Clive Eakin (3 Viewers)

Super Graham Withey · Feb 6, 2025

Gurney needs to go and work for another local BBC station. He's talented but I think him coming back to cover City was a mistake-he's far too emotionally connected to the club and I can see it ending badly here for him-which will be a real shame. It works for Clive because although he has obvious affection for City he can retain some objectivity as his true football love is Tranmere Rovers. I'm surprised that the BBC allow presenters to cover their boyhood clubs, I'm not sure it happens much tbh.

Gynnsthetonic · Feb 6, 2025

Super Graham Withey said:
Gurney needs to go and work for another local BBC station. He's talented but I think him coming back to cover City was a mistake-he's far too emotionally connected to the club and I can see it ending badly here for him-which will be a real shame. It works for Clive because although he has obvious affection for City he can retain some objectivity as his true football love is Tranmere Rovers. I'm surprised that the BBC allow presenters to cover their boyhood clubs, I'm not sure it happens much tbh.

Clive is quite a talented journalist in general if you've ever heard him do a slot on CWR. Music, current affairs and other sports.

Sky_Blue_Daz · Feb 6, 2025

I would like to see some of the fans off the podcast get a bit more involved in the build up to match day. Out of interest what happened to Geoff Foster ?

Nick · Feb 6, 2025

Sky_Blue_Daz said:
I would like to see some of the fans off the podcast get a bit more involved in the build up to match day. Out of interest what happened to Geoff Foster ?

Which podcasts?

pusbccfc · Feb 6, 2025

Nick said:
Which podcasts?

'Fancast' that's on Monday?

Sky_Blue_Daz · Feb 6, 2025

Nick said:
Which podcasts

pusbccfc said:
'Fancast' that's on Monday?

yes that one

baldy · Feb 6, 2025

pusbccfc said:
Don't mind either of them. They do a good job. Oggy too.

They are local radio reporters. They are never going to be world class pundits.

Rob loves the club and has been through difficult mental health problems. I hope he doesn't take all this stick to heart.

I'm sure the poor diddums would be ok & doesn't need you sticking up for him

Balli001 · Feb 6, 2025

baldy said:
I'm sure the poor diddums would be ok & doesn't need you sticking up for him

Nice to see you sympathetic to mental health illnesses

pusbccfc · Feb 6, 2025

baldy said:
I'm sure the poor diddums would be ok & doesn't need you sticking up for him

Oh dear

Terry Gibson's perm · Feb 6, 2025

Gynnsthetonic said:
Clive is quite a talented journalist in general if you've ever heard him do a slot on CWR. Music, current affairs and other sports.

When Clive does the Bears comms he is excellent

chiefdave · Feb 6, 2025

Super Graham Withey said:
Gurney needs to go and work for another local BBC station. He's talented but I think him coming back to cover City was a mistake-he's far too emotionally connected to the club and I can see it ending badly here for him-which will be a real shame. It works for Clive because although he has obvious affection for City he can retain some objectivity as his true football love is Tranmere Rovers. I'm surprised that the BBC allow presenters to cover their boyhood clubs, I'm not sure it happens much tbh.

For years we had people moaning that they wanted Gurney back because Clive wasn't a Cov supporter. Now he's back we've got people moaning he is too passionate and biased because he's a Cov supporter

Grendel · Feb 6, 2025

chiefdave said:
For years we had people moaning that they wanted Gurney back because Clive wasn't a Cov supporter. Now he's back we've got people moaning he is too passionate and biased because he's a Cov supporter

Hardly anyone wanted Gurney back - most are very positive about Eakin and have for some time

baldy · Feb 6, 2025

Balli001 said:
Nice to see you sympathetic to mental health illnesses

ffs how'd you know he even sees these posts criticising him? Stop being dramatic

Balli001 · Feb 6, 2025

baldy said:
ffs how'd you know he even sees these posts criticising him? Stop being dramatic

How do you know he doesn't. You just blindly dismiss mental health on the assumption he wont read it anyway.

SkyBluePower · Feb 6, 2025

Gurney was suspended last season for a sweary rant on a hot mic and was broadcast. If this was a symptom of his issues then it’s terrible for the guy. However he is in danger of doing it again at this rate and he needs to tone it down - his bosses need to be talking to him about it.

Robinshio · Feb 6, 2025

wasnt he involved in some sort of punch up at norwich aswell ?

Diogenes · Feb 6, 2025

Robinshio said:
wasnt he involved in some sort of punch up at norwich aswell ?

This is escalating quickly. Next it will be "Rob disarmed a police officer and baton charged the Norwich end whilst screaming fuck you delia down the mic"

COVKIDSNEVERQUIT · Feb 6, 2025

Super Graham Withey said:
Gurney needs to go and work for another local BBC station. He's talented but I think him coming back to cover City was a mistake-he's far too emotionally connected to the club and I can see it ending badly here for him-which will be a real shame. It works for Clive because although he has obvious affection for City he can retain some objectivity as his true football love is Tranmere Rovers. I'm surprised that the BBC allow presenters to cover their boyhood clubs, I'm not sure it happens much tbh.

If the BBC on the match of the Day can have Ex Leicester players, Newcastle players, Arsenal players and Man City players, making comments about their old team, then we can have Oggy and Rob Gurney.

Alkhen · Feb 6, 2025

Said it on the match thread, we are spoiled to have Clive and Oggy compared to what a lot of other teams have to put up with. Had to watch a Leeds comms stream 1st half last night, they were so dull, monotone and soulless. Clive and Oggy despite a few miss pronunciations bring a tonne of passion and match the flow of the game.

have to agree I'm not a huge Gurney fan, seems quick to sound bitter

Shannerz · Feb 6, 2025

baldy said:
I'm sure the poor diddums would be ok & doesn't need you sticking up for him

You're not a very emotionally mature man, are you, really.

Gynnsthetonic · Feb 6, 2025

Diogenes said:
This is escalating quickly. Next it will be "Rob disarmed a police officer and baton charged the Norwich end whilst screaming fuck you delia down the mic"

Cmon, let's be avin you!

RoboCCFC90 · Feb 6, 2025

Flying Fokker · Feb 6, 2025

Super Graham Withey said:
Gurney needs to go and work for another local BBC station. He's talented but I think him coming back to cover City was a mistake-he's far too emotionally connected to the club and I can see it ending badly here for him-which will be a real shame. It works for Clive because although he has obvious affection for City he can retain some objectivity as his true football love is Tranmere Rovers. I'm surprised that the BBC allow presenters to cover their boyhood clubs, I'm not sure it happens much tbh.

Never really thought that was a problem. Having a partisan reporter has both good and bad qualities.

Robinshio · Feb 6, 2025

Diogenes said:
This is escalating quickly. Next it will be "Rob disarmed a police officer and baton charged the Norwich end whilst screaming fuck you delia down the mic"

there was some sort of incident, he keeps referring to it in commentary

Sick Boy · Feb 6, 2025

I'd genuinely like to have a few pints with Clive. I imagine it'd be in a country pub with him in tweed with a sheep dog in tow.

fernandopartridge · Feb 6, 2025

Sky_Blue_Daz said:
I would like to see some of the fans off the podcast get a bit more involved in the build up to match day. Out of interest what happened to Geoff Foster ?

I think he took early retirement, he'd not been well for a while

AOM · Feb 6, 2025

Sick Boy said:
I'd genuinely like to have a few pints with Clive. I imagine it'd be in a country pub with him in tweed with a sheep dog in tow.

They should commission a TV show just based on Oggy and Clive driving around the country for away day fixtures.
Like Mortimer and Whitehouse: Gone Fishing

Tommo1993 · Feb 6, 2025

Sick Boy said:
I'd genuinely like to have a few pints with Clive. I imagine it'd be in a country pub with him in tweed with a sheep dog in tow.

Country pubs are the bizzle!

Shannerz · Feb 6, 2025

Clive's genuinely one of my favourite sports commentators.

He can be a bit erratic, but he's knowledgeable, engaging, fair, and fun to listen to.

Some of his commentary is iconic.

Sick Boy · Feb 6, 2025

AOM said:
They should commission a TV show just based on Oggy and Clive driving around the country for away day fixtures.
Like Mortimer and Whitehouse: Gone Fishing

Haha, yes!!

robbiekeane · Feb 6, 2025

who was that bloke ages ago we had who couldn’t string a sentence together and just gave his interior ramblings and paused mid sentence as something was about to happen? is that rob gurney? had the paramount + commentary last night sounds like a blessing

not clive i love clive, he’s head and shoulders above any other local commentators.

Martw · Feb 6, 2025

Sky_Blue_Daz said:
I would like to see some of the fans off the podcast get a bit more involved in the build up to match day. Out of interest what happened to Geoff Foster ?

Retired many years ago , I think he had some I’ll health , maybe a stroke?

Earlsdon_Skyblue1 · Feb 6, 2025

I love the CWR team. Whatever we think of them, they surely don't deserve the shit they get on the phone in each week.

There's nothing like seeing us win a game and getting in the car in a great mood, only to put the radio on and want to crash into Blue Ribbon Island 5 minutes later because the third caller in a row has said we played shit, despite not only watching, but after us winning so convincingly.

Sick Boy · Feb 6, 2025

Earlsdon_Skyblue1 said:
I love the CWR team. Whatever we think of them, they surely don't deserve the shit they get on the phone in each week.

There's nothing like seeing us win a game and getting in the car in a great mood, only to put the radio on and want to crash into Blue Ribbon Island 5 minutes later because the third caller in a row has said we played shit, despite not only watching, but after us winning so convincingly.

There are still callers who are salty about Eakin replacing Gurney.

duffer · Feb 6, 2025

Well, personally speaking, I like listening to all three of them. It's just the callers that I tend to switch off!

If it wasn't for CWR, I think I'd have lost all interest in the club years ago, particularly when it decided to go a-wandering.

Each to their own though, obviously.

Clive Eakin (3 Viewers)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency