My football knowledge is not what i thought (1 Viewer)

[covboy1987]

Reading the telegraph it was praising Jack finch and James Madison who yes i thought look cracking prospects but not a mention of Ryan Haynes who stood out to me a mile as our brightest prospect for the future - they always say football is about opinions

 

---

[gspotgaz]

I thought Finch looked horrendously out of his depth.... not to say he won't go on to improve and become a good player though.

 

[gary_ccfcforever]

Jack’s only just turned 18 but in my opinion he’s got all the attributes to be a top player,” said the manager. “He gave a brilliant performance – way beyond his years. “It just depends where his best position is because we can use him in the centre of midfield – he’s got terrific ability to get around the pitch and handle the ball but also he’s a really good central defender.
“It will be interesting to see where we decide is his best position, where he develops.
“I’m really happy with his progress, but it’s his first game in the first team and the real challenge for all our young players is can they do it week in week out, season after season?”
Andy Webster, who played alongside Finch on Wednesday, has no doubts on that score, saying: “I thought JJ was outstanding – he wasn’t just good for a young player making his way into the first team, he was probably our best player on the night.

Really?

Pressley and Webster singing Finchs praises? Did they watch a different game???

 

[Otis]

Reading the telegraph it was praising Jack finch and James Madison who yes i thought look cracking prospects but not a mention of Ryan Haynes who stood out to me a mile as our brightest prospect for the future - they always say football is about opinions

My football knowledge is not what I thought, I support Coventry City.

 

[Otis]

Finch though, was way out of his depth I have to say and that was anything but a brilliant performance the other night.

 

[Ian1779]

I don't seem to remember Maddison even touching the ball.

Finch did look a little lost, especially in the first half, but then he had zero support from his fellow centre backs.. and is still very young. Happier to see a centre back (or maybe he's better as a midfielder) attempting to keep the ball on the floor and trying to find his team mates than just lumping it forward and hoping for the best.

 

[Nick]

I don't seem to remember Maddison even touching the ball.

Finch did look a little lost, especially in the first half, but then he had zero support from his fellow centre backs.. and is still very young. Happier to see a centre back (or maybe he's better as a midfielder) attempting to keep the ball on the floor and trying to find his team mates than just lumping it forward and hoping for the best.

Didn't Maddison lay the ball out to Haynes when he set the goal up? He seemed to actually want to do something with the ball and push forward.

 

[Otis]

I would say Haynes was very good though. He looks like he could be a real gem for us in the future.

 

[skybluefred]

I would say Haynes was very good though. He looks like he could be a real gem for us in the future.

More money for the sisu coffers if he makes the grade.

 

[Nick]

I would say Haynes was very good though. He looks like he could be a real gem for us in the future.

Yep, can see him at left back and Phillips at right back.

 

[letsallsingtogether]

Got to be honest don't know anything about 90% of our players don't take much notice these days just get to know them and they are changed just can't keep up

 

[fernandopartridge]

Jack’s only just turned 18 but in my opinion he’s got all the attributes to be a top player,” said the manager. “He gave a brilliant performance – way beyond his years. “It just depends where his best position is because we can use him in the centre of midfield – he’s got terrific ability to get around the pitch and handle the ball but also he’s a really good central defender.
“It will be interesting to see where we decide is his best position, where he develops.
“I’m really happy with his progress, but it’s his first game in the first team and the real challenge for all our young players is can they do it week in week out, season after season?”
Andy Webster, who played alongside Finch on Wednesday, has no doubts on that score, saying: “I thought JJ was outstanding – he wasn’t just good for a young player making his way into the first team, he was probably our best player on the night.

Really?

Pressley and Webster singing Finchs praises? Did they watch a different game???

Yeah he's going to come out and say Finch was shite. Again, what did he do wrong?

#CarlBakerDay #ClivePlattWeek #JohnGayleMonth

 

[shmmeee]

Lawton was U18 captain and also plays CB and CM, Finch must be doing something right to get in ahead of him and Urquhart.

Would like to see Maddison, Phillips and Haynes all get time this season. More excited by them than most of our signings.

 

[fernandopartridge]

Lawton was U18 captain and also plays CB and CM, Finch must be doing something right to get in ahead of him and Urquhart.

Would like to see Maddison, Phillips and Haynes all get time this season. More excited by them than most of our signings.

Yes. One positive of these austere times is seeing our young players come through. Remember Robins signing the likes of that Arsenal midfielder instead of using what we had?

The problem is that fans moan about it. Look at Finch. Looked shaky at times early on but certainly not 'out of his depth'. Yet people on here are exaggerating about how poor he was.

It reminds me of when Turner came through. He turned out alright.

#CarlBakerDay #ClivePlattWeek #JohnGayleMonth

 

[gary_ccfcforever]

I'm not getting on Finchs' back. he's 18 but to say he was excellent and Webster saying he was the best player on the park is simply ridiculous.

 

[Otis]

Yes. One positive of these austere times is seeing our young players come through. Remember Robins signing the likes of that Arsenal midfielder instead of using what we had?

The problem is that fans moan about it. Look at Finch. Looked shaky at times early on but certainly not 'out of his depth'. Yet people on here are exaggerating about how poor he was.

It reminds me of when Turner came through. He turned out alright.

#CarlBakerDay #ClivePlattWeek #JohnGayleMonth

Disagree, fernando. Not saying he is out of his depth as a player, but he was certainly out of his depth on Wednesday night. Lost count of the amount of times he needlessly gave the ball away in dangerous postions. Even if he wasn't that poor, he most certainly wasn't brilliant.

We certainly need to give him time though. If the club rate him hopefully we will see him come good in the future. Haynes for me looked a complete natural. Seemed a lot more assured in his performance.

I'm all for giving the youngsters time. I recall when Ben Turner first came into the team. He was making a fair few mistakes but I never got on his back. With the younger players they do tend to be rather raw and need time.

Like shmmeee,I too would like to see more of the young players this season. I can't see myself us challenging at the top of the table, so as long as we're doing okay I would like to see many of them get more game time.

 

[turlykerd]

if Finch's mandate was to run, really really fast, backwards, and allow the opposition to have a free run on goal by parting the defence in a way Moses would be truly proud of, then yes...he was "excellent"

and i guess the one great positive was, he didnt cost SISU any money in laundry fees as he didnt get his kit all dirty and muddy by making any tackles

 

[AndyM]

Didn't Maddison lay the ball out to Haynes when he set the goal up?

He did.

 

[mark82]

I'm not getting on Finchs' back. he's 18 but to say he was excellent and Webster saying he was the best player on the park is simply ridiculous.

Expect they are trying to buoy his confidence. Would serve no purpose saying he was dreadful (which he wasn't). He just isn't quite ready for regular first team football yet. The more he can be exposed when it doesn't really matter, the better prepared he will be when his time comes.

 

[mark82]

I just hope none of our kids read this forum.

 

[turlykerd]

I just hope none of our kids read this forum.

parental control ??

 

[Otis]

I just hope none of our kids read this forum.

That's why I only post negative things about young players after 10 p.m., cos they will all be in bed asleep.