Andy Turner's 1/3rd of the season school report (1 Viewer)

Forums New posts
steve82

steve82

Well-Known Member
The telegraph's Andy Turner has done a "half term style" report from A to E and this is there scoring

Lee Burge - B
Liam O'Brien - D
Chris Stokes - C
Ryan Haynes - C
Rod Mcdonald - A
Jordan Willis - A
Jack Grimmer - B
Micky Doyle - A
Liam Kelly - A
Ben Stevenson - C
Jordan Shipley - B
Callum Maycock - C
Jodi Jones - B
Peter Vincenti - C
Devon Kelly-Evans - C
Marc McNulty - C
Duckens Nazon - A
Maxime Biamou - C
Stuart Beavon - C
Jordan Ponticelli - A
Tom Davies - C
Kwame Thomas - D


How has Kwame Thomas who's played one checkatrade game scored a D and Ben Stevenson possibly the biggest disappointment of the season so far a C

RATED: Our grades for every Sky Blues player so far this season
 
steve82

steve82

Well-Known Member
Some of the ratings you could agree with but some are shocking and needed a serious rating of E.

What's Ben Stevenson done to warrant a C? He's been missing in most his games and only thing of note was his goal v West Brom.

Where's the form that gave him his January price tag and deserved championship interest. Hes gone backwards, now struggling to command a space in a L2 side.
 
oucho

oucho

Well-Known Member
Adge said:
What a load of old pony! O'Brien and Burge both making mistakes and Burge is B but O'Brien D?:banghead:
Click to expand...
That was my view too. In fact, I was going to start a thread discussing at what point it would be fair to give LOB a run in the team again.
 
steve82

steve82

Well-Known Member
Adge said:
What a load of old pony! O'Brien and Burge both making mistakes and Burge is B but O'Brien D?:banghead:
Click to expand...

oucho said:
That was my view too. In fact, I was going to start a thread discussing at what point it would be fair to give LOB a run in the team again.
Click to expand...

O'Brien deserves a C if Stevenson is rated a C and Burge is rated B. Let's not forget he was excellent in the first two games and made some fine saves v Blackburn before his mixup at Yeovil and costly mistake v Newport tho not too dissimilar to Burge's error.

Not so sure I'd bring O'Brien back in on current form as Burge has done ok in all honesty baring his sole mistake tho maybe he could of got across quicker for McDonald's goal for Mansfield.
 
clint van damme

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
shmmeee said:
Stepped up to U23 and first team football and scored goals while doing it?

More to the point, what more are you expecting from a teenager?
Click to expand...

he's done OK and I like him, but an A is ridiculous and his first team goals came against a non league and an under 23 team. He's got a long way to go.
 
skybluegod

skybluegod

Well-Known Member
shmmeee said:
Stepped up to U23 and first team football and scored goals while doing it?

More to the point, what more are you expecting from a teenager?
Click to expand...

You don’t upmark him just because he’s a teenager imo- you have to judge him like everybody else. As mentioned he has scored against and u23’s side and a non- league he isn’t an A.
The only people that deserve an A are: McDonald, Willis and maybe could make a case for Doyle. That’s it.
 
lifeskyblue

lifeskyblue

Well-Known Member
For me only McDonald gets an ‘A’. Willis, Grimmer, Jones, Doyle a ‘B’


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
oucho

oucho

Well-Known Member
It tells you a lot about the lack of anything interesting that the CT has to do a "third of the season" rather than "half term" report, just padding so that they have something to write. Who has ever heard of a "1/3 term report"???
 
steve82

steve82

Well-Known Member
For me I rate them in this order to there performance levels
A - the consistent performer Mcdonald.
B - Burge, Willis, Grimmer, Davies, Doyle, Kelly, JJ, Nazon
C - O'Brien, Stokes, Haynes, Shipley, Mcnulty, Biamou, Ponticelli
D - Maycock, DeKE, Vincenti, Beavon,
E - Stevenson, K Thomas

Rod Mcdonalds performance levels never seem to drop, JJ I'd give a B nothing more. Too many games he's gone missing in recently yet in others he's excelled and done the job we expect. Stevenson and Thomas nothing more than a E can be given to what they've contributed to the 1st team.
 
ccfcway

ccfcway

Well-Known Member
Pont was behind.....

McNulty, Beavon, Thomas, Biamou, Andreu and Nazon at the start of the season

for him to play himself into the 1st team action is very good.

I would say he has done very well compared to expectations
 
steve82

steve82

Well-Known Member
ccfcway said:
Pont was behind.....

McNulty, Beavon, Thomas, Biamou, Andreu and Nazon at the start of the season

for him to play himself into the 1st team action is very good.

I would say he has done very well compared to expectations
Click to expand...

I agree he's done very well to get into the 1st team and his work in the u18's and 21's this season has been excellent.

However how much of his involvement in the 1st team is down to the poor form of those ahead of him and the sides inability to score in games giving Robins no choice but to play him in the hope of him solving the huge issue that's plagued us in too many games by replicating his form in the development sides after growing pressure from the stands.
 
letsallsingtogether

letsallsingtogether

Well-Known Member
The scores are someone' opinion that' all.
I got plenty of D's and F's in my own reports, didn' stop me though:)
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
shmmeee said:
Stepped up to U23 and first team football and scored goals while doing it?

More to the point, what more are you expecting from a teenager?
Click to expand...

That's all well and good, but it doesn't make him the player of the season just yet.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Top