Brad Collins (13 Viewers)

Nuskyblue

Well-Known Member
Simon Moore, in that second season up, is by far the best keeper we've had since promotion.
First half or two thirds, he was ropey at the end and as bad as Collins has been this season.

Colins has also regressed, maybe it's coaching?
 

hinckley cov

Well-Known Member
I've never been a fan of Collins.
But he's nowhere near the level now that he was when he replaced Wilson.

Im genuinely bemused by people defending him
He's costing us goals on analyst weekly basis.

If Wilson died in his sleep, I'd still put his lifeless body on the goal line and back it to be more effective than Collins!
He’s letting in shots that an amateur would be disappointed with , we are not being harsh, most of them were run of the mill saves and I can’t see him recovering from this he’s finished at cov .
 

The Philosopher

Well-Known Member
First half or two thirds, he was ropey at the end and as bad as Collins has been this season.

Colins has also regressed, maybe it's coaching?
Interesting point that.

Oggy was goalkeeping coach forever and a day and (look, we all love him to bits) but I’m struggling to recall a keeper he progressed. Kirkland maybe? Westwood came in as a good keeper and left the same level.

Don’t know much about Aled Williams.

Maybe Frank will get Peter Cech to stop messing about on an ice rink.
 

SBT

Well-Known Member
First half or two thirds, he was ropey at the end and as bad as Collins has been this season.
Moore was nowhere near as bad as Collins has been playing and is now a regular backup for a team sitting above us in the league. While there were supposedly personal issues at play, I still maintain we got rid of him too quickly.
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Moore was nowhere near as bad as Collins has been playing and is now a regular backup for a team sitting above us in the league. While there were supposedly personal issues at play, I still maintain we got rid of him too quickly.
I think the player himself needed to move on in Moore’s case.
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
That 'highlights' reel is astonishing.

I don't know how anyone (yes that includes you Frank!) can look at that and think it's worse persisting with Collins over Wilson.
 

no_loyalty

Well-Known Member


he‘s made a couple of mistakes what keeper doesn’t, but everything that’s at him you’d expect him to save he saves, no brainer surely ?

Wilson is rapid getting down to make the save compared to Collins who dives after the ball is past him on occasions, it just looks comical.
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
If it was up to me, Wilson would never have played for the club again after Cardiff away last season.

It was beyond pathetic.

There’s a reason several managers have dropped him and he’s had one season of first team football in his whole career.
Neither of them are good enough. But the reality is, one of them’s shot to pieces and the other deals better with errors and pressure. That’s all it comes down to at this point.
 

PVA

Well-Known Member


he‘s made a couple of mistakes what keeper doesn’t, but everything that’s at him you’d expect him to save he saves, no brainer surely ?


Some of those are routine, but there's quite a few brilliant saves in there that Collins just isn't capable of.

So if you've got the choice of:

A - liable to chuck one in his own net and let's in every other shot he faces
B - liable to chuck one in his own net but capable of some good saves


Then it's a no brainer by default.
 

chiefdave

Well-Known Member
Oggy was goalkeeping coach forever and a day and (look, we all love him to bits) but I’m struggling to recall a keeper he progressed. Kirkland maybe? Westwood came in as a good keeper and left the same level.

Don’t know much about Aled Williams.

Maybe Frank will get Peter Cech to stop messing about on an ice rink.
Players not getting better is one thing but we've had two keepers in quick succession who appear to have completely fallen apart.

One you could put down as just one of those things or something external but can't be often a club has had it happen to two keepers in a row. Both of whom were bought to be the first choice.
 

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
In the hall of unreliable goalkeeping fame, where does he sit? We've had some whoppers over the years. Burge, Debec, Dimi, the legend that is Eric McManus (one for the kidz), Nuzzo, Ireland. There's quite a competition for the title.
I've long held Nuzzo as my worst goalkeeper from memory. It was only one game though.

I am considering whether Collins is taking that top spot though.
 

Nuskyblue

Well-Known Member
Moore was nowhere near as bad as Collins has been playing and is now a regular backup for a team sitting above us in the league. While there were supposedly personal issues at play, I still maintain we got rid of him too quickly.
I forgot about the personal issues tbf. He still stunk the place out though admittedly over a shorter time period. Hull Away sticks in my memory.
 

SwanLane

Well-Known Member
Has anyone checked Collins’ betting activity?

Just a joke (I think)

On a serious note, once a keeper gets spooked, it can take a year or two to recover any kind of confidence. (E.g.Leighton, Karius) I hope he’s ok and can rebuild his career (as long as he’s not chucking matches) but he just shouldn’t be in goal for us.
 

Robinshio

Well-Known Member
wilson is very poor on 1 v 1 and that is the issue
when a player is through on goal, wilson stands to the side giving an easy tap in
I would even go with Bell at this point
 

Cool Cory

New Member
I consider Wilson to be much better than Collins. Collins has had too many opportunities and has failed to proove he has what it takes to play regularly for us.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top