Ratings (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Cracking game. 2nd half particularly we bossed it apart from that nailed on pen they really didnt threaten we were on front foot.
Much improved when Rose went off injured.
Stand outs for me.
Very pleasantly surprised Doyle and Panzo were very impressive stood up to their bullies upfront. 8s for me.
Rose shouldn't be anywhere near first team gets bullied constantly.
Hamer back to his best. Firget about his cracking goal his energy was fantastic. Was always protecting a poor Dabo in the first half wanted the ball (wasnt perfect) but he was disciplined too.
8.
Gyokores absolutely terrorised their defence cut above. MOTM, would have got a 9 for me if he put away the easier chances.
The referee I thought was abysmal for both teams completely lost it in 2nd half. Possibly worst referee I seen live and that's saying something.
Much improved when Rose went off injured.
Stand outs for me.
Very pleasantly surprised Doyle and Panzo were very impressive stood up to their bullies upfront. 8s for me.
Rose shouldn't be anywhere near first team gets bullied constantly.
Hamer back to his best. Firget about his cracking goal his energy was fantastic. Was always protecting a poor Dabo in the first half wanted the ball (wasnt perfect) but he was disciplined too.
8.
Gyokores absolutely terrorised their defence cut above. MOTM, would have got a 9 for me if he put away the easier chances.
The referee I thought was abysmal for both teams completely lost it in 2nd half. Possibly worst referee I seen live and that's saying something.
stupot07
Well-Known Member
Didn't they also hit the post in the second half?
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
Grendel
Well-Known Member
And had a stonewall penalty
SlowerThanPlatt
Well-Known Member
In real time can see why referee wasn’t sure but with benefit of replays got away with one there
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Was he not
stupot07
Well-Known Member
Definitely there was no way the ref could see it and the linesman was the other side of the pitch.
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
Unfortunately there's been no need to wait for the accident to happen with Moore.
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
It was the only thing the ref gave us all night.
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
Gyökeres was lower for the miss. Doyle was good but collectively the defence, including him, were shaky.
GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee
Well-Known Member
That cannot be true as categorically every ref ever has a personal vendetta against us
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
No vendetta last night, just some interesting decisions. As a neutral I'd have said the ref was reasonable last night but not booking Morris after he spent the first 20 minutes hammering the linesman was strange. He then continued to do it later on in the second half.
I feel the referees do not like setting a precedent. Same goes with time wasting.
Malaka
Well-Known Member
Wilson 6 Needs to boos the defence (grow a pair)
Doyle 6 This lad is growing on me
Fadz 4 His age was exploited, at fault for the second goal and it should have been a penalty
Panzo 7 Thought he was solid
Dabo 5 much better going forward in the second half, first half he was pants
Bidwell 6.5 Decent game, hardworker
Sheaf 7 Gave the ball away a couple of times, but he is gonna be massive for us this season
Hamer 7.5 Steady, would have been 6 if it wasn't for that screamer
Allen 6 Decent game
Godden 6 Ran his socks of and created space for Vic
Gyokeres 8.5 MOM what a beast, he must be horrible to play against
Doyle 6 This lad is growing on me
Fadz 4 His age was exploited, at fault for the second goal and it should have been a penalty
Panzo 7 Thought he was solid
Dabo 5 much better going forward in the second half, first half he was pants
Bidwell 6.5 Decent game, hardworker
Sheaf 7 Gave the ball away a couple of times, but he is gonna be massive for us this season
Hamer 7.5 Steady, would have been 6 if it wasn't for that screamer
Allen 6 Decent game
Godden 6 Ran his socks of and created space for Vic
Gyokeres 8.5 MOM what a beast, he must be horrible to play against
I thought Gyokeres was great. Scored and created numerous other chances. I prefer players that get lots of chances even if they miss a high proportion than those that never look like scoring. That's why in my view O'Hare is so much better than Allen. Allen just feels pointless in that role.
GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee
Well-Known Member
Didn’t think he was bad at all. Morris should have been booked 100%. Most the other stuff was just people moaning cuz they love a moan. We’ve become the arsenal of 2010ish where we don’t like a tackle or any physicality unless it’s us making it. Granted they could have had a pen but it’s such a hard decision in that speed
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Just felt a few times he didn’t seem to know what he was doing and took far too much lip from Luton players. Thought in general he let the game flow well TBH.
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Only watched last 15 mins and he gave nothing
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Including a penalty
covboy1987
Well-Known Member
Wilson 6
Dabo 5
Doyle 7
Fadz 5
Rose 5
Bidwell 7
Sheaf 8
Hamer 6
Allen 4
Gyokeres 7.5
Godden 4
Razzle Dazzle Dean Gordon
Well-Known Member
Gyokores must be a nightmare for most centre halves in this division when he's on song. It's frustrating that he seems to miss so many clear-cut chances but i can't imagine many defenders enjoy a game against him.
Id probably have sheaf with a slightly higher rating for his superb assist but otherwose those scores are about how i saw it too.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
He can make something out of nothing a hell of a lot, but really needs more help from his colleagues.
These are not too far off for me - Rose, Hamer and Godden too high; Vik and Sheaf half-a-point under.
Glad you called out Doyle for the mistake for the opener - I mentioned it in the match thread. Obviously a talented young player and I'm sure he'll develop into a quality player but it was an abysmal attempt at a header in the build-up to the first goal and he had a few other hairy moments in the box; Oggy called him out for one in the commentary, too. Was also skinned far too easily in the final play of the game when the Luton player got a cross in which came to nothing. He was better than Rose on the right, though, and did a couple of decent things near the end.
Good to see Panzo coming out with the ball and I thought @shmmeee's comment was spot on - if they're all rubbish you might as well play the one who can bring the ball out and attack.
Allen at least got in a couple of half-decent scoring positions and his second might have gone in had it not hit a defender. Not sure I have the faith in Palmer to get into those positions but also hope he comes good.
Disappointed Robins didn't change things - Godden was completely ineffective and out of the game and we were on top with ever more space opening up.
Really need Hamer to have a big game on Saturday. Cracking goal but he's had zero influence on games so far, that aside (and his red).
mmttww
Well-Known Member
People are being harsh on Godden. He put Vik through for that howler at the start. Held the ball up better than I've seen him and never stopped. He missed one chance. Like someone else said, he and Vik made runs wide and made space for others.
Allen being bang average with that space, Dabo being awful first half and Bidwell being fairly cautious meant he barely had a sniff. No other fwd in the match squad could've done a better job last night. Maybe Waghorn at a push.
Allen being bang average with that space, Dabo being awful first half and Bidwell being fairly cautious meant he barely had a sniff. No other fwd in the match squad could've done a better job last night. Maybe Waghorn at a push.
Sky_Blue_Dreamer
Well-Known Member
Wilson 5.5. Didn't do much except chuck the ball at the feet of a striker during a clearance,
Dabo 5. Shocking for first goal. Thought he was going to get sent off lunging in after miscontrolling. Improved a bit second half.
Bidwell 7. Solid.
Rose 5.5. Far from great.
Fadz 5. Awful for second goal. Looks like age has caught up with him.
Doyle 6.5. Best of a bad bunch, but shouldn't be relying on a teenager in defence.
Sheaf 7. Great assist but still some infuriating easy passes going astray.
Hamer 7. Fantastic goal but had a number of speculative shots. Didn't get books. Just needs to do the simple things .
Allen 5. Bundle of energy but has absolutely no impact on a game at all either in attack or defence. Game pass him by.
Gyokeres 6. Missed a great chance in first minute and maybe could have had a hat-trick. Got a goal and causes problems, but he's trying to do too much on his own.
Godden 5.5. Worked reasonably hard but he's a goalscorer and if the attack is mainly going through his strike partner who's trying to do it all himself he's a passenger.
Dabo 5. Shocking for first goal. Thought he was going to get sent off lunging in after miscontrolling. Improved a bit second half.
Bidwell 7. Solid.
Rose 5.5. Far from great.
Fadz 5. Awful for second goal. Looks like age has caught up with him.
Doyle 6.5. Best of a bad bunch, but shouldn't be relying on a teenager in defence.
Sheaf 7. Great assist but still some infuriating easy passes going astray.
Hamer 7. Fantastic goal but had a number of speculative shots. Didn't get books. Just needs to do the simple things .
Allen 5. Bundle of energy but has absolutely no impact on a game at all either in attack or defence. Game pass him by.
Gyokeres 6. Missed a great chance in first minute and maybe could have had a hat-trick. Got a goal and causes problems, but he's trying to do too much on his own.
Godden 5.5. Worked reasonably hard but he's a goalscorer and if the attack is mainly going through his strike partner who's trying to do it all himself he's a passenger.
eastwoodsdustman
Well-Known Member
I've Left it a while for the dust to settle and overall I think we weren't as bad as some think. Their sub at half time definitely helped us as we seemed to have more room to play in the middle when Cornick went off. We're on the back of 3 consecutive losses and got dicked 5-0 last year so I really wasn't overly optimistic.
Wilson - 6 Almost saved the first and made another decent save in 1st half
Dabo -6 Was a 4 in the first and 8 in the second. much improved as the game went on. Everyone was dreading it when they brought on their sub at half time but Fanky got to grips with him and offered an outlet going forward in the second half. Hopefully he's turned the corner.
Bidwell - 7 Solid but got less attacking as second half wore on.
McFadz - 6 Bar the one error I thought he handled them pretty well and was certainly better when rose went off.
Rose - 5 looked a bit lost
Doyle -7.5 Played well and got forward a bit in the second half
Hamer - 7 Great goal and ran himself into the ground but a few poor passes
Sheaf - 7 As per hamer but with a great pass instead of the goal
Allen - 7 Second half he was everywhere when we went forward. Watching him off the ball when we were in possession was a joy. He kept picking up little pockets of space to receive the ball.
Godden - 7 Did plenty of running pulling defenders out of position and used the ball well in the main
Gyokores - 8 He ran their defence ragged. They got tight and he turned them, They dropped off and he ran at them. They really didnt know what to do. Missed a couple of chances that would have got him a 9 or a 10.
Subs
Panzo 7 Solid and good going forward. We looked so much better with him on the pitch.
Wilson - 6 Almost saved the first and made another decent save in 1st half
Dabo -6 Was a 4 in the first and 8 in the second. much improved as the game went on. Everyone was dreading it when they brought on their sub at half time but Fanky got to grips with him and offered an outlet going forward in the second half. Hopefully he's turned the corner.
Bidwell - 7 Solid but got less attacking as second half wore on.
McFadz - 6 Bar the one error I thought he handled them pretty well and was certainly better when rose went off.
Rose - 5 looked a bit lost
Doyle -7.5 Played well and got forward a bit in the second half
Hamer - 7 Great goal and ran himself into the ground but a few poor passes
Sheaf - 7 As per hamer but with a great pass instead of the goal
Allen - 7 Second half he was everywhere when we went forward. Watching him off the ball when we were in possession was a joy. He kept picking up little pockets of space to receive the ball.
Godden - 7 Did plenty of running pulling defenders out of position and used the ball well in the main
Gyokores - 8 He ran their defence ragged. They got tight and he turned them, They dropped off and he ran at them. They really didnt know what to do. Missed a couple of chances that would have got him a 9 or a 10.
Subs
Panzo 7 Solid and good going forward. We looked so much better with him on the pitch.
Esoterica
Well-Known Member
Robins needs to get us back to playing to our strengths. Think the last few weeks have got in his head and he's lost a bit of clarity in his decision making.
Dabo is much better (although his crossing was piss poor on Wednesday) when he gets up the pitch and provides an overload on his side of the pitch, Godden is much better in the box than dropping short or running channels. Allen is at his most effective when he makes those runs beyond the strikers and actually gets in the box instead of being asked to play like a poundshop O'Hare.
We have a small squad with some limited Championship footballers in it. Get them doing what they do best.
Dabo is much better (although his crossing was piss poor on Wednesday) when he gets up the pitch and provides an overload on his side of the pitch, Godden is much better in the box than dropping short or running channels. Allen is at his most effective when he makes those runs beyond the strikers and actually gets in the box instead of being asked to play like a poundshop O'Hare.
We have a small squad with some limited Championship footballers in it. Get them doing what they do best.
