The EU: In, out, shake it all about.... (32 Viewers)

As of right now, how are thinking of voting? In or out

  • Remain

    Votes: 23 37.1%
  • Leave

    Votes: 35 56.5%
  • Undecided

    Votes: 3 4.8%
  • Not registered or not intention to vote

    Votes: 1 1.6%

  • Total voters
    62
  • Poll closed .

SkyblueBazza

Well-Known Member
Over 12% of the population here in Germany don’t have a German passport, but I just walked into the dentist and got an appointment. Doctors aren’t great problem in the cities either and are now offering Tele services inside areas.
Wondering if such professionals' salaries are so relatively massive in Germany (& other EU states) compared to say a retail assistant like here in the UK? I suspect a certain greed here rather than a moral type approach. For example they (dentists) all start off doing NHS work largely. Then build up a patient list...switch to private & charge us. Thus making some relatively fabulous earnings along the way - & most treatment is beyond question without paying again to check their treatment advice is good. Ethically they wouldn't - but I was advised to replace a filling 4yrs ago & decided to leave it. It hasn't been mentioned as needing replacement since!

Sent from my SM-G900F using Tapatalk
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
Open door? Not speculation? Either Eastern Europeans are working for the minimum wage and putting people out of work, or the are inflating house prices by 30%.... but, we have full employment and the country is awash with black money and speculative investments. Something in your argument doesn’t add up.
Let me see.

Not enough homes for people to live in. A 7 figure amount of people don't have somewhere to call home. True

The NHS is struggling to cope. True.

Schools are overcrowded. True.

Our roads are getting gridlocked. True.

How many more points would you like that are true? None I suppose.

Germany is a massive country. Yet our population is quickly catching up. France is a massive country. Yet our population has about caught up.

You say that the lack of homes isn't a problem as we have some grass somewhere to build on. Don't worry about the lack of infrastructure. Because we can blame it on Brexit. You say we should build more hospitals. Each one costs billions. Would just a few more sort out the whole of the UK? And then we would need the staff for them. And because we can't choose what skills can come here the situation continues to get worse.

But none of this matters to Mart. All he is worried about is being allowed to live in Germany. And he doesn't trust the EU to make his long term residency permanent.

If the UK is so fantastic as you make out why don't you just come back here to live instead of being worried you might have to come back?
 

martcov

Well-Known Member
Let me see.

Not enough homes for people to live in. A 7 figure amount of people don't have somewhere to call home. True

The NHS is struggling to cope. True.

Schools are overcrowded. True.

Our roads are getting gridlocked. True.

How many more points would you like that are true? None I suppose.

Germany is a massive country. Yet our population is quickly catching up. France is a massive country. Yet our population has about caught up.

You say that the lack of homes isn't a problem as we have some grass somewhere to build on. Don't worry about the lack of infrastructure. Because we can blame it on Brexit. You say we should build more hospitals. Each one costs billions. Would just a few more sort out the whole of the UK? And then we would need the staff for them. And because we can't choose what skills can come here the situation continues to get worse.

But none of this matters to Mart. All he is worried about is being allowed to live in Germany. And he doesn't trust the EU to make his long term residency permanent.

If the UK is so fantastic as you make out why don't you just come back here to live instead of being worried you might have to come back?

The reasons for these things are not as simple as you like to make out.

Yes, if we build hospitals we will need staff. We will need hospitals whether we are in or out of the EU. That has to do with demographics. We are living longer.

I haven’t said the lack of homes is not a problem. I have not blamed lack of homes or investment in infrastructure on Brexit. You just like a bit of dramatics and if there aren’t any, you just throw some of your own inventions in.

One reason our roads are gridlocked is that we have more cars. Everyone wants one and they are comparatively cheap because of the methods of production.

One thing that matters to Mart is freedom and the right for everyone to live and earn a living throughout the continent of Europe. We are a medium sized country and don’t seem to get it. Being on an island seems to create this fortress like approach towards the rest of Europe.

I am not worried that I may have to come back as long as my German citizenship comes through in the next couple of months. They actually do make thorough checks as to who is applying for a passport and that takes a couple of months extra to what I have already had to do.

It is not a case of not wanting to come home, but that my daughter, missus, businesses and friends are here. If I were loaded, I would buy a second home in or near Cov for my retirement and have the best of both worlds.

I do trust the EU, but I don’t trust „no deal“ Brexiteers who could create a situation of tit for tat negative regulations for foreigners. Do you seriously think I would put my future peace of mind in the hands of „mince“ Davis doing the negotiations backed up by Fox, BoJo and the sinister figure of the pompous Victorian, Mogg? Have fun with that lot.
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
The reasons for these things are not as simple as you like to make out.

They are not as complex as you make out




Yes, if we build hospitals we will need staff. We will need hospitals whether we are in or out of the EU. That has to do with demographics. We are living longer.

Our population has gone up by millions. Most are of an age where they will have children in the future. This puts a strain on maternity wards. People get ill. People need operations. And after all that as you say people live longer. So will thise who come to live here. And we don't have enough hospitals or staff for even the present number living here. Yet you try to deny it being a problem.

I haven’t said the lack of homes is not a problem. I have not blamed lack of homes or investment in infrastructure on Brexit. You just like a bit of dramatics and if there aren’t any, you just throw some of your own inventions in.

So you finally admit that we have a severe shortage of homes. But you still say that we should have an open border for anyone with an EU passport :rolleyes:
One reason our roads are gridlocked is that we have more cars. Everyone wants one and they are comparatively cheap because of the methods of production.

And the more people that come here to live the more people there will be who will want a car. Or hasn't that registered with you?
One thing that matters to Mart is freedom and the right for everyone to live and earn a living throughout the continent of Europe. We are a medium sized country and don’t seem to get it. Being on an island seems to create this fortress like approach towards the rest of Europe.

Living on an island means you have limited space. We are not massive like France or Germany.

I am not worried that I may have to come back as long as my German citizenship comes through in the next couple of months. They actually do make thorough checks as to who is applying for a passport and that takes a couple of months extra to what I have already had to do.

I hope you get sorted. You chose Germany as a home decades ago. But with this you don't seem ti have a clue about the reality of what has happened here.

It is not a case of not wanting to come home, but that my daughter, missus, businesses and friends are here. If I were loaded, I would buy a second home in or near Cov for my retirement and have the best of both worlds.

Don't worry. We need all the homes here for people already here.

I do trust the EU, but I don’t trust „no deal“ Brexiteers who could create a situation of tit for tat negative regulations for foreigners. Do you seriously think I would put my future peace of mind in the hands of „mince“ Davis doing the negotiations backed up by Fox, BoJo and the sinister figure of the pompous Victorian, Mogg? Have fun with that lot.

The EU make the rules. We have to try our best to survive within these rules. Just like we have for many years now.
 

martcov

Well-Known Member
They are not as complex as you make



Our population has gone up by millions. Most are of an age where they will have children in the future. This puts a strain on maternity wards. People get ill. People need operations. And after all that as you say people live longer. So will thise who come to live here. And we don't have enough hospitals or staff for even the present number living here. Yet you try to deny it being a problem.



So you finally admit that we have a severe shortage of homes. But you still say that we should have an open border for anyone with an EU passport :rolleyes:


And the more people that come here to live the more people there will be who will want a car. Or hasn't that registered with you?


Living on an island means you have limited space. We are not massive like France or Germany.



I hope you get sorted. You chose Germany as a home decades ago. But with this you don't seem ti have a clue about the reality of what has happened here.



Don't worry. We need all the homes here for people already here.



The EU make the rules. We have to try our best to survive within these rules. Just like we have for many years now.
They are not as complex as you make out






Our population has gone up by millions. Most are of an age where they will have children in the future. This puts a strain on maternity wards. People get ill. People need operations. And after all that as you say people live longer. So will thise who come to live here. And we don't have enough hospitals or staff for even the present number living here. Yet you try to deny it being a problem.



So you finally admit that we have a severe shortage of homes. But you still say that we should have an open border for anyone with an EU passport :rolleyes:


And the more people that come here to live the more people there will be who will want a car. Or hasn't that registered with you?


Living on an island means you have limited space. We are not massive like France or Germany.



I hope you get sorted. You chose Germany as a home decades ago. But with this you don't seem ti have a clue about the reality of what has happened here.



Don't worry. We need all the homes here for people already here.



The EU make the rules. We have to try our best to survive within these rules. Just like we have for many years now.

Housing issues are complex... as others in here keep telling you.

We need children being born as the next generation of pensioners will have to be cared for as well as my generation who will still be alive ( I hope ).

The younger fit EU immigrants at the moment are a bonus for the economy, which despite your negativity is still doing well. Wait til we leave ;-). They take up less health care than many of our ageing population.

The people who want or can afford cars are not necessarily those doing low paid jobs e.g. in catering. Still no reason for infrastructure not being a priority.

Germany is pretty built up except for mountains etc., and areas where there is no industry/ jobs.

I do have a clue as to what is happening in Cov, but not in the beautiful low populated area of Cumbria. Maybe I should buy a house there instead, and put a flagpole with an EU flag in the garden. Then I would feel at home... ;-).

The rules of the EU are the ones we helped make. The extension eastwards was what we wanted. Letting Poles, Romanians and Bulgarians in to live and work years earlier than needed or as e.g. in Germany, was The UK‘s idea. Having pushed for eastwards expansion and therefore, more immigrants, we are leaving because of er... too many immigrants, and people like you blame the EU.... you cannot make this up...
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
Housing issues are complex... as others in here keep telling you.

We need children being born as the next generation of pensioners will have to be cared for as well as my generation who will still be alive ( I hope ).

The younger fit EU immigrants at the moment are a bonus for the economy, which despite your negativity is still doing well. Wait til we leave ;-). They take up less health care than many of our ageing population.

The people who want or can afford cars are not necessarily those doing low paid jobs e.g. in catering. Still no reason for infrastructure not being a priority.

Germany is pretty built up except for mountains etc., and areas where there is no industry/ jobs.

I do have a clue as to what is happening in Cov, but not in the beautiful low populated area of Cumbria. Maybe I should buy a house there instead, and put a flagpole with an EU flag in the garden. Then I would feel at home... ;-).

The rules of the EU are the ones we helped make. The extension eastwards was what we wanted. Letting Poles, Romanians and Bulgarians in to live and work years earlier than needed or as e.g. in Germany, was The UK‘s idea. Having pushed for eastwards expansion and therefore, more immigrants, we are leaving because of er... too many immigrants, and people like you blame the EU.... you cannot make this up...
Are you trying to pretend that I don't know about our problems, how they have come about or what we should do about them?

I have said several times. But all that registers with you is anyone saying we should sort out the problems before we let millions more people live here.

We helped make the rules? If you want a debate can you keep to the truth? We joined the common market. It became the EU where we don't get much of a say. And we certainly didn't ask for open borders for anyone with an EU passport.

Yes Cumbria is a great place to live. But it doesn't mean that I don't know what goes in elsewhere. Our nearest family are about 200 miles away. So we travel around a lot. Visitors can't believe it when they can get to see a doctor straight away when they are nit even registered here. Or when they walk into a hospital and get seen straight away. It is also cheap and easy to find somewhere to live. And it is a great place to live. We don't have homeless on the streets. I have to explain it to my kids when we go elsewhere. They just don't get it.

But you are so pro EU that you don't care how much people are suffering as long as you keep what you want.
 

martcov

Well-Known Member
Are you trying to pretend that I don't know about our problems, how they have come about or what we should do about them?

I have said several times. But all that registers with you is anyone saying we should sort out the problems before we let millions more people live here.

We helped make the rules? If you want a debate can you keep to the truth? We joined the common market. It became the EU where we don't get much of a say. And we certainly didn't ask for open borders for anyone with an EU passport.

Yes Cumbria is a great place to live. But it doesn't mean that I don't know what goes in elsewhere. Our nearest family are about 200 miles away. So we travel around a lot. Visitors can't believe it when they can get to see a doctor straight away when they are nit even registered here. Or when they walk into a hospital and get seen straight away. It is also cheap and easy to find somewhere to live. And it is a great place to live. We don't have homeless on the streets. I have to explain it to my kids when we go elsewhere. They just don't get it.

But you are so pro EU that you don't care how much people are suffering as long as you keep what you want.

We have been in the EU since 1973. we had a vote in 1975 to stay in the common market with a convincing 2:1 majority to stay in. Our successive governments have ratified every step of the way with a couple of „get out“ options where we couldn’t agree. Some things were our ideas and we had as much say based on population size as anyone else. If the others don’t agree with all our requests it doesn’t make it undemocratic. It would be undemocratic if we did always get our way. We did ask for the SM and CU under Thatcher. Which means we did ask for FOM. That was before the Tories fell under the influence of the Farage UKIP vote and the DUP.

Being pro EU means I do care about citizens rights and don’t think the people suffering now will be the slightest bit better off under a Tory Brexit Britain.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
We have been in the EU since 1973. we had a vote in 1975 to stay in the common market with a convincing 2:1 majority to stay in. Our successive governments have ratified every step of the way with a couple of „get out“ options where we couldn’t agree. Some things were our ideas and we had as much say based on population size as anyone else. If the others don’t agree with all our requests it doesn’t make it undemocratic. It would be undemocratic if we did always get our way. We did ask for the SM and CU under Thatcher. Which means we did ask for FOM. That was before the Tories fell under the influence of the Farage UKIP vote and the DUP.

Being pro EU means I do care about citizens rights and don’t think the people suffering now will be the slightest bit better off under a Tory Brexit Britain.

Did we have a public vote to agree the Maastricht treaty which hugely changed the Eu in terms of what it offered?
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
We have been in the EU since 1973. we had a vote in 1975 to stay in the common market with a convincing 2:1 majority to stay in. Our successive governments have ratified every step of the way with a couple of „get out“ options where we couldn’t agree. Some things were our ideas and we had as much say based on population size as anyone else. If the others don’t agree with all our requests it doesn’t make it undemocratic. It would be undemocratic if we did always get our way. We did ask for the SM and CU under Thatcher. Which means we did ask for FOM. That was before the Tories fell under the influence of the Farage UKIP vote and the DUP.

Being pro EU means I do care about citizens rights and don’t think the people suffering now will be the slightest bit better off under a Tory Brexit Britain.
Wrong.

We joined the common market. We voted to stay in the common market. We have not been in the EU since 1973. That came much later.

A lot has changed in over 40 years since there was a vote.
 

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
And here is more good news. Something else that wouldn't happen if you listened to the aame experts that said house prices would crash and the unemployment rate would soar.

Pound remains close to post-Brexit high

The pound fell sharply against the euro following the referendum and has not been back above €1.20 since.

The euro strengthened in 2017 on the back of an improving eurozone economy and predictions that the ECB could start to scale back its bond-buying programme.

That's all very weird when the EU and € were both on the verge of collapsing following on from the vote to leave.
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
The pound fell sharply against the euro following the referendum and has not been back above €1.20 since.

The euro strengthened in 2017 on the back of an improving eurozone economy and predictions that the ECB could start to scale back its bond-buying programme.

That's all very weird when the EU and € were both on the verge of collapsing following on from the vote to leave.
You don't half know how to twist things around.

The £ is nearly back to where it was before the Brexit vote. This wasn't supposed to happen. But like I said house prices were also supposed to crash and unemployment was supposed to soar. And many on here were commentung on the € being worth 1 for 1 with the £.

And isn't it strange how you paste the small bit that looks good for the € in an article from a pro EU that is supposed to be impartial news outlet.

Look at the comments at end of the article. People have had enough of the pro EU crap.
 

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
You don't half know how to twist things around.

The £ is nearly back to where it was before the Brexit vote. This wasn't supposed to happen. But like I said house prices were also supposed to crash and unemployment was supposed to soar. And many on here were commentung on the € being worth 1 for 1 with the £.

And isn't it strange how you paste the small bit that looks good for the € in an article from a pro EU that is supposed to be impartial news outlet.

Look at the comments at end of the article. People have had enough of the pro EU crap.

Can you point out where it has made significant gains against the €?

From my quick glance at the article it was focusing on the £ vs $?
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
Did we have a public vote to agree the Maastricht treaty which hugely changed the Eu in terms of what it offered?

So were the basis of the three pillars in the Tory 1987 manifesto? Between the signing of the Maastricht and it come into effect we had a General Election that according to the opinion polls John Major was going to lose and he won convincingly. We may not have had a referendum but there’s absolutely nothing to suggest that the country was against it at the time.
 

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
So were the basis of the three pillars in the Tory 1987 manifesto? Between the signing of the Maastricht and it come into effect we had a General Election that according to the opinion polls John Major was going to lose and he won convincingly. We may not have had a referendum but there’s absolutely nothing to suggest that the country was against it at the time.

Indeed, he tried to claim that the public overwhelming endorsed Brexit at the recent election, so presumably he'd agree with you
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
So were the basis of the three pillars in the Tory 1987 manifesto? Between the signing of the Maastricht and it come into effect we had a General Election that according to the opinion polls John Major was going to lose and he won convincingly. We may not have had a referendum but there’s absolutely nothing to suggest that the country was against it at the time.
Hello racist Tony. Are you back to tell us about you voting UKIP and to defend them again?
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
You don't half know how to twist things around.

The £ is nearly back to where it was before the Brexit vote. This wasn't supposed to happen. But like I said house prices were also supposed to crash and unemployment was supposed to soar. And many on here were commentung on the € being worth 1 for 1 with the £.

And isn't it strange how you paste the small bit that looks good for the € in an article from a pro EU that is supposed to be impartial news outlet.

Look at the comments at end of the article. People have had enough of the pro EU crap.

Before the referendum you could get anywhere between €1.40 to €1.50 to the pound. Early in the evening when everyone thought that remain would win it peaked above €1.50 so I’m not sure how you work out that it’s where it was before the referendum. It crashed against everything not just the Euro either.

The ECB are supposed to be considering stopping quantitative easing on the Euro this year. Be interesting to see what happens to the value of the Euro then.
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
Hello racist Tony. Are you back to tell us about you voting UKIP and to defend them again?

Can’t argue the point so attacks the man. I’m glad that you know I voted UKIP in a European election even if you ignore my reasoning. If nothing else it confirms you’re talking shit and with very little questioning your opinion turns to dust and you attack the person like some school yard bully.

How old are you out of interest?
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
Before the referendum you could get anywhere between €1.40 to €1.50 to the pound. Early in the evening when everyone thought that remain would win it peaked above €1.50 so I’m not sure how you work out that it’s where it was before the referendum. It crashed against everything not just the Euro either.

The ECB are supposed to be considering stopping quantitative easing on the Euro this year. Be interesting to see what happens to the value of the Euro then.
Racist Tony gets it wrong again. It was 1:3017

Brexit Exchange Rate Tracker (GBP/EUR/USD/CAD) | finder UK
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
Can’t argue the point so attacks the man. I’m glad that you know I voted UKIP in a European election even if you ignore my reasoning. If nothing else it confirms you’re talking shit and with very little questioning your opinion turns to dust and you attack the person like some school yard bully.

How old are you out of interest?
So you wanted to stay in the EU but voted UKIP and defended them. Ask on here what that makes you. We have all been told UKIP voters are racist. And you didn't vote for them to get out of the EU.
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
It's still quite a way off its previous highs, strange considering that it's a basket case currency, apparently.
So who called it that?

More like the £ was supposed to be and we were supposed to get to £ and € worth the same.

Just shows that the pro EU experts didn't get much right.
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
Did you actually read the first paragraph where it confirmed that the pound fell 19%? Thanks for link that confirms I’m right. You must be a racist sympathiser. I guess that makes you a racist too.
I don't sympathise with you. Have never voted UKIP and never will.

Yes it did fall 19%. But it isn't 19% lower now is it. And is still rising against the €.

Bit of a difference between the 1:50 you said and the 1:30 it was. Not like you to exaggerate is it racist Tony.......
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
No. Did we have a vote on the Falklands War, Iraq or Syria? We have a parliament which is sovereign. „sovereignty“ is what you want.
Are you saying that the EU was against it?
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
Speculation on 1. a rise in interest rates and 2. good negotiations with the EU 3. hoping for lax controls on black money in a no deal situation ( when repatriating profits)
It dropped 19% because of speculation. But I suppose you will try and call it something else.
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
So you wanted to stay in the EU but voted UKIP and defended them. Ask on here what that makes you. We have all been told UKIP voters are racist. And you didn't vote for them to get out of the EU.

Didn’t you repeatedly claim to vote remain before becoming the EU’s biggest boo boy? I think you’re hardly anyone to judge on that score.

I voted UKIP ahead of David Cameron’s negotiations ahead of the referendum. I know what the EU is and I know what it isn’t. I knew it wouldn’t reform willingly unless they thought that there was a real chance of us voting leave. So I took my vote in the European election and voted UKIP as I saw it as the only voice I had to say to the EU you better take this seriously. I had grave doubts about the outcome of the referendum from the day it was announced it was happening. Being so close didn’t come as a surprise to me and I always thought that unless David Cameron came back with anything less than what he was asking for a leave win was inevitable. I actually thought it would be a bigger margin than it was.

So no I’m not a racist. No I didn’t vote UKIP as an endorsement of their policies (ironically something that you practically spout every time you post on the subject) and yes I used my vote as a protest vote. Not to protest to leave but to protest for reform.

So you carry on calling me a racist if you like, it really doesn’t bother me. All it confirms is that you are A) a childish, name calling school type bully and B) wrong and lack the intellect to argue the point so you resort to name calling instead. It says considerably more about the type of person you are than it ever will about me so carry on.
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
I don't sympathise with you. Have never voted UKIP and never will.

Yes it did fall 19%. But it isn't 19% lower now is it. And is still rising against the €.

Bit of a difference between the 1:50 you said and the 1:30 it was. Not like you to exaggerate is it racist Tony.......
You spout the same nonsense UKIP spout every time you post. You’re the very epitome of a UKIP sympathiser.

Like I said. Let’s see what the Euro does if the ECB relax or stop quantitative easing.
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
Didn’t you repeatedly claim to vote remain before becoming the EU’s biggest boo boy? I think you’re hardly anyone to judge on that score.

I voted UKIP ahead of David Cameron’s negotiations ahead of the referendum. I know what the EU is and I know what it isn’t. I knew it wouldn’t reform willingly unless they thought that there was a real chance of us voting leave. So I took my vote in the European election and voted UKIP as I saw it as the only voice I had to say to the EU you better take this seriously. I had grave doubts about the outcome of the referendum from the day it was announced it was happening. Being so close didn’t come as a surprise to me and I always thought that unless David Cameron came back with anything less than what he was asking for a leave win was inevitable. I actually thought it would be a bigger margin than it was.

So no I’m not a racist. No I didn’t vote UKIP as an endorsement of their policies (ironically something that you practically spout every time you post on the subject) and yes I used my vote as a protest vote. Not to protest to leave but to protest for reform.

So you carry on calling me a racist if you like, it really doesn’t bother me. All it confirms is that you are A) a childish, name calling school type bully and B) wrong and lack the intellect to argue the point so you resort to name calling instead. It says considerably more about the type of person you are than it ever will about me so carry on.
Knew your comment was going to be full of shite after the first line so didn't read the rest.

I started off playing devils advocate. Trying to put both sides over. But only one side ever comes out. A massive bias for the EU. Everything bad about us being overpopulated or bad against the EU gets ignored. So I have ended up pointing out the lies. Like the £ € was 1:50 before the Brexit vote.
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
You spout the same nonsense UKIP spout every time you post. You’re the very epitome of a UKIP sympathiser.

Like I said. Let’s see what the Euro does if the ECB relax or stop quantitative easing.
So you vote UKIP and defend them yet accuse me of the same.


Would you like to point out me defending UKIP like you have done racist Tony?
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
Knew your comment was going to be full of shite after the first line so didn't read the rest.

I started off playing devils advocate. Trying to put both sides over. But only one side ever comes out. A massive bias for the EU. Everything bad about us being overpopulated or bad against the EU gets ignored. So I have ended up pointing out the lies. Like the £ € was 1:50 before the Brexit vote.
That’s a yes then. Thanks for the confirmation.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top