Transfer Rumour Brandon Thomas-Asante (2 Viewers)

mmttww

Well-Known Member
Just feels expensive @£2-3m.

I seriously doubt you'd get someone who got 11 goals in this league in a dull as sh*t side for any less than that.

Factor in we're probably succession planning; someone to develop in case Simms or Wright are sold.

Brentford and Brighton have that side of it nailed esp. Brighton. Next one ready before the sale rather than after.
 

skybluecam

Well-Known Member
I thought that was cheap?

Think what our fans would have wanted for O'Hare if he wasn't out of contract? O'Hare is a year older, played slightly less games, yet BTA has scored double the amount of goals to O'Hare.
Just a nonsensical comparison. BTA is a striker, O'Hare isn't.
 

skybluecam

Well-Known Member
I seriously doubt you'd get someone who got 11 goals in this league in a dull as sh*t side for any less than that.

Factor in we're probably succession planning; someone to develop in case Simms or Wright are sold.

Brentford and Brighton have that side of it nailed esp. Brighton. Next one ready before the sale rather than after.
That's also my point. Would I be happy if Simms and Wright are sold next summer and BTA is our #1 striker for 25/26? Not on the evidence of his last couple of seasons.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Simms was £3.5m + add ons, not 8. Wright was £7.7m

Just not sure we needed to spend £2-3m on an average championship striker. Could have been a bit more adventurous in the market.
BTA apparently isn’t 2-3m upfront. For consistency, I’ve used all the top end values. Bearing in mind we signed Godden for £750k in the same window Pompey signed Marquis for £2.5m, that should provide some context.

BTW scored 11 goals, plays across the front 3 and comparing those league goals to Wright (16) and Simms (13) - you’re not getting much value for money imo.
 

junglej13

Well-Known Member
WBA may have accepted a bid from Hull, but the player himself has to want to go and agree personal terms. We've been talking to him for a long time now, I don't believe Hull was ever in his mind. Goes to show that creating good relationships with potential signings can give you the edge when it comes to the business being done. Recruitment team doing a great job imo.
Used to be called tapping up in old money! I'm all for it!
 

SleepyGinger

Well-Known Member
WBA may have accepted a bid from Hull, but the player himself has to want to go and agree personal terms. We've been talking to him for a long time now, I don't believe Hull was ever in his mind. Goes to show that creating good relationships with potential signings can give you the edge when it comes to the business being done. Recruitment team doing a great job imo.
Any more snippets Jimmy?
 

mmttww

Well-Known Member
Would I be happy if Simms and Wright are sold next summer and BTA is our #1 striker for 25/26? Not on the evidence of his last couple of seasons.

Come on, what evidence is there that we'd sell both and not buy anyone else? I'm talking about having someone who could step up if one player is sold. Don't move the goalposts. It's cheating.

Some very well run clubs have players around who they develop ready for a bigger role if needed. If they cut it, job done. If they don't, you go to the market and they stay as role players.
 

skybluecam

Well-Known Member
Come on, what evidence is there that we'd sell both and not buy anyone else? I'm talking about having someone who could step up if one player is sold. Don't move the goalposts. It's cheating.

Some very well run clubs have players around who they develop ready for a bigger role if needed. If they cut it, job done. If they don't, you go to the market and they stay as role players.
That’s what you just said? Succession planning for Wright/Simms?
 

Alkhen

Well-Known Member

But I got a Philip Larkin joke in first.

Angry Season 3 GIF by SuccessionHBO

Here's Phillip Larkin's take:

In Hull's grey heart, the faithful wait,
Their hopes pinned on a distant dream,
But fate, that cruel mistress, seals their fate,
And leaves them stranded by a cold, grey stream.

Brandon Thomas-Asante, swift and bright,
Promised to be the star we've longed to see,
Yet Sky Blue shirts, a siren's blight,
Lured him away, and left us in dismay.

The Tigers' roar now muted, soft and low,
In pubs and bars, our pints a bitter toast,
To what might have been, to dreams aglow,
Now shattered, left to haunt us like a ghost.

Hull, crowned with culture's fleeting grace,
Now feels the sting of yet another blow,
Each jilt, each loss, another harsh embrace,
Another striker gone, despair to show.

The pitch, once green with possibility,
Now seems a field of sorrow, lined with loss,
Each pass, each goal, a painful parody,
Of dreams deferred, now covered in a moss.

Yet still we stand, the faithful, every game,
Our hearts worn down by yet another blow,
For Hull's the place where hope and heartache claim,
Their due, in equal measure, as we know.

So here's to Brandon, gone to Sky Blue shores,
May Coventry bring all he hoped to find,
While here in Hull, we'll chant, our throats now hoarse,
And dream of days when fate will change her mind.
 

procdoc

Well-Known Member
Here's Phillip Larkin's take:

In Hull's grey heart, the faithful wait,
Their hopes pinned on a distant dream,
But fate, that cruel mistress, seals their fate,
And leaves them stranded by a cold, grey stream.

Brandon Thomas-Asante, swift and bright,
Promised to be the star we've longed to see,
Yet Sky Blue shirts, a siren's blight,
Lured him away, and left us in dismay.

The Tigers' roar now muted, soft and low,
In pubs and bars, our pints a bitter toast,
To what might have been, to dreams aglow,
Now shattered, left to haunt us like a ghost.

Hull, crowned with culture's fleeting grace,
Now feels the sting of yet another blow,
Each jilt, each loss, another harsh embrace,
Another striker gone, despair to show.

The pitch, once green with possibility,
Now seems a field of sorrow, lined with loss,
Each pass, each goal, a painful parody,
Of dreams deferred, now covered in a moss.

Yet still we stand, the faithful, every game,
Our hearts worn down by yet another blow,
For Hull's the place where hope and heartache claim,
Their due, in equal measure, as we know.

So here's to Brandon, gone to Sky Blue shores,
May Coventry bring all he hoped to find,
While here in Hull, we'll chant, our throats now hoarse,
And dream of days when fate will change her mind.
Chat GPT has a lot to answer for
 

Deity

Well-Known Member
Can we please stop with the bullshit about fees when talking about selection , it has absolutely no relevance to form or fitness or managers ideas regarding the team

Jeez
It shouldn’t but it does …..

If a club pays big money for a player the manager is under pressure to give them the minutes to find their form….

I’m not saying Robins is easily swayed but it’s wrong to suggest that managers don’t come under pressure from owners and DofF’s to play major signings …..
 

Perennial Lurker

Well-Known Member
It shouldn’t but it does …..

If a club pays big money for a player the manager is under pressure to give them the minutes to find their form….

I’m not saying Robins is easily swayed but it’s wrong to suggest that managers don’t come under pressure from owners and DofF’s to play major signings …..
Nonsense !
If we have a squad full of players who we've paid fees for then an owner like Doug will trust Robins and his team with selection .
You seriously think Robins and his coaching team will determine one player over another based on how much they cost and not fitness and performance data then you are deluded
 

Brylowes

Well-Known Member
That's also my point. Would I be happy if Simms and Wright are sold next summer and BTA is our #1 striker for 25/26? Not on the evidence of his last couple of seasons.
Have we signed BTA to spearhead our attack ?…..No.

If we were to sell Simms & Wright next summer, would we be likely to replace them ?…….Yes.
 

fatso

Well-Known Member
That's also my point. Would I be happy if Simms and Wright are sold next summer and BTA is our #1 striker for 25/26? Not on the evidence of his last couple of seasons.
If Simms and Wright are sold next summer it means they've done well again, and we would get a healthy transfer fee to re-invest.
So BTA would remain a second or third choice striker.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top