RATINGS FOLKS v West Ham (2 Viewers)

johnniericoh · Nov 19, 2011

Best game of the season

Murphy 7
Christie 7
Keogh 9
Cranie 7
Hussey 8
Clingan 8
McSheffrey 7
Gael 7
Thomas 8
Platt 8
Juke 7

Subs

Baker 6
Wood 6

MOM

Keogh - awesome

PUSB

SkyBlue · Nov 19, 2011

Joe Murphy 7
Cyrus Christie 6
Richard Keogh 9
Martin Cranie 7
Chris Hussey 7
Sammy Clingan 8
Gael Bigirimana 6
Conor Thomas 8/9
Clive Platt 7
Lukas Jutkiewicz 7

Subs

Carl Baker 7
Richard Wood 6

MOM - Keogh

Andy Thorn 7

Lord_Nampil · Nov 19, 2011

Best game we played Conor and gael will only get better!! Platt for me was immense!! We have t Got a bad side, not no self belief, and that's on and off the pitch!!! With Clarke nearly bk as well we haven't got a bad set up, just need wins to boost the confidence! All ratings for me are a 7 part from Conor Platt and Keogh who get an 8!

skybluesteve76 · Nov 19, 2011

Murphy 7
Christie 6
Keogh 9
Cranie 6
Bigi 7
Thomas 6
Clingan 7
Sheff 7
Platt 7
Juke 7

Nonleagueherewecome · Nov 19, 2011

Murphy-6
Christie-6
Keogh-9
Cranie-7
Hussey-10
Clingan-8
Thomas-7
Gael-8
McSheffrey-8
Platt-7
Lukas-7

Subs:
Wood-6
Baker-7

Best left-back performance by a City player since we had Fox. Marcus never delivered a performance that good in his whole career! Gael was immense first half and Sammy only gets a 8 instead of a 9 because he failed to spot McSheffreys superb run in the first half. Christie would have been a 7 or even 8 for the first half, but was truly dreadful in the second-if unlucky for the 2nd goal. Possibly Keoghs best performance for us, and against the club he supports. Beckenbauer and Adams rolled into one. But he'll be off at Xmas

Nonleagueherewecome · Nov 19, 2011

skybluesteve76 said:
Murphy 7
Christie 6
Keogh 9
Cranie 6
Bigi 7
Thomas 6
Clingan 7
Sheff 7
Platt 7
Juke 7

You missed out the best player on the pitch...and Murphy was OK too!

covcity4life · Nov 19, 2011

Murphy 7
Christie 7
Keogh 9
Cranie 7
hussey 7
Bigi 7
Thomas 6
Clingan 9
Sheff 6
Platt 7
Juke 6

thought bakers dribbling was great when he came on too,hope he gets his confidence back

stupot07 · Nov 19, 2011

How can anyone rate any of our player less that a 7 today is beyond me. A couple of 6's for Thomas? Your having a laugh, he played really well today.

MatthewWallis · Nov 19, 2011

covcity4life said:
Murphy 7
Christie 7
Keogh 9
Cranie 7
hussey 7
Bigi 7
Thomas 6
Clingan 9
Sheff 6
Platt 7
Juke 6

thought bakers dribbling was great when he came on too,hope he gets his confidence back

Thomas was much more than a 6 today, at least an 8, possible MOTM for me

Nonleagueherewecome · Nov 19, 2011

covcity4life said:
Murphy 7
Christie 7
Keogh 9
Cranie 7
hussey 7
Bigi 7
Thomas 6
Clingan 9
Sheff 6
Platt 7
Juke 6

thought bakers dribbling was great when he came on too,hope he gets his confidence back

Agreed, it was a quality cameo performance. Back to his dribbling best, and one deflected ball near the end almost fell for him in the same position as the Derby goal. I often think he's most effective as an impact sub.

Nonleagueherewecome · Nov 19, 2011

MatthewWallis said:
Thomas was much more than a 6 today, at least an 8, possible MOTM for me

He did some really good things-some great passes and a great tackle- but gave the ball away a fair few times as well. He also fails to attack the space in front of him or make forward runs off the ball. He didn't help Cyrus enough 2nd half or close down the WH LB, who had all the time in the world to hoof it up to Cole 2nd half.

wingy · Nov 19, 2011

Thought he waas more effective than Bgi todayNLHWC ,felt bigi suffered from the lack of physical presence today ,he must become more creative than the simple sideways.must remember including Cyrus thy're all boys.

skybluegod · Nov 19, 2011

Murphy 7=came to get crosses looked good for the game!
Christie 7= good croos for goal had a part to play for there goals but he's youg and learning!
Keogh 8=played well made some great challenges and is a key player for us!
Cranie 7=had an alright came not his best but still good!
hussey 8= made some great challenges and is a great player made some good crosses and his positioning was top notch!
Bigi 8= had a great games made some good runs and looked solid even after his suspension and seems to have learned making a very good one footed slide tackle in first half!
Thomas 8= best game he's had for us by a mile i think great game good passing some top tackles and nice dribbling! (proved me wrong)
Clingan 8=had a good game some good crosses and tackles but not the best player today but still top match and hope he stays!
Sheff 8=i think he's back had a great game made some great runs good passing and vision and never stoped trying but shooting mayby need a bit of work!
Platt 9=well took goal easily best partner for juke and is my MOM for today and i hope he keeps his spot such a big presence and closed down well!
Juke 7=game seemed to pass him today and was quiet for long parts great volley making green pull of a good stop and good hold up play!

Baker 7= some neat dribbles and passing didn't put a foot wrong for the 15mins he was on but not enough to judge
wood 6= didn't do much came on to late !

stupot07 · Nov 19, 2011

Nonleagueherewecome said:
He did some really good things-some great passes and a great tackle- but gave the ball away a fair few times as well. He also fails to attack the space in front of him or make forward runs off the ball. He didn't help Cyrus enough 2nd half or close down the WH LB, who had all the time in the world to hoof it up to Cole 2nd half.

How many times did bigi give the ball away? Thomas worked his nuts off, kept the ball ticking over, put in lots of challenges and covered in at right back every time Christies went forward. He also started to make a few forward runs in the last 20 mins.

Again what did bigi do that Thomas didn't? I get the feeling fans don't understand what Thomas brings to the team but are blinded by Bigi's flamboyance.

wingy · Nov 19, 2011

I concur with the above skybluegod,exactly how isaw it.

stupot07 · Nov 19, 2011

skybluegod said:
Murphy 7=came to get crosses looked good for the game!
Christie 7= good croos for goal had a part to play for there goals but he's youg and learning!
Keogh 8=played well made some great challenges and is a key player for us!
Cranie 7=had an alright came not his best but still good!
hussey 8= made some great challenges and is a great player made some good crosses and his positioning was top notch!
Bigi 8= had a great games made some good runs and looked solid even after his suspension and seems to have learned making a very good one footed slide tackle in first half!
Thomas 8= best game he's had for us by a mile i think great game good passing some top tackles and nice dribbling! (proved me wrong)
Clingan 8=had a good game some good crosses and tackles but not the best player today but still top match and hope he stays!
Sheff 8=i think he's back had a great game made some great runs good passing and vision and never stoped trying but shooting mayby need a bit of work!
Platt 9=well took goal easily best partner for juke and is my MOM for today and i hope he keeps his spot such a big presence and closed down well!
Juke 7=game seemed to pass him today and was quiet for long parts great volley making green pull of a good stop and good hold up play!

Baker 7= some neat dribbles and passing didn't put a foot wrong for the 15mins he was on but not enough to judge
wood 6= didn't do much came on to late !

That is about spot on IMO.

Nonleagueherewecome · Nov 19, 2011

wingy said:
Thought he waas more effective than Bgi todayNLHWC ,felt bigi suffered from the lack of physical presence today ,he must become more creative than the simple sideways.must remember including Cyrus thy're all boys.

Beg to differ on this one; Gael was superb, closing down at pace all over the pitch, played some fantastic passes, movement was immense and speed of thought fantastic. Yes he got tacled a few times when trying to work some magic in tight situations, he faded a bit 2nd half (1st game in weeks so that's inevitable), and he has probably yet to win a header in his career. But the good things that he did were so good, that massively outweighs those minor blemishes. Not quite as good as he was 1st half against Burnley, but he is now looking like a future top 4 Prem club player in the making to my eyes, and against the 2nd best side in the Championship, not just Nuneaton or Leam!

Nonleagueherewecome · Nov 19, 2011

stupot07 said:
How many times did bigi give the ball away? Thomas worked his nuts off, kept the ball ticking over, put in lots of challenges and covered in at right back every time Christies went forward. He also started to make a few forward runs in the last 20 mins.

Again what did bigi do that Thomas didn't? I get the feeling fans don't understand what Thomas brings to the team but are blinded by Bigi's flamboyance.

About 4? Mostly by taking too long when he had the ball to make a decision, and he isn't great at tracking the man in his own half. I don't think he plays the role as well as Gael, I'm not an obsessive Gael fan-boy..and hang on, I gave Connor a 7! He did some good stuff, I wasn't having a go!

pusbccfc · Nov 19, 2011

I think gael has better ball control and has more skill on the ball, thomas has more physical presents, but I think other than that the passing and speed are both similar.

stupot07 · Nov 19, 2011

Nonleagueherewecome said:
About 4? Mostly by taking too long when he had the ball to make a decision, and he isn't great at tracking the man in his own half. I don't think he plays the role as well as Gael, I'm not an obsessive Gael fan-boy..and hang on, I gave Connor a 7! He did some good stuff, I wasn't having a go!

Sorry nonleague wasn't getting at you, it was the one's that gave him a 6's.

wingy · Nov 19, 2011

They're both great assets inour future if wekeep them.

covcity4life · Nov 19, 2011

i thought thomas played well,hes a bit like carrick,keeps midfield ticking over,he grew into the game strength wise too

i only gave him a 6 because he wasnt quite as good as brigi today,call it a 7 if you want,either way i thought we played very well

Pigeon · Nov 19, 2011

Keogh was Mr Reliable as always
Clingan much better than recent weeks
Thomas' best game in a Cov shirt
Hussey much improved
The Juke seemed a bit quite today but did his bit.

stupot07 · Nov 19, 2011

pusbccfc said:
I think gael has better ball control and has more skill on the ball, thomas has more physical presents, but I think other than that the passing and speed are both similar.

I agree, I've said on a previous post a couple of weeks ago that Thomas is the ying to bigi's flamboyant yang. They are both top top prospects and IMO are rightly in the starting line up on their performances.

I just sometimes feel that people expect Thomas to be more like bigi but he's a different type of player.

Nonleagueherewecome · Nov 19, 2011

I would have expected a tad more hyperbole after Hussey's showing today. He was absolute mint; if he didn't have an option to pass to, he skinned Faubert-a 7.5m signing I believe-every single time, and rained in some fantastic crosses. He also defended really well. It was pretty much the complete performance for a full back.

SkyBlue_Bear83 · Nov 19, 2011

Murphy -7- claimed some crosses well, good distribution and couldn't do much for the goal
Christie-6- crossing was generally poor but did well in the build up to the goal
Keogh-8- fantastic
Cranie-6- did ok in his first game back, thought he struggled with the physical style of West Ham at times.
Hussey-7- played well and made some great surging runs down the line
Clingan-8- generally controlled the game against a premiership midfield with Gael and Thomas
Gael-8- Same as Clingan, seemed at times the only player trying to thread through ball to the strikers
Thomas-7-good game, not as quite as good as Gael or Sammy
Sheff-6-not bad, made some good runs beyond the strikers. Would have got a 7 but 2 or 3 times he tried a speculative shot from 30 yards when there were far better options
Platt-8- fantastic goal and led the line well.
Juke-7- Worked hard but never got any breaks today

Baker-7-some good dribbling and showed signs of a good understanding with Gael.
Wood-?-no comment

All in all I think it was the best performance of the season and we certainly didn't deserve to lose. West Ham only started getting chances when the game got stretched, before the equaliser we just needed to keep a good spell of possession and take the sting out of West Ham. Midfield 3 containing 2 teens dominated a premiership midfield and Gael and Thomas can be very proud of there performance tonight. Defence looked to struggle with West Ham's physicality and in particular Cole. I think Baker is worth a start ahead of Mcsheff on Tuesday behind the strikers.
I think Platt is the best like for like replacement for King we have at the moment, both of them play centrally and don't drift to the wings, have ok ball control and a good awareness of players around them and good anticiapation.
If we can keep up that standard of performance we will not be relegated imo.

wingy · Nov 19, 2011

For all the stick he recieved prior to the the last international break and the Forrest game he's totally manned up and turned it round QQQQQQQQQQQuality.

covcity4life · Nov 19, 2011

Nonleagueherewecome said:
I would have expected a tad more hyperbole after Hussey's showing today. He was absolute mint; if he didn't have an option to pass to, he skinned Faubert-a 7.5m signing I believe-every single time, and rained in some fantastic crosses. He also defended really well. It was pretty much the complete performance for a full back.

his corssing wasnt mint

Nonleagueherewecome · Nov 19, 2011

covcity4life said:
his corssing wasnt mint

I thought it was pretty good-he hit the edge of the 6 yard box constantly, it's just that the two huge WH defenders headed them clear above our attackers. Any one could have led to a goal.

Grendel · Nov 19, 2011

I thought Connor Thomas gave a great performance today. Considering the midfield he was up against he gave a stand-out performance. By contrast Bigi was not great and flagged badly in the second half. Keogh was outstanding and Platt looked better than Juke who struggled against their centre-half.

ccfcway · Nov 19, 2011

"Best game of the season"

LOST

NOW 6 POINTS (might as well be 7) clear of relegation

Going Down

Lets celebrate a 1-2 defeat

A loss is a loss

pusbccfc · Nov 19, 2011

Now we have two tall powerful strikers in the box, using the full backs/wingers to whip balls in is the easiest way to get goals, I liked the way west ham drove into the box before crossing, hussey tried a lot of that today unlucky not to get a equaliser.

stupot07 · Nov 19, 2011

ccfcway said:
"Best game of the season"

LOST

NOW 6 POINTS (might as well be 7) clear of relegation

Going Down

Lets celebrate a 1-2 defeat

A loss is a loss

So we can't be proud of a very good performance against a team packed full of premier league players?

SkyBlue_Bear83 · Nov 19, 2011

ccfcway said:
"Best game of the season"

LOST

NOW 6 POINTS (might as well be 7) clear of relegation

Going Down

Lets celebrate a 1-2 defeat

A loss is a loss

If we can keep up that standard of performance we won't keep losing, sooner or later results reflect performances. In the short term we may want to play rubbish but win but that is not a long term solution as Boothroyd showed last year.
If performances are CONSISTENTLY good the results will follow.

Nonleagueherewecome · Nov 19, 2011

Platt gave the ball away 3 times 2nd half with hospital passes. He was good first half but faded, possibly due to lack of fitness. But I don't really think Cody would have offered much more..maybe it was worth chucking him on for Platt for the last 10. I'm not sure where the negativity on Juke has come from, I thought he battled superbly and was unlucky with his stinging shot.

RATINGS FOLKS v West Ham (2 Viewers)

Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency