Ex Player Watch (6 Viewers)

[Sky Blue Harry H]

Or short sighted biased football fans maybe?

 

---

[SkyBlueCRJ]

cant beleieve some of our fans couldnt see his quality just because end product lacking

I think fans saw his quality but come on you can't just ignore his inability to do anything significant in the final third when he's an attacking player. His lack of quality in front of goal was appalling.

 

[covcity4life]

I think fans saw his quality but come on you can't just ignore his inability to do anything significant in the final third when he's an attacking player. His lack of quality in front of goal was appalling.

he was young and we missed him when he went

 

[SkyBlueCRJ]

he was young and we missed him when he went

Did we? Albeit he would've probably been a better inclusion than Cole, but I doubt he would've done much to change our fortunes when he barely scored or assisted during his time with us. He was all flare no bite.

 

[covcity4life]

Did we? Albeit he would've probably been a better inclusion than Cole, but I doubt he would've done much to change our fortunes when he barely scored or assisted during his time with us. He was all flare no bite.

he went and we had a poor 2nd half to season. we defo missed him

i bet you hate luke thomas too right now, hardly scores or assists,completley miss how his pace scares defences and make sus a threat

 

[stevefloyd]

You baiting again Mr 4l? I liked Kent because at worst he occupied opposing defenders the same as Thomas whos pace is frightening and drags at least 2 players towards him maybe the end product isnt there at the minute but his tracking back and tackling is a great help

 

[Nick]

Or short sighted biased football fans maybe?

Ironic really considering you seem to defend incompetent refs to the death for missing things.

 

[SkyBlueCRJ]

he went and we had a poor 2nd half to season. we defo missed him

i bet you hate luke thomas too right now, hardly scores or assists,completley miss how his pace scares defences and make sus a threat

But what evidence could you provide that suggests he would've improved our fortunes during that slump. His lack of end product was exposed at Barnsley, Freiburg and Bristol City after his spell with us, albeit at a higher level, but the principle remains the same he couldn't make a difference. Similarly, you suggest that his end product has been revolutionised but he's only seemed to find form in the SPL during his career to date. Hardly the best standard is it. Probably on par with League One, and he's playing in one of the best sides in that league and he's still only scored 3 goals in 18 games. Players like Kent can scare the opposition until the cows come home but until his still ineffective as he's constantly guilting of gifting the ball away to the opposition by making unnecessary dibbles, or making unnecessary/poor crosses.

Where have I said I hated Thomas? His end product obviously needs work, and clearly you think so as well otherwise you wouldn't have mentioned it.

 

[covcity4life]

But what evidence could you provide that suggests he would've improved our fortunes during that slump. His lack of end product was exposed at Barnsley, Freiburg and Bristol City after his spell with us, albeit at a higher level, but the principle remains the same he couldn't make a difference. Similarly, you suggest that his end product has been revolutionised but he's only seemed to find form in the SPL during his career to date. Hardly the best standard is it. Probably on par with League One, and he's playing in one of the best sides in that league and he's still only scored 3 goals in 18 games. Players like Kent can scare the opposition until the cows come home but until his still ineffective as he's constantly guilting of gifting the ball away to the opposition by making unnecessary dibbles, or making unnecessary/poor crosses.

Where have I said I hated Thomas? His end product obviously needs work, and clearly you think so as well otherwise you wouldn't have mentioned it.

and i want to keep luke thomas, do you?

 

[SkyBlueCRJ]

and i want to keep luke thomas, do you?

I'd like to keep him but do I think he would warrant a start once Jodi Jones returns to full fitness? Then the answer is no, as I think Thomas would be far more effective off the bench when defenders tire in the final 20 minutes. But Derby aren't loaning us their player for him to be a benchwarmer so I doubt we have such a luxury.

 

[covcity4life]

I'd like to keep him but do I think he would warrant a start once Jodi Jones returns to full fitness? Then the answer is no, as I think Thomas would be far more effective off the bench when defenders tire in the final 20 minutes. But Derby aren't loaning us their player for him to be a benchwarmer so I doubt we have such a luxury.

Ok fair enough

I would like to see them both utilised as a test. Move Thomas to left

 

[SkyBlueCRJ]

Ok fair enough

I would like to see them both utilised as a test. Move Thomas to left

We'd be slightly exposed defensively but it would be worth a test.

 

[Nonleagueherewecome]

I think my post has gone over your head, that's exactly my point

Well, if you will utilise the lowest form of wit, I'm not going to miss an open goal, am I?

Insert Cody pun *here*.

 

[mark82]

Kent created space for the other attacking players in the team. He could've made a difference but we'll never know.

 

[Joy Division]

Kent created space for the other attacking players in the team. He could've made a difference but we'll never know.

Shame he failed to find them most of the time though.

 

[Adge]

Ironic really considering you seem to defend incompetent refs to the death for missing things.

Yeah ironic. Rinse and repeat....

 

[ceetee]

What I find ironic is people criticising young kids learning their game for having no end product, but cutting lots of slack for Chaplin who hasn't demonstrated very much end product yet, and has missed more chances than Max Biamou did when he was much maligned

 

[Adge]

What I find ironic is people criticising young kids learning their game for having no end product, but cutting lots of slack for Chaplin who hasn't demonstrated very much end product yet, and has missed more chances than Max Biamou did when he was much maligned

Why? Should they get a free ride then? You’re right about Chaplin though.

 

[Liquid Gold]

McNulty not even making the Reading bench now

 

[Nick]

McNulty not even making the Reading bench now

Need to ask him the old "just got in, how did McNulty do for reading"

 

[fernandopartridge]

What I find ironic is people criticising young kids learning their game for having no end product, but cutting lots of slack for Chaplin who hasn't demonstrated very much end product yet, and has missed more chances than Max Biamou did when he was much maligned

He's a young kid himself you douche

 

[cc84cov]

McNulty not even making the Reading bench now

Just seen that struggling to make the squad now can see him defo going out on loan in Jan...Pompey return maybe

 

[Sky Blue Harry H]

What I find ironic is people criticising young kids learning their game for having no end product, but cutting lots of slack for Chaplin who hasn't demonstrated very much end product yet, and has missed more chances than Max Biamou did when he was much maligned

Goaaalllllll !

 

[covcity4life]

Bring mcnukty back in Jan on loan if possible. Would help all parties involved.

Don't think it means we stuck in past. It could be a bargain that's all.

 

[SlowerThanPlatt]

Bring mcnukty back in Jan on loan if possible. Would help all parties involved.

Don't think it means we stuck in past. It could be a bargain that's all.

Would you drop Chaplin to accommodate him then?

 

[covcity4life]

Would you drop Chaplin to accommodate him then?

Can't say as January is 2.5 months away

It's not about dropping. We play loads of games. Just a rotation option could be huge be it because players tired or playing poor

And if mcnukty gets in starting 11 because he's better then the club will be the ones benefitting

 

[ceetee]

He's a young kid himself you douche

That's a strange response to someone you don't know.
Chaplin has much more experience of EFL football than Kent and Thomas had when they joined us.

 

[Warwickhunt]

got to many add on's to bring him back IMHO, built into the budgets

 

[Cov kid 55]

I'd like to keep him but do I think he would warrant a start once Jodi Jones returns to full fitness? Then the answer is no, as I think Thomas would be far more effective off the bench when defenders tire in the final 20 minutes. But Derby aren't loaning us their player for him to be a benchwarmer so I doubt we have such a luxury.

I understand what your saying, but is there not room for both Thomas and Jones, as we finished last night? I don’t think Jones is near full fitness yet, so Thomas is vital to us, and as with Sterling, I think Thomas will get better and better with more game time. We will miss him if he is recalled.

 

[SkyBlueCRJ]

I understand what your saying, but is there not room for both Thomas and Jones, as we finished last night? I don’t think Jones is near full fitness yet, so Thomas is vital to us, and as with Sterling, I think Thomas will get better and better with more game time. We will miss him if he is recalled.

Exactly, as I reiterated in another thread that having both Jones and Thomas on either flanks would leave us terribly exposed defensively as neither track back particularly well, nor are physically gifted players. Thomas has been integral to the squad as shown from last nights performance, but would I want him to start ahead of Jones come January when Jones is fully fit - which won't be too far off I might add? Then the answer is still no as I believe Jones' final product (when fully fit) is far better than Thomas'.

I agree we would miss him but I think it will come down to a battle between him and Jones for a starting spot because both need game time. Thomas won't be retained if we can't promise Derby that he'll get regular minutes and we can't expect Jones to rot on the bench for the rest of the season. It's still a long way to go until January though so we'll see. But IMO if both are to get regular minutes the formation will have to be changed - but why change it when it's going so well? It's not like it's an impossibility that both players can be on the same pitch but it's certainly food for thought for MR.

 

[larry_david]

I've always been impressed by Thomas and his defensive work ethic. He's always tracking back isn't he?

 

[SBAndy]

I've always been impressed by Thomas and his defensive work ethic. He's always tracking back isn't he?

Yes, as was Jones prior to his injury.

 

[Irish Sky Blue]

I've always been impressed by Thomas and his defensive work ethic. He's always tracking back isn't he?

Agree with this. I think it is one of his main attributes.

 

[Kubrick]

Exactly, as I reiterated in another thread that having both Jones and Thomas on either flanks would leave us terribly exposed defensively as neither track back particularly well, nor are physically gifted players. Thomas has been integral to the squad as shown from last nights performance, but would I want him to start ahead of Jones come January when Jones is fully fit - which won't be too far off I might add? Then the answer is still no as I believe Jones' final product (when fully fit) is far better than Thomas'.

I agree we would miss him but I think it will come down to a battle between him and Jones for a starting spot because both need game time. Thomas won't be retained if we can't promise Derby that he'll get regular minutes and we can't expect Jones to rot on the bench for the rest of the season. It's still a long way to go until January though so we'll see. But IMO if both are to get regular minutes the formation will have to be changed - but why change it when it's going so well? It's not like it's an impossibility that both players can be on the same pitch but it's certainly food for thought for MR.

212 words in this post and no end product.

 

[SkyBlueCRJ]

212 words in this post and no end product.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

What are you struggling with?