What’s your expectation for the new guy? (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter shmmeee
- Start date
Guessing the reason doug sacked robins this early into the season is so that the new manager has enough time to get us play offs at least, be very surprised if we don’t add in January, push on 2nd half of the season, for me if we don’t get at least play offs, then it’s been the wrong decision,
SBAndy
Well-Known Member
I’ve voted playoffs but there would be some leniency in there. If the playoff points total was abnormally high (don’t think it will be) or if we’re still in contention at 44 games but don’t quite make it, that’d suffice. The idea that we should just be aiming for a top half finish lacks ambition.
Also worth noting I wasn’t expecting us to be relegated, or even be in a relegation battle come the new year. The point is that this squad should be battling up the other end of the table. We can’t afford to tread water, lose players at the end of the season and then have to go through the whole ‘rebuild’ phase again.
Also worth noting I wasn’t expecting us to be relegated, or even be in a relegation battle come the new year. The point is that this squad should be battling up the other end of the table. We can’t afford to tread water, lose players at the end of the season and then have to go through the whole ‘rebuild’ phase again.
That expectation was over a full season with a squad and formation Robis had trained. We are now 1/3rd through the season and miles behind the top 6. Expectations therefore can alter.
SBAndy
Well-Known Member
Statistically, if a manager doesn’t get at least 8 points from their first 8 games then they will never turn things round. If we end up in that mess then pull the trigger sharpish.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
By miles you mean 3 wins
skybluecam
Well-Known Member
74 points is generally the minimum that will reliably get you into the playoffs. That's just over 1.6 points a game. I'd hope the new manager to average that for the remainder of the season which would give us 65/66 points and we'd probably finish around 10th.
Telfer85
Well-Known Member
To be realistic it’s not 3 wins though is it. It would be 3 wins if you expected no one above us to win any games at all over that period.
Also with our defensive record as it is and these next couple of fixtures coming up we will need a while to chalk up them 3 wins.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
You're right but I imagine if we won 3 games straight we'd be within 3 or 4 points based on average ppg
SkyBlueMatt
Well-Known Member
Considering the expectations that were given to MR. We should be playoffs, anything less should be seen as a massive failure.
Sent from my M2101K6G using Tapatalk
Sent from my M2101K6G using Tapatalk
Jamesimus
Well-Known Member
Given it’s a new manager who will likely implement a few new things and new players, I would give them some time for this to work.
Top half this season, playoffs next as a minimum would be my level of expectation.
Telfer85
Well-Known Member
Agreed and obviously I hope we do but I think the reality at this moment in time with how we’ve been playing is we are more looking at making sure we aren’t looking over our shoulders than looking up.
I’d have said the same even if robins was still in charge. To me my expectations changed when we left ourselves short in summer. I’m hoping we might be a bit more active than Jan than previous years through necessity but I won’t hold my breath.
I think if a new manager can come in and bed in a style of football that makes the most of the squad’s talent and has us consistently performing at a level that would get us into the playoffs on a full-season basis, then that would be a marked improvement over the past 12 months, even if it probably wouldn’t be enough to make the top 6 this season. Not sure why I should be unhappy with that.
The watchmaker
Well-Known Member
I would have said the opposite. I had high expectations because of Robins. If it is a 'Lampard' let's just concentrate on staying up. I'm not being negative there. Just lowering expectations.
Based on many years of previous experience. There is a reason the fans of other clubs sh@t themselves after we thumped Boro. The stats were good, the goals are starting to come - no one other than a few flakey Coventry fans had us finishing bottom half.
skybluecam
Well-Known Member
We're 15 games in and our points total is relegation form. The new manager presumably won't have a time machine back to August, so that is a ridiculous statement.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
We are 8 points off the playoffs.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
How can our points tally be relegation form if we're 17th ? It's not static every season
skybluecam
Well-Known Member
blues got relegated on a higher ppg than we're averaging. Anyway, that's not the point I'm making.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Our current ppg doesn't relegate you most seasons.. we are 17th and 8 points off bloody 6th get a grip
skybluecam
Well-Known Member
That’s a lot after 15 games.
Maybe not but it’s equivalent to about 20th place.
Anyway, the point is that to get playoffs now we’d have to average autos form for the rest of the season. That’s unrealistic.
Hobo
Well-Known Member
The season is still very much alive with plenty of games left, which is why I thought the trigger was pulled too hastily on Mark Robins after all he has achieved.
I don't think it will matter what the fans expectations are - I think it will be delivering Kings expectations. I think this ends King's honeymoon period at the club and he is about to find out how difficult it can be chasing success in football.
I don't think it will matter what the fans expectations are - I think it will be delivering Kings expectations. I think this ends King's honeymoon period at the club and he is about to find out how difficult it can be chasing success in football.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
If there were 15 to go it wouldn’t even be a lot. The season is still wide open.
torchomatic
Well-Known Member
Be interesting what the Robins Out crew will come up with.
If they didn't expect anything less than play offs with Robins then they can't seriously expect anything less with their new man.
In fact, we should be surpassing what we expected Robins to achieve this season as the new guy should be "better" than what we had.
If they didn't expect anything less than play offs with Robins then they can't seriously expect anything less with their new man.
In fact, we should be surpassing what we expected Robins to achieve this season as the new guy should be "better" than what we had.
The watchmaker
Well-Known Member
Yeah, I agree with you both, and did genuinely believe that Robins would drag us into the playoff mix at some point but Cam's key point here was that we shouldn't be sacking the new manager for finishing 7th given that would be playoff form over the course of a full season. I get Nanolimp's "what's the point" but it's done now. Sacking a manager that finished 7th would be exceptionally harsh.
bigfatronssba
Well-Known Member
Doug King was expecting a Play Off challenge this season
So I'm expecting him to appoint someone who will deliver that
So I'm expecting him to appoint someone who will deliver that
bigfatronssba
Well-Known Member
We should be challenging for the play offs though.
The watchmaker
Well-Known Member
8 points is nothing in the championship as we have shown in previous seasons. Lots of points get dropped and anyone that can string a run together will find themselves there or there abouts.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Sacking a manager who has never had a bad season is harsher. “That’s football”
Whoever it is has been brought in for instant success. If they aren’t better than the last seven years then they’ve failed.
Jamesimus
Well-Known Member
Did you even read his post?
It would take a very good run of form to get us to that stage and getting a new manager in and likely new systems / new players could disrupt things slightly. Also, it may have the opposite effect. No guarantees.
I’ll be giving the new guy a bit of time; that level of patience worked with the last guy…
bigfatronssba
Well-Known Member
Yes. Have you read mine? I don't believe I've disagreed with anyone
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
The idea of “playoff form” “relegation form” is nonsense really. Not many teams average the same ppg consistently throughout the season. Robins has shown that even with a start like we’ve had you can expect a top ten finish. Whatever comes in has to be better than that.