skybluetony176
Well-Known Member
David Baddiel wrote a good article on the whole Livingstone affair.
David Baddiel wrote a good article on the whole Livingstone affair.Those in the far right will be anti-Zionist and anti-Semitic. Though being the former doesn't de facto make you the latter, which is the lazy conclusion being jumped to against anyone with a negative comment to make about Israel.
David Baddiel wrote a good article on the whole Livingstone affair.
I know what anti Zionism is and I know what anti Semitic is. Some people like to blur the lines for political gain, like you. Others blur it because they’re stupid and don’t realise the difference. Same as members of the Indian community used to get labelled an abbreviation of a neighbouring country as a derogatory term. If people are using Zio as a derogatory term against all Jewish people then you’re in good company as you’ve misunderstood the meaning of Zionism and Zionist the same as them.
Judaism is a religion, Zionism is an ideology. Judaism as a religion is over 3500 years old. Zionism as an ideology is also only about 140 years old. As long as there has been Zionism there has been an anti Zionist movements in the Jewish faith even from within Israel itself, the OJC is almost 100years old and based in Jerusalem and predates the state of Israel. Haredi Jews are anti Zionist and is an older movement than the OJC. Hasidic Jews are anti Zionist. One of the three oaths is that Jews will not forcibly claim Israel. Many Jews believe Zionism is a direct threat to God. Many view Zionism as an ideology based on racism. Should I go on?
David Baddiel wrote a good article on the whole Livingstone affair.
The Nazi deal with Zionist Jews was about the Nazis protecting the German economy. Nothing to do with being Zionist or supporting Zionism. That was just a byproduct.
No Tony because as usual you spectacularly miss the point. The point is Corbyn and his friends in Hamas want the Jews removed from Palestine.
I’ve already proved to you that 90% of British Jews want Israel to remain as is but only 59% are Zionist’s as they are the religious order.
Mr Corbyn rejects the views of the 90% not the 59%
Tiny in patronising mood when he’s never heard a known kkk word for Jews and thinks it’s an uncle in Italian.
Brighton disagrees with you he thinks it was hitler being compassionate before he “went a bit mad”
Brighton disagrees with you he thinks it was hitler being compassionate before he “went a bit mad”
OK point by point.
Define Palestine. Are you talking about illegal Jewish settlements that contravene international law on the West Bank and Gaza? Are you saying that we shouldn’t up hold international law or are you suggesting we cherry pick which international law we uphold depending on your own personal political leaning? Or maybe you’re referring to Palestine as the state of Israel along with the West Bank and Gaza? In which case he never remotely suggested anything like what you’ve suggested he has ever.
Zionism isn’t a religious order it’s an ideology. Enough said.
Don’t think you ever did reveal your source for this poll. Has Corbyn ever actually said he doesn’t want Israel to remain? Presumably you have a link to this statement he’s apparently made.
There’s a reason I don’t know a KKK derogatory term for Jews. Not being a racist I don’t follow what the KKK is up to. Maybe you do but I don’t. And finally Italian for uncle is Zio. Look it up yourself if you don’t believe me.
I’ve already told you the source poll Tony I’m not doing it again. Oddly having made numerous requests to provide your source of information for your counter argument you have failed to provide anything - nothing new there
The Zionist argument I’ve blown apart by other links Tony - links I’ve included in replies to you - as far as I’m aware you should be able to access as there is no subscription- if there is PM me and I’ll hold your hand through the process.
The Zio statement came up from an interview by Andrew Neil when he massacred Ken Livingstone and referred to the deeply offensive term. Oddly enough I’ve shared that link as well Tony. Seems again you’ve not bothered to research before you speak.
I’ve stopped the ignore Tony and I’m disappointed. Still the snarling, contradictory rhetoric. The request for evidence which when provided you don’t see. The request for counter evidence ignored and replaced by babbling extracts from journals which you pretend are your own thoughts.
Tony you need to do better or it’s back in ignore.
I’ve given you a chance to engage in sensible debate. Don’t blow it please.
I repeat
“Judaism is a religion, Zionism is an ideology. Judaism as a religion is over 3500 years old. Zionism as an ideology is also only about 140 years old. As long as there has been Zionism there has been an anti Zionist movements in the Jewish faith even from within Israel itself, the OJC is almost 100years old and based in Jerusalem and predates the state of Israel. Haredi Jews are anti Zionist and is an older movement than the OJC. Hasidic Jews are anti Zionist. One of the three oaths is that Jews will not forcibly claim Israel. Many Jews believe Zionism is a direct threat to God. Many view Zionism as an ideology based on racism. Should I go on?”
Just to add. Jews invented Zionism. Jews also invented anti Zionism. To assume that being anti Zionist also makes you anti Semitic is just ignorant to history and mostly this is a deliberate ignorance.
On that note I’m out. You’ve detracted this thread enough. Somebody must have said something honest about the Home Secretary. Honest and Home Secretary mentioned in the same sentence. There’s something you don’t see very often.
So we have gone from spies and poisoning to Hitler, to Corbyn, to the Jews and Zionism.
All we need now are a few barbs about Brexit and why black people don't eat crisps and it will be the Full Monty.
Well that worked.Can we keep this thread to topic .
Seem to be overspill from two other lengthy threads crossing over here .
Politely.
Dad now out of critical condition and improving.
Some odds things about all this. Usually if Russia want you dead and they get to you, you stay dead.
Botched job if it was the Russians and the Russians intention was to kill him.
Very Very Strange affair .Dad now out of critical condition and improving.
Some odds things about all this. Usually if Russia want you dead and they get to you, you stay dead.
Botched job if it was the Russians and the Russians intention was to kill him.
Well, I agree, but it doesn't make sense that if Russia wanted to kill him that he's still alive.One thing everyone accepts (well other than Marxist Jeremy) is that this was an act purely state driven - ie manufactured weaponised in the same laboratory - so what other state would have done it?
Nope!Did your Mrs translate the speech last night ,some inaccuracies from the intrrpretor I believe especially around the term "You're playing with Fire" .
Who the hell is Vicktorias Visa?UK refuses Viktorias Visa.
I reckon Livingstone will take a word in the ear to fuck off quietly for “the good of the left”, or at least I hope so. The guys drinking has obviously taken its toll and best for all for him to tend to his allotment now.
Momentum are OK, mostly idealistic young people in my experience, plus the odd old leftie tacked on in the hopes of an 80s revival which is unlikely considering the majority are the young idealists. There simply aren’t enough far left people to take over a major political party.
Looks like the USA has beaten us to the Maginsky act and locked up Vlads money ,over there at least .
It's an interesting divergence from Trumps oft stated desire to benifit from getting along with Russia, unless the State is driving things.
UK refuses Viktorias Visa.
Yulia released from Hospital.
TV interview imminent?
Habeas Corpas writ to follow ?
Fireworks tonight ?I wouldn’t think so. The police and secret services will see her and she has already declined a meeting with the Russian authorities- I can’t think why.
Meanwhile Macron allies himself to Trump and the prospect of military action against the Russian backed regime grows by the day.
Wow finally she speaks.
So glad !!
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?