Is Dave Hockaday going to be our next manager? (4 Viewers)

Deleted member 5849 · Feb 15, 2015

Hobo said:
No he is trying to rubbish Sillets reputation when he achieved promotion as champions when he was at Hereford, saying his tenure was a complete flop when it wasn't.

Where he is right is there was a suspicion Sillett's best days were behind him by the time he took over at CCFC - he'd also been sacked as coach by Gould, of course. And I think I'm right he only got the gig because Terry Yorath turned it down. Hindsight proves everyone else wrong, but there was certainly a narrative present that asked how could a man sacked as Hereford manager become manager of *us*?!?

It'd be a bit like Steve Tilson rocking up at West Brom as manager - it'd certainly raise more eyebrows nowadays.

Deleted member 5849 · Feb 15, 2015

As an aside, it was around the time of Curtis and Sillett's first pre-season when the Telegraph letters pages had comments as per now in their own way - one fan at least was disappointed we'd not signed Bryan Robson.

Baring in mind we'd just avoided relegation, and Robson was England captain and playing for the richest, most glamorous side in the country, this wasn't overly realistic!

Ambition doesn't have to equal unrealistic expectations...

Now personally I see Hockaday here much as when Harrison came in under Coleman - he's a coach with a track record as coach (no shitting into cups from wardrobes mind you), to support a manager who needs some support.

If Pressley goes he might be caretaker, and depending on results would see if he got the gig (as per Sillett and Curtis keeping us up after Mackay went) but I don't see him as here to replace Pressley, more to help him.

SkyBlue_Bear83 · Feb 15, 2015

Hobo said:
No he is trying to rubbish Sillets reputation when he achieved promotion as champions when he was at Hereford, saying his tenure was a complete flop when it wasn't.

Point still stands, he's saying he would give Hockaday a chance as you never know what will happen even if they aren't a popular choice or have a good reputation at that level. If a premier league club went and appointed Gary Johnson now there would be more than a few raised eye brows.

Similar to what you have said about not knowing what you are getting when you sign anybody.

SkyBlue_Bear83 · Feb 15, 2015

The Lurker said:
FFS - look at hockaday record. Does that inspire a revival? Doesn't for me. But hey you and Grendel love sticking up for sisu so no surprise there

I don't stick up for SISU, I just dare to criticise other groups as well as SISU.

wingy · Feb 15, 2015

I seriously wonder what effect on the players he would have
IMO the requirement usually Is that a fresh appointment who brings the bounce effect to a team Is one who they can have confidence In
Whether he has that I know not

Grendel · Feb 15, 2015

Hobo said:
No he is trying to rubbish Sillets reputation when he achieved promotion as champions when he was at Hereford, saying his tenure was a complete flop when it wasn't.

Utter claptrap. You will find many posts on here from me praising Sillett and the sacking of him being a pivotal moment in our decline.

My point is obvious as others have pointed out. At the time he and Curtis were seen as cheap appointments and signs the club lack ambition. There was no reason a manager who had not worked for 8 years (and by the way had only 4% pts better win ratio at Hereford than hockaday) would succeed. He replaced an equally cheap option and Poynton was massively slated for it.

wingy · Feb 15, 2015

Grendel said:
Utter claptrap. You will find many posts on here from me praising Sillett and the sacking of him being a pivotal moment in our decline.

My point is obvious as others have pointed out. At the time he and Curtis were seen as cheap appointments and signs the club lack ambition. There was no reason a manager who had not worked for 8 years (and by the way had only 4% pts better win ratio at Hereford than hockaday) would succeed. He replaced an equally cheap option and Poynton was massively slated for it.

Agreed largely but surely far more likely to engender goodwill hope and trust through
ones legendary status

The Lurker · Feb 15, 2015

Grendel said:
Utter claptrap. You will find many posts on here from me praising Sillett and the sacking of him being a pivotal moment in our decline.

My point is obvious as others have pointed out. At the time he and Curtis were seen as cheap appointments and signs the club lack ambition. There was no reason a manager who had not worked for 8 years (and by the way had only 4% pts better win ratio at Hereford than hockaday) would succeed. He replaced an equally cheap option and Poynton was massively slated for it.

And for every 1 sillett you get 10 andy thorns. If sisu went down that route again then god help our plight

covboy1987 · Feb 15, 2015

steveecov said:
I'd be more concerned about the similarity to HEREFORD and US than SILLETT and PRESLEY

absolutely bang on with your thoughts - who is managing us is actually secondary as the club seem to be on an uncontrollable nose dive to league 2 and beyond

Chez78 · Feb 15, 2015

Hockaday is great coach and has a good rep for that, his management record is bloody terrible though and he shouldn't be allowed anywhere near the managers seat on anything other than a caretaker basis. Comparing his record to John Sillets is laughable.

There is good managers in both league two and conference level who I'd like to see given the chance I'd just prefer for once we didn't go with a name and actually have a look at their record. To many times we've appointed managers on the back of failure rather than steady performance or recent success.

Grendel · Feb 15, 2015

Chez78 said:
Hockaday is great coach and has a good rep for that, his management record is bloody terrible though and he shouldn't be allowed anywhere near the managers seat on anything other than a caretaker basis. Comparing his record to John Sillets is laughable.

There is good managers in both league two and conference level who I'd like to see given the chance I'd just prefer for once we didn't go with a name and actually have a look at their record. To many times we've appointed managers on the back of failure rather than steady performance or recent success.

I am not comparing it - it is worth pointing out though that when Sillett was appointed CCFC manager his win ratio was less than the current incumbent

rupert_bear · Feb 16, 2015

I can't see any reason for Dave Hockaday to be brought to the club if it isn't to replace Steve Pressley if only until the end of the season. It seems certain to me Pressley didn't appoint him. The next two fixtures could be the watershed in SPs time here, 2 defeats and I am certain he will be let go. I am told SP going will rejuvenate the dressing room, might even help Reda Johnson's injury!

Captain Dart · Feb 16, 2015

rupert_bear said:
I can't see any reason for Dave Hockaday to be brought to the club if it isn't to replace Steve Pressley if only until the end of the season. It seems certain to me Pressley didn't appoint him. The next two fixtures could be the watershed in SPs time here, 2 defeats and I am certain he will be let go. I am told SP going will rejuvenate the dressing room, might even help Reda Johnson's injury!

My gut feeling is that nothing will happen till the close season, whatever the league position. Then if Hockaday succeeds Pressley he will not have the stigma of demotion on his CV.

Gosford Green · Feb 16, 2015

Sillett and Curtis inherited a squad with 6 maybe 7 top quality international class players.

The current bunch and the type of player we now acquire are non league level who even Jose Mourinho would struggle to get results with.

Gazolba · Feb 17, 2015

Personally, I think it's already too late for a new manager to make a difference. I think we are doomed to L2. Sacking SP would just cost us a ton of money and there is no guarantee a new manager would save us. The only option is to keep SP but take away his managership responsibilities.

rupert_bear · Feb 17, 2015

Gazolba said:
Personally, I think it's already too late for a new manager to make a difference. I think we are doomed to L2. Sacking SP would just cost us a ton of money and there is no guarantee a new manager would save us. The only option is to keep SP but take away his managership responsibilities.

It appears Pressley has an eighteen month severency deal built into his contract so that is the bill for getting rid of him or he stays until 2018, probably over £250000, looks like we are stuck with him.

henry the wasp · Feb 17, 2015

Gosford Green said:
Sillett and Curtis inherited a squad with 6 maybe 7 top quality international class players.

The current bunch and the type of player we now acquire are non league level who even Jose Mourinho would struggle to get results with.

6 or 7 top quality international class players? Really?

Brighton Sky Blue · Feb 17, 2015

Gazolba said:
Personally, I think it's already too late for a new manager to make a difference. I think we are doomed to L2. Sacking SP would just cost us a ton of money and there is no guarantee a new manager would save us. The only option is to keep SP but take away his managership responsibilities.

Disagree, his departure would boost morale instantly.

covcity4life · Feb 18, 2015

thomas now praising hockaday

at least the players seem to like him.

Is Dave Hockaday going to be our next manager? (4 Viewers)

Deleted member 5849

Guest

Deleted member 5849

Guest

SkyBlue_Bear83

Well-Known Member

SkyBlue_Bear83

Well-Known Member

wingy

Well-Known Member

Grendel

Well-Known Member

wingy

Well-Known Member

The Lurker

Well-Known Member

covboy1987

Well-Known Member

Chez78

New Member

Grendel

Well-Known Member

rupert_bear

Well-Known Member

Captain Dart

Well-Known Member

Gosford Green

Well-Known Member

Gazolba

Well-Known Member

rupert_bear

Well-Known Member

henry the wasp

Well-Known Member

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member

covcity4life

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Is Dave Hockaday going to be our next manager? (4 Viewers)

Deleted member 5849

Guest

Deleted member 5849

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency