite wrong to label him a liar on a one sided cross examination

Will the whole JR rise or fall on whether SISU got told that 2 out of 3 of the parties are going to approach the Bank?. What duty to inform did Charity, Council or ACL have towards SISU?

The logical conclusion would, based on some of the comments here, be that the Charity and Council were not working together....... kind of hard to prove conspiracy between the two if true :thinking about:

 

[DazzleTommyDazzle]

Chris West is an officer of the council not a councillor

There may of course be a reasonable explanation for what has been said when CW is allowed to have his say. Quite wrong to label him a liar on a one sided cross examination

Will the whole JR rise or fall on whether SISU got told that 2 out of 3 of the parties are going to approach the Bank. What duty to inform did Charity, Council or ACL have towards SISU?

The logical conclusion would, based on some of the comments here, be that the Charity and Council were not working together....... kind of hard to prove conspiracy between the two if true :thinking about:

Don't spoil G's fun

 

[Sub]

Simon Gilbert ‏@TheSimonGilbert 2 mins Marilyn Knatchbull-Hugessen, chair of Higgs trustees, dislikes Sisu and Joy Seppala due to 'bullying/intimidation' for commercial advantage

 

[SlowerThanPlatt]

Marilyn Knatchbull-Hugessen, chair of Higgs trustees, dislikes Sisu and Joy Seppala due to 'bullying/intimidation' for commercial advantage

 

[Rob S]

Mkh done. Ms Lucy Barlow on now.

 

[chiefdave]

Simon Gilbert ‏@TheSimonGilbert Marilyn Knatchbull-Hugessen, chair of Higgs trustees, dislikes Sisu and Joy Seppala due to 'bullying/intimidation' for commercial advantage

She's pretty much summed in SISU there!

 

[covcity4life]

dont give her any balloons.

 

[wingy]

Good Girl!!

 

[blueflint]

Yes but the point is why do it? Did it influence Higgs decision - would they have not agreed to transfer the loan to the Council without West confirming this?

I also assume you are outraged at a councillor lying to a charity? Yes?

as yet there is no proof west didn't inform SISU only someone saying he didn't maybe someone at SISU slipped up and didn't act on the information that was passed lets not jump to conclusions yet hey

 

[James Smith]

Marilyn Knatchbull-Hugessen, chair of Higgs trustees, dislikes Sisu and Joy Seppala due to 'bullying/intimidation' for commercial advantage

So no different to some other Sky Blues fans in that respect.

 

[torchomatic]

He said jumping to conclusions.

maybe someone at SISU slipped up and didn't act on the information that was passed lets not jump to conclusions yet hey

 

[tisza]

It's not whether there was a responsibility to inform sisu but whether West misled/lied to the Higgs people.

 

[Rob S]

Court hears mkh is highly personally critical of Sisu & Joy. She accuses JS of threats and bullying to gain commercial advantage.

Sisu QC seeks to question how informed she is to come to such conclusions and says Sisu invested £50m in club

 

[covcity4life]

lol council lovers turning on Higgs now haha

 

[blueflint]

He said jumping to conclusions.

read from the start i didn't jump just mentioned other possibilities lets hear mr west first

 

[oldskyblue58]

so if he did "misinform" the Charity would that have changed the decisions the Charity came to? Not convinced it would

 

[wingy]

Court hears mkh is highly personally critical of Sisu & Joy. She accuses JS of threats and bullying to gain commercial advantage.

Sisu QC seeks to question how informed she is to come to such conclusions and says Sisu invested £50m in club

That should be fairly simple..

 

[SkyBlueCharlie]

lol council lovers turning on Higgs now haha

Silly little boy!

 

[oldskyblue58]

says Sisu invested £50m in club

have they ? :thinking about:

 

[blueflint]

have they ? :thinking about:

haven't seen any proof of this have you

 

[Godiva]

have they ? :thinking about:

Not even close

 

[wingy]

have they ? :thinking about:

No and extremely Incompetently come to that .

I mean who would'nt take the first available option to secure the club a share In ACL?

 

[olderskyblue]

Can Higgs QC put SISU QC in the dock and ask him to prove that comment?

 

[James Smith]

Court hears mkh is highly personally critical of Sisu & Joy. She accuses JS of threats and bullying to gain commercial advantage.

Sisu QC seeks to question how informed she is to come to such conclusions and says Sisu invested £50m in club

I'd like to hear from Sisu / Joy what the actual amount she offered for the freehold. Bit sad if they've invested £50m in us and we're a third division team playing in Sixfields.

 

[torchomatic]

Ah, one man's "jumping to conclusions" is another man's "possibilities". Got you now.

read from the start i didn't jump just mentioned other possibilities lets hear mr west first

 

[letsallsingtogether]

Since when have Sisu intimidated or bullied anyone?:thinking about:

 

[oldskyblue58]

who is Miss Lucy Barlow?