Newcastle and armstrong (2 Viewers)

  • Thread starter Deleted member 2477
  • Start date
D

Deleted member 2477

Guest
I think after today mclaren is on borrowed time and possibly gone by monday. Will a new manager recall armstrong ? I really hope not but im worried
 

st john

Well-Known Member
Newcastle have got some good players, a new manager would wait to see what the existing players can do under him, and hopefully would get a new manager bounce anyway.
 

sw88

Chief Commentator!
I don't think Armstrong is what they need. It's a new manager they need, And with one of them at the helm, the current squad should perform a lot better.

Also do worry that Armstrong isn't ready for premiership football so unlikely to get recalled just yet
 

Terry Gibson's perm

Well-Known Member
Doubt he will get sacked as he is on the board there, they would be mad to take Armstrong back he is not ready yet and the pressure could wreck him.
 

Samo

Well-Known Member
If Newcastle had even the slightest suspicion that AA was ready for the Prem he wouldn't be playing in L1.
 

Warwickhunt

Well-Known Member
Don't worry about Armstrong! I am more concerned that they will want TM
 

Otis

Well-Known Member
Apparently on BBC's Final Score some pundits were asking as to why Newcastle don't bring back Armstrong.
 
Last edited:

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
Our biggest obstacle with keeping AA is if a championship club look at him for a loan once our agreement is up. I feel that's a real danger as I can see championship clubs taking a chance on him being able to step up and I can see Newcastle wanting to see if he can make that step up. I hope I'm wrong but I can't see him staying on for the rest of the season.
 

rupert_bear

Well-Known Member
My concern is Newcastle feed him to a championship team after Christmas to get him ready for their championship season next year
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Our biggest obstacle with keeping AA is if a championship club look at him for a loan once our agreement is up. I feel that's a real danger as I can see championship clubs taking a chance on him being able to step up and I can see Newcastle wanting to see if he can make that step up. I hope I'm wrong but I can't see him staying on for the rest of the season.

He wouldn't get in most championship teams. What's the point of sending him to the likes of Rotherham?

Top championship teams would never pick him.
 

Evo1883

Well-Known Member
He wouldn't get in most championship teams. What's the point of sending him to the likes of Rotherham?

Top championship teams would never pick him.

Why ? Just curious .
Could have said the same about wilson could we not
 

SkyBlueSid

Well-Known Member
I think that if McClaren gets the boot, that would be good news for City. A new manager would want to assess what was there before recalling youngsters. If McClaren survives, he may try more and more desperate measures to keep his job, and that could include giving Armstrong a try.

I am concerned that he will be farmed out to the Championship in January to hasten his development. If he is recalled he would have no choice but to go. This is the downside of getting a successful loan player.
 

covcity4life

Well-Known Member
He would have some input too wouldn't he? I think he'd wanna finish thr promotion job and win a medal. This is his team right now after all. He must be starting to feel the love for cov
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
He wouldn't get in most championship teams. What's the point of sending him to the likes of Rotherham?

Top championship teams would never pick him.

I would think that they're championship club's eyeing him up already. He is the league one top scorer after all and a stat like that is always going to catch the eye of teams in the league above. The fact that he's only here until January means he'll be available and if you're a mid table team come Christmas with aspersion's on a play off place but you're a little lightweight in the goal scoring dept and the league one top scorer is going to be available in a few weeks on loan to the end of the season why wouldn't you be looking at him?

For Newcastle it's a no brainer also. As someone else has pointed out Newcastle are looking favourite's to be playing championship football next season so why wouldn't you test your young striker in that league if you have the opportunity?

Like I said. I hope I'm wrong but at the moment I can't see him staying here past his current agreement.
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
Why ? Just curious .
Could have said the same about wilson could we not

Exactly. There was no shortage of posters on here who were saying that he's a league one season wonder and wouldn't cut it in the championship. I wasn't one of them. Grendull, remind me were you? :thinking about:
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
I would think that they're championship club's eyeing him up already. He is the league one top scorer after all and a stat like that is always going to catch the eye of teams in the league above. The fact that he's only here until January means he'll be available and if you're a mid table team come Christmas with aspersion's on a play off place but you're a little lightweight in the goal scoring dept and the league one top scorer is going to be available in a few weeks on loan to the end of the season why wouldn't you be looking at him?

For Newcastle it's a no brainer also. As someone else has pointed out Newcastle are looking favourite's to be playing championship football next season so why wouldn't you test your young striker in that league if you have the opportunity?

Like I said. I hope I'm wrong but at the moment I can't see him staying here past his current agreement.

What's the reason to test him? He could potentially score 30 goals this season. That would make his value massive, most championship clubs will not want an unproven striker at this level - Ashley will sell him if he probes worth it and that's more likely to happen here.

That said he could be sold in January I suppose.
 
J

Jack Griffin

Guest
Exactly. There was no shortage of posters on here who were saying that he's a league one season wonder and wouldn't cut it in the championship. I wasn't one of them. Grendull, remind me were you? :thinking about:

That Wilson chap was the same, flash in the pan.
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
What's the reason to test him? He could potentially score 30 goals this season. That would make his value massive, most championship clubs will not want an unproven striker at this level - Ashley will sell him if he probes worth it and that's more likely to happen here.

That said he could be sold in January I suppose.

Errr. To measure his progression. Or was that too obvious? 30 goals in one season certainly would increase his worth. Even more so if half of them came in the championship.

I hope I'm wrong and he's here all season. Just not seeing that possibility at this moment.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
He fluked it last season in the championship. He won't score for toffee in the premier league. :laugh:

Wilson is a lot older and will end the season scoring 5 goals in the premier league. His asset value is now plummeting.

Which is exactly my point
 

Nick

Administrator
Wilson is a lot older and will end the season scoring 5 goals in the premier league. His asset value is now plummeting.

Which is exactly my point
That is down to injury though in fairness. If he played or was dropped then your point would stand wouldn't it?
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
Wilson is a lot older and will end the season scoring 5 goals in the premier league. His asset value is now plummeting.

Which is exactly my point

He's seriously injured you knob head and is likely to miss most if not all of the rest of the season. You've proved nothing. You do know that if he isn't able to fully recover from his injury it doesn't prove you right on anything?
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
That is down to injury though in fairness. If he played or was dropped then your point would stand wouldn't it?

The point is asset value abd risk of decline. If he stays here it will be similar to the guy Huddersfield sold for £9 million.

If he moved to a championship club he may struggle or may stay on the bench.

Ashley doesn't give a fuck about Newcastle, if he ends up record scorer in this league he will attract a fee and be sold. Same as Bournemouth now will forever regret not offloading Wilson even if circumstance is different.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top