Keepers (8 Viewers)

Earlsdon_Skyblue1

Well-Known Member
Wilson is quite disliked by a corner of the fan base for whatever reason, but I would choose him over Collins any day of the week. He actually has some credit from the golden glove season at least. Collins looks like he is going through a crisis and needs taking straight back out of the team. What happened today is also partly on Kitching, but as a goalkeeper you just cannot be that fragile with six games to go when so much is at stake.
 

JulianDarbyFTW

Well-Known Member
Collins has been poor since he joined. Some liked him early on, but he's always had teflon hands and either makes ludicrous mistakes (reminiscent of Moore when he went to pot) or pushes the ball back into dangerous areas. Wilson makes mistakes too but at least he - and the defenders - know his limitations. No way he wouldn't have thundertwatted that ball today.
 

SkyBlueDom26

Well-Known Member
Collins has been poor since he joined. Some liked him early on, but he's always had teflon hands and either makes ludicrous mistakes (reminiscent of Moore when he went to pot) or pushes the ball back into dangerous areas. Wilson makes mistakes too but at least he - and the defenders - know his limitations. No way he wouldn't have thundertwatted that ball today.
Bell or him have to play next game, if bell is good enough then he can, give him a chance if Wilson ain’t fit. Collins can not play for us again, he will cost us every game
 

chiefdave

Well-Known Member
tbh I feel sorry for him at this point. fuck knows what happened to him but something clearly has.

He has been so bad this season to the point he's a literal meme and the only person who seems unable to see it is Lampard.

I didn't agree with it but at least when he was sat on the bench over Wilson and people were saying Wilson is out of contract at the end of the year so why would they play him there was a reason. Now Wilson has renewed there's zero reason for him not to be playing.
 

SBT

Well-Known Member
He fucked up the first goal and then it was a horrendous mix-up with Kitching for the second. Maybe I’m just too forgiving, but I think you have to see if he can get a grip in the next game and see if he can be the keeper we need him to be with this system. The alternative is punting him off forever and going with your third choice.
 

Chris1987

Well-Known Member
Said in the match day but has to be Wilson next. Just wouldn’t make the two mistakes. If that means we have to drop the high line so be it
So you're suggesting to make up for the replacements shortcomings we change our tactics? Both keepers have major issues but surely its too late now to try and change the system.
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
So you're suggesting to make up for the replacements shortcomings we change our tactics? Both keepers have major issues but surely it’s too late now to try and change the system.
Teaching Collins how to avoid howlers every week is a lost cause. Give it Wilson and hope for the best
 

Sky Blue Goblin

Well-Known Member
So you're suggesting to make up for the replacements shortcomings we change our tactics? Both keepers have major issues but surely it’s too late now to try and change the system.
I mean the system should suit the players first and foremost. We have played with a lower line of engagement and press.

Did it a lot in the 5-3-2 and Robins had his line lower. Just asking us to adapt to what’s happened instead of putting circles into round holes
 

Shannerz

Well-Known Member
tbh I feel sorry for him at this point. fuck knows what happened to him but something clearly has.

He has been so bad this season to the point he's a literal meme and the only person who seems unable to see it is Lampard.

I didn't agree with it but at least when he was sat on the bench over Wilson and people were saying Wilson is out of contract at the end of the year so why would they play him there was a reason. Now Wilson has renewed there's zero reason for him not to be playing.
If you don't pick Wilson over a broken Collins, why extend his contract?

It's so weird.
 

Captain Dart

Well-Known Member
The goalie and whole of the back line looked nervous from the start.
 

bigfatronssba

Well-Known Member
If Collins plays on Wednesday, and makes another mistake, the crowd will turn. People were reasonably forgiving today, but there is a limit.

For his own benefit, he should never play for us again
 

Diogenes

Well-Known Member
Worryingly Joe Edwards seemed to brush off the error as not a big issue. Get backing your players publicly but I really hope this isn't a sign that he will be playing wed.
 

bigfatronssba

Well-Known Member
Worryingly Joe Edwards seemed to brush off the error as not a big issue. Get backing your players publicly but I really hope this isn't a sign that he will be playing wed.

I honestly don’t see how he can play on Wednesday
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top