Player Ratings (3 Viewers)

play_in_skyblue_stripes · Nov 20, 2021

At the match today. I don't think I can give individual ratings, just observations and point out good performers.

Central defence and Moore very good. MOM for me was Sheaf. Strange substitutions that made us less effective. Overall both sides could claim that game was there for the taking.
A point is fine. We are a very decent team in a hard league. A bit lucky to hang on in the end, we could have won it earlier though for sure.

Grendel · Nov 20, 2021

play_in_skyblue_stripes said:
At the match today. I don't think I can give individual ratings, just observations and point out good performers.

Central defence and Moore very good. MOM for me was Sheaf. Strange substitutions that made us less effective. Overall both sides could claim that game was there for the taking.
A point is fine. We are a very decent team in a hard league. A bit lucky to hang on in the end, we could have won it earlier though for sure.

I didn’t think Hyam and Rose were that great and it was them bringing on mcgoldrick that changed momentum - we struggled at that point on

wingy · Nov 20, 2021

rob9872 said:
Mostly agree with that but think a bit harsh scoring Hyam lower, I'd give him 7 too.

Hamer was controlling the middle but I was concerned for him and think it should've been a straight swap with Kelly leaving the extra man in the middle. Front subs offered nothing should've been for last 10 not last 30. Robins had it spot on tactically until he changed it.

Damned if he's does, damned if he doesn't really.
So often knocked for not being proactive or tardy with substitutions.
I'd also have only made the one change but we got the result the previous 60 mins projected.

WestEndAgro · Nov 20, 2021

Sheaf was excellent as was Moore and Fadz, the rest average

CDK · Nov 20, 2021

The mcgoldrick substitution added to bringing godden ,walker on did change the last quarter of the game to there advantage.
I think we should play the box away from home a lot more as we look very good at the system.

Hobo · Nov 20, 2021

Grendel said:
It’s the same with many fans here. Look like you put a shift in and you are ok.
Effort (or perceived effort) over ability is the way

Every team needs a mix of both -sublime and ugly. But every really top class side has effort all the way through the side. Top class sides graft for each other full stop. The sublime bits just make the highlights package.

larry_david · Nov 20, 2021

Sheaf and hamer both good today. I don't particularly get the hamer hype, but today I saw it!

Question: why isn't o hare smashing that in for the dive/pen. Haven't seen it back but in real time he surely needs to just shoot

GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee · Nov 20, 2021

McFadzean is such an asset. Every week I say “Fadz is an 8/10 unless he’s a 1/10”, and those 1/10 games have been probably 2 or 3 in his entire time here. Such a good signing. I always think he’s gonna start declining due to age, and he continues to deliver. Will be hugely missed. Best centre back we’ve have had in a long time. Sheaf was superb. Moore made some crucial stops. Kane’s delivery is so threatening. Interesting choices at full back Tuesday. Robins misjudged the subs, very rare for him to get it quite so wrong. Still came away with a point. On to blues.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Hobo · Nov 20, 2021

GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee said:
McFadzean is such an asset. Every week I say “Fadz is an 8/10 unless he’s a 1/10, and those 1/10 games have been probably 2 or 3 in his entire time here. Such a good signing. I always think he’s gonna start declining due to age, and he continues to deliver. Will be hugely missed. Best centre back we’ve have had in a long time. Sheaf was superb. Moore made some crucial stops. Kane’s delivery is so threatening. Interesting choices at full back Tuesday. Robins misjudged the subs, very rare for him to get it quite so wrong. Still came away with a point. On to blues.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I agree. Always been a McFadz fan right from the get go. But there are chinks appearing - main one pace. We need to source a replacement going forward. At the age where the legs will go before the heart and passion.

the rumpo kid · Nov 20, 2021

Sky Blue Pete said:
Thought Kane was excellent but then so was Dabo. Fabulous goal saving header

I know what your saying :- Kane. V dabo. Both really good attacking full backs. Just a pity they' both want to play the same side.
I thought dabs was showing his displeasure ( fancy Dan ) today by doing the minimum without letting the team down.

Of course he wanted us to win but I'm sure he's not happy being pushed over to the left.
Think Kane is good, but never never under estimate dabo. Top mam.

Sky Blue Pete · Nov 20, 2021

CDK said:
The mcgoldrick substitution added to bringing godden ,walker on did change the last quarter of the game to there advantage.
I think we should play the box away from home a lot more as we look very good at the system.

But impotent

Deleted member 9744 · Nov 20, 2021

the rumpo kid said:
I know what your saying :- Kane. V dabo. Both really good attacking full backs. Just a pity they' both want to play the same side.
I thought dabs was showing his displeasure ( fancy Dan ) today by doing the minimum without letting the team down.

Of course he wanted us to win but I'm sure he's not happy being pushed over to the left.
Think Kane is good, but never never under estimate dabo. Top mam.

Yes that crucial block header showed to me that he was doing the minimum too. As well as those runs all match.

the rumpo kid · Nov 20, 2021

Deleted member 9744 said:
Yes that crucial block header showed to me that he was doing the minimum too. As well as those runs all match.

Just don't think he's happy playing on the left. As I said he would never do anything to let his team mates or supporters down. I love the guy just want him to be comfortable in his role
He is such a good player .

PUSB-We_are_going_up · Nov 20, 2021

Nick said:
Moore and McFadz Immense.

OHare summed up by his dive and awful shot.

Wrong subs made, instantly changed the game when Gyo went off. Allen should have gone off for Kelly.

O’hare didnt dive….there was no board or water

robbiekeane · Nov 21, 2021

the rumpo kid said:
Just don't think he's happy playing on the left. As I said he would never do anything to let his team mates or supporters down. I love the guy just want him to be comfortable in his role
He is such a good player .

What are you on about

Sky Blue Pete · Nov 21, 2021

One cross from Dabo where Allen had a great chance and we should have had a pen was magnificent

Londonccfcfan · Nov 21, 2021

CDK said:
The mcgoldrick substitution added to bringing godden ,walker on did change the last quarter of the game to there advantage.
I think we should play the box away from home a lot more as we look very good at the system.

Anybody whos seen any of our away games would concurr with that. Just cannot, completely over run in midfield as soon as extra midfielder went off.

We were in control and limited them to Nothing with the box and just Gyro upfront.

Sky Blue Pete · Nov 21, 2021

Londonccfcfan said:
Anybody whos seen any of our away games would concurr with that. Just cannot, completely over run in midfield as soon as extra midfielder went off.

We were in control and limited them to Nothing with the box and just Gyro upfront.

But didn’t look like scoring

Londonccfcfan · Nov 21, 2021

Sky Blue Pete said:
One cross from Dabo where Allen had a great chance and we should have had a pen was magnificent

After the ridiculous substitutions we created nothing. Couldnt string 2 passes together.

If it isnt broke it dont need fixing. Boy did we get out of jail that last 25 mins.

Londonccfcfan · Nov 21, 2021

Sky Blue Pete said:
But didn’t look like scoring

Erm we created nothing after that. We had chances to win and limited them to nothing before substitutions.

Were you not watching?

Another 10-15 mins of them not creating nothing and the crowd would have git on their back. Fucking abysmal tactics.

Londonccfcfan · Nov 21, 2021

Felt like we were playing with 9 men after the substitutions. Same thing happened at QPR but we lost as soon Walker/Godden come on. We were in complete control until Gyro went off. Waghorn played a bit deeper that game.

Perryccfc · Nov 21, 2021

Just watched the game again, this time with no emotion. Kane and Sheaf were both exceptional.

Sky Blue Pete · Nov 21, 2021

Perryccfc said:
Just watched the game again, this time with no emotion. Kane and Sheaf we’re both exceptional.

Which one are you?

Sky Blue Pete · Nov 21, 2021

Londonccfcfan said:
Erm we created nothing after that. We had chances to win and limited them to nothing before substitutions.

Were you not watching?

Another 10-15 mins of them not creating nothing and the crowd would have git on their back. Fucking abysmal tactics.

Yep we were worse after the changes but we didn’t look like scoring before. I don’t think he’ll try that again with the same players. It should have worked better than it did and it didn’t

Reppz · Nov 21, 2021

Baffled at the lack of mentions of Sheaf here. He was our best player by a country mile (especially in the first half). He is criminally underrated.

wingy · Nov 21, 2021

Londonccfcfan said:
After the ridiculous substitutions we created nothing. Couldnt string 2 passes together.

If it isnt broke it dont need fixing. Boy did we get out of jail that last 25 mins.

This is nonesense.
He tried a different avenue which is often demanded on here and we didn't lose from it .

Hindsight.

Perryccfc · Nov 21, 2021

wingy said:
This is nonesense.
He tried a different avenue which is often demanded on here and we didn't lose from it .

Hindsight.

Exactly. If he didn’t make the changes he would have been criticised for not going for the win.

Brighton Sky Blue · Nov 21, 2021

wingy said:
This is nonesense.
He tried a different avenue which is often demanded on here and we didn't lose from it .

Hindsight.

Not sure he means the shape Wingy, Gyo going off combined with taking a man out of midfield was likely to give us less control of the ball and as it turned out we couldn’t really get out of our half. Allen staying on instead of Sheaf also seemed a bit curious given how both were faring at the time.

pusbccfc · Nov 21, 2021

I'd certainly start Kane Tuesday and look at Maatsen as an option if the game is stretched in the second half.

Terry_dactyl · Nov 21, 2021

Brighton Sky Blue said:
Not sure he means the shape Wingy, Gyo going off combined with taking a man out of midfield was likely to give us less control of the ball and as it turned out we couldn’t really get out of our half. Allen staying on instead of Sheaf also seemed a bit curious given how both were faring at the time.

I assumed Sheaf and Gyo were tired. No other reason to take off our two best players on the day.
I thought at the time it was a strange formation change…that their change of formation hadn’t done anything to improve them, and that as the game wore on we were likely to find more space upfront as a consequence.

Brighton Sky Blue · Nov 21, 2021

Terry_dactyl said:
I assumed Sheaf and Gyo were tired. No other reason to take off our two best players on the day.
I thought at the time it was a strange formation change…that their change of formation hadn’t done anything to improve them, and that as the game wore on we were likely to find more space upfront as a consequence.

Neither of them looked tired for me, and they’ve just had 2 weeks’ break. We defended pretty heroically at the end, which we likely wouldn’t have managed last season-so that’s good. Just feel the combination of changes left us with nobody to hold the ball up at the front and one less man to compete in midfield.

First half it was a model away performance just missing the final cutting edge. We should persist with it but really work on the play in the final third.

FulltimeWum · Nov 21, 2021

Hobo said:
I agree. Always been a McFadz fan right from the get go. But there are chinks appearing - main one pace. We need to source a replacement going forward. At the age where the legs will go before the heart and passion.

He was playing for the other team. Basham.

Perryccfc · Nov 21, 2021

What a graphic this is…

pusbccfc · Nov 21, 2021

Terry_dactyl said:
I assumed Sheaf and Gyo were tired. No other reason to take off our two best players on the day.
I thought at the time it was a strange formation change…that their change of formation hadn’t done anything to improve them, and that as the game wore on we were likely to find more space upfront as a consequence.

With an eye on Tuesday I think.

TomRad85 · Nov 21, 2021

FulltimeWum said:
He was playing for the other team. Basham.

Basham is only 1 year younger

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

Player Ratings (3 Viewers)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 9744

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Attachments

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency