Shamima Begum (11 Viewers)

[Sky Blue Pete]

Just reading some of the justification from the government lawyer and I quote

You could well have been radicalised and manipulated at an age (15) when you are vulnerable …. But nevertheless however unfortunate it might be you are now a risk

There’s more but wow!!!!!

No wonder girls in care are abused by men and ignored by those in authority in social services and the police ffs

 

---

[Grendel]

She’s lost her case against the government

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

She’s lost her case against the government

I’m really surprised but I’ve seen legal issues dealt with after the event

As a 15 year old she was groomed and not protected by the system. But hey who cares eh

 

[Grendel]

I’m really surprised but I’ve seen legal issues dealt with after the event

As a 15 year old she was groomed and not protected by the system. But hey who cares eh

would you have the same view if she’d left on her 16th birthday 8 weeks later?

 

[David O'Day]

would you have the same view if she’d left on her 16th birthday 8 weeks later?

yes as she would of still been a child

 

[Grendel]

yes as she would of still been a child

Well not if she was in Scotland of course

 

[David O'Day]

Well not if she was in Scotland of course

If London was in Scotland then you'd have a point

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

would you have the same view if she’d left on her 16th birthday 8 weeks later?

More importantly the law would see it differently but not very different.

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

would you have the same view if she’d left on her 16th birthday 8 weeks later?

Do you believe she was able to make that decision at 15?

 

[David O'Day]

Do you believe she was able to make that decision at 15?

He doesn't, he's doing his contrarian nonsense again, best left alone.

 

[Otis]

It's a sad case isn't it. Two 15 year olds and one 16 year old, groomed and systematically brainwashed. And weren't they all married off to IS fighters pretty soon after arriving over there?

Not sure I know the answer though as what we should do/have done with her.

Just a very sad case. The other two girls were both killed weren't they?

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

It's a sad case isn't it. Two 15 year olds and one 16 year old, groomed and systematically brainwashed. And weren't they all married off to IS fighters pretty soon after arriving over there?

Not sure I know the answer though as what we should do/have done with her.

Just a very sad case. The other two girls were both killed weren't they?

It appears that way yes
It’s why this case is more important that Shamima for me otis
If we are saying 15 year olds are legally responsible under adult laws that’s so so dangerous

 

[Bugsy]

My personal opinion is you reap what u sow.

who's to say she still doesn't have links to ISIS. that's a national security risk end of.

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

My personally opinion is you reap what u sow.

who's to say she still doesn't have links to ISIS. that's a national security risk end of.

On the wider point though bugsy?

 

[LastGarrison]

If it had been upheld and thus set a precedent would that in turn them have pushed radical organisations to try to ‘recruit’ more under 16’s as it could be seen as they could act with impunity?

Not saying I agree with that but just throwing out a different angle. I genuinely don’t know where I stand on this case.

 

[clint van damme]

Which country is she in currently?

 

[Sick Boy]

A state stripping someone of their citizenship doesn’t sit comfortably with me, especially as she was 15 at the time.

 

[David O'Day]

Which country is she in currently?

My personal opinion is you reap what u sow.

who's to say she still doesn't have links to ISIS. that's a national security risk end of.

At 15? so someone grooms you and it's your fault? We let adult fighters back in, it's government policy.

She was a kid and she was used as a pawn by a failing and frankly awful home sec to score political points.

 

[Grendel]

It appears that way yes
It’s why this case is more important that Shamima for me otis
If we are saying 15 year olds are legally responsible under adult laws that’s so so dangerous

I think at 15 you would have knowledge of the law and should be legally responsible yes I do

The citizenship debate is different but you have to be held responsible

 

[David O'Day]

A state stripping someone of their citizenship doesn’t sit comfortably with me, especially as she was 15 at the time.

It's also illegal as she has no other citizenship. She isn't Bangladeshi, Bangladesh has confirmed that many times already.

It'll open up back in open court

 

[shmmeee]

I think at 15 you would have knowledge of the law and should be legally responsible yes I do

The citizenship debate is different but you have to be held responsible

Do you think the abusers of the Rotherham girls should have been prosecuted?

 

[David O'Day]

I think at 15 you would have knowledge of the law and should be legally responsible yes I do

The citizenship debate is different but you have to be held responsible

at 15 she was child, a child who many people who should of protected her failed.

Weird

 

[Grendel]

at 15 she was child, a child who many people who should of protected her failed.

Weird

So you’d say the 15 year olds who murdered Brianna Grey are somehow more excused from their actions as they are not 16?

 

[olderskyblue]

Begum infamously said “when I saw my first severed head in a bin it didn’t faze me at all” and how the gruesome trophy was from “an enemy of Islam”. Just days later in an interview with the BBC Begum went on to say there was “justification” for the Manchester Bombings because of ISIS losses in Syria and Iraq, calling it a “a two-way thing”.

Can we say for sure that she isnt still a supporter of ISIS?

 

[skybluetony176]

Get her back and trial her as an adult for all her crimes and then the judge can consider her age at time of the crime when sentencing. Surely the obvious compromise.

 

[Nick]

Pete and O'Day can share custody of her in their spare room then?

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

I think at 15 you would have knowledge of the law and should be legally responsible yes I do

The citizenship debate is different but you have to be held responsible

At 15 you are not tried as an adult or shouldn’t be

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

So you’d say the 15 year olds who murdered Brianna Grey are somehow more excused from their actions as they are not 16?

They are not treated the same

 

[Sick Boy]

Most other European countries and the USA have got their citizens back home to face justice. A country washing their hands of someone who was born and radicalised there isn’t right.

 

[David O'Day]

Pete and O'Day can share custody of her in their spare room then?

What? Having citizenship doesn't mean she would come back. There's plenty of people in the same camps that do have British citizenship, no one is saying they should repatriate her. In fact she seems more interested in going back to Holland where her husband is from.

It's more a 15 year child who was groomed being used as a political pawn by a failed Home Sec. to prop up what was May's failing admin.

Also why would anyone have to put her up? if she did ever come back she has family in the Uk as she was fucking born here.

 

[Nick]

Let her go back to Holland then...

 

[fernandopartridge]

I for one can't see the precedent of removing a person's citizenship be misused at all by a proto fascist government

 

[David O'Day]

Let her go back to Holland then...

She's not going anywhere, she's stuck in a camp that having citizenship won't help her get out of.

It's about the rights and wrongs of using a victim of childhood grooming as a political pawn.

 

[Nick]

“From what I heard, Islamically that is all allowed. So I was okay with it.”

 

[David O'Day]

The full transcript of is proof that she was groomed.