Right who's the next manager then? (14 Viewers)

Earlsdon_Skyblue1

Well-Known Member
There's an unsurprising correlation between those that:

-Wanted Robins sacked
-Want a 'famous name'
-Dismiss unattractive sounding realistic options
-Call people 'embarrasing' or 'overreacting' when it's pointed out that sacking Robins and bringing in a famous name looks like a clown move that's potentially going to backfire badly

I for one hope we have a random candidate out of nowhere that no one is expecting. I haven't heard a single name that sounds inspiring so far.
 

lewys33

Well-Known Member
There's an unsurprising correlation between those that:

-Wanted Robins sacked
-Want a 'famous name'
-Dismiss unattractive sounding realistic options
-Call people 'embarrasing' or 'overreacting' when it's pointed out that sacking Robins and bringing in a famous name looks like a clown move that's potentially going to backfire badly

I for one hope we have a random candidate out of nowhere that no one is expecting. I haven't heard a single name that sounds inspiring so far.

Captain hindsight will decide who was right, and no doubt they will laud it over the entire forum whilst ignoring the fact none of us have a clue and chat waffle 24/7.
 

RobinsSkyBlues

Well-Known Member
He's got 2 promotions and a FL trophy already in his first 6 years of management
Robins got 2 promotions, tin pot trophy winner and a toenail away from the FA cup final with us in 7 years after taking over a club in total turmoil. And only 1 of them seasons didn't see us finish higher than the season before. And he isn't seen as good enough.
 

RobinsSkyBlues

Well-Known Member
He looks to be suffering this season with cheap goals being conceded, which naturally if you are trying to implement an almost ‘tiki taka’ style in L1 will be used as a stick to beat him with.

Their XG Against is 14.9 and they’ve conceded 24 goals. It’s a bit of misfortune. Wouldn’t be my pick but he’s not exactly hopeless.
Sounds like Robins record this season.
 

Sky Blue Goblin

Well-Known Member
Robins got 2 promotions, tin pot trophy winner and a toenail away from the FA cup final with us in 7 years after taking over a club in total turmoil. And only 1 of them seasons didn't see us finish higher than the season before. And he isn't seen as good enough.
So what you’re saying is I want to replace robins, with a younger Robins?

Thought you’d be up for that 🤣
 

Evo1883

Well-Known Member
Robins got 2 promotions, tin pot trophy winner and a toenail away from the FA cup final with us in 7 years after taking over a club in total turmoil. And only 1 of them seasons didn't see us finish higher than the season before. And he isn't seen as good enough.


Why would we appoint lampard whose achieved nothing in management if your logic was applied
 
Last edited:

2024/25 League 1 Champs?

Well-Known Member
interesting that we are talking about either big names with limited to no experience of managing in and / or getting out of the Championship (other than, tenuously, Lampard), OR lower league managers unproven at this level, but there’s little to no mention of anybody who has any real recent record of managing in our league and getting teams out of it…..
 

KarmicChris

Active Member
interesting that we are talking about either big names with limited to no experience of managing in and / or getting out of the Championship (other than, tenuously, Lampard), OR lower league managers unproven at this level, but there’s little to no mention of anybody who has any real recent record of managing in our league and getting teams out of it…..

Like who?
 

Sky Blue Goblin

Well-Known Member
interesting that we are talking about either big names with limited to no experience of managing in and / or getting out of the Championship (other than, tenuously, Lampard), OR lower league managers unproven at this level, but there’s little to no mention of anybody who has any real recent record of managing in our league and getting teams out of it…..
Not many of them available as far as I can tell bar maybe Rob Edwards who desperately needs a break.
 

Sky Blue Goblin

Well-Known Member
well, although all currently employed, Steve Cooper, Russell Martin, Rob Edwards, Scott Parker as examples

I believe at least two may have been interested
All of them and I don’t mean to sound mean are currently employed at either parachute payment clubs or premier league clubs.

Apart from Rob Edward (who I’m not 100% about), don’t think a single one would leave there current job to join USA they’ll be on higher wages for one and in regard to the prem ones at the top division where they have the spotlight.

Just couldn’t see which is why I think a lot of focus is based on big name managers who are thought to have potential and drawing power or unproven coaches who again have potential and will be hungry for the chance to manage us.
 

Sky Blue Goblin

Well-Known Member
Has Ian Evatt paid you to push him for manager 😂
Suspicious Monkey GIF by MOODMAN
 

SkyBluePower

Well-Known Member
It’s funny the manager that eventually got Robins sacked (Warne) is now the longest serving in the Championship.
Not exactly pretty football but he is keeping them collecting points when they were nailed on favourites to go back down and have no money to spend.
It’s almost as if Derby have learned their lesson from us after vanity appointments like McLaren, Cocu, Lampard and Rooney.
Just hope we are not going in that direction. Maybe Evatt , the unglamorous appointment is just what we need.
 

KarmicChris

Active Member
well, although all currently employed, Steve Cooper, Russell Martin, Rob Edwards, Scott Parker as examples

I believe at least two may have been interested

Well if they’re employed that’s probably a good reason why they’re not being mentioned! Also, do they have a record of being good at this level, or have they just been good with a club.
Rob Edwards @ Luton, a great season with a team he inherited, which is now struggling, but didn’t work at Watford.
Russell Martin didn’t reach the play offs with Swansea for 2 seasons, did well with Southampton but they have a good team.

For me, a record would be with a couple of clubs across a number of seasons
 

Sky Blue Goblin

Well-Known Member
It’s funny the manager that eventually got Robins sacked (Warne) is now the longest serving in the Championship.
Not exactly pretty football but he is keeping them collecting points when they were nailed on favourites to go back down and have no money to spend.
It’s almost as if Derby have learned their lesson from us after vanity appointments like McLaren, Cocu, Lampard and Rooney.
Just hope we are not going in that direction. Maybe Evatt , the unglamorous appointment is just what we need.
Join Us Mystery Science Theater 3000 GIF by MOODMAN
 

RobinsSkyBlues

Well-Known Member
Why would we appoint lampard whose achieved nothing in management if your logic was applied
So you understand my logic. Thanks.

I'm not against getting Lampard. Looking at the list I see him as about the best out of them. But is he the right one to take us forward?

Whoever gets the role will have my backing. But I'm not expecting miracles. Some people will be.
 

2024/25 League 1 Champs?

Well-Known Member
All of them and I don’t mean to sound mean are currently employed at either parachute payment clubs or premier league clubs.

Apart from Rob Edward (who I’m not 100% about), don’t think a single one would leave there current job to join USA they’ll be on higher wages for one and in regard to the prem ones at the top division where they have the spotlight.

Just couldn’t see which is why I think a lot of focus is based on big name managers who are thought to have potential and drawing power or unproven coaches who again have potential and will be hungry for the chance to manage us.
Well if they’re employed that’s probably a good reason why they’re not being mentioned! Also, do they have a record of being good at this level, or have they just been good with a club.
Rob Edwards @ Luton, a great season with a team he inherited, which is now struggling, but didn’t work at Watford.
Russell Martin didn’t reach the play offs with Swansea for 2 seasons, did well with Southampton but they have a good team.

For me, a record would be with a couple of clubs across a number of seasons

all fair points, and my point really is more that either way we are going for untried and untested at this level unless we bring in a ‘coach’ who has knowledge, experience and success at this level

lower level might work, but how often have you seen someone piss league one then struggle to adapt to this league, and a big name could be a success but, again, how often have you seen them fail…

lower level might mean more drive to prove themselves and succeed, big name might mean more draw for better transfer targets and players engaging more in training, who knows

it’s a gamble either way
 

CoventryUSA

Well-Known Member
Would this guy even be on our radar?
How would Austin/King/Roberts be aware of him!? (How are you even aware of him!?)

I'm late to respond to this. But I know him because I'm an American who watches more MLS than any other league. Also, I'm within the MLS media sphere.

As mentioned by the other, I am not sure how King is conducting the search. But if he is using any sort of analytics-based firm, then Nancy's name absolutely would pop up as a top candidate.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top