Coronavirus Thread (Off Topic, Politics) (166 Viewers)

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
So hes American by birth then yes?
That twat david has Irish parentage but was born here,has never lived in Ireland but would rather identify as Irish for some freak reason. You think that's normal?

Most African-Americans have never been near Africa and their families haven't been to Africa in generations. Still identify as African-American rather than just American. We have a similar thing here with Indian/Pakistani communities that have never set foot in those countries but identify as such.

My auntie was born in Belfast but was brought here after two days. She considers herself English. Yet bizarrely she considers my other nan Welsh even though she was born here and couldn't speak any Welsh just because her Welsh parents gave her a Welsh name.
 

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
I think the whole concept of nationality is silly TBH. From a technical point if you’re born there that’s your nationality. But identity is funny. I know people who aren’t black but have black heritage and are proud of it.

Like Elizabeth Warren and her native American heritage. Although that is also probably partly due to political angle as well.
 

Alan Dugdales Moustache

Well-Known Member
I havent got a clue but I guess he doesnt pretend to be from another country. Why would you do that?
Haha. Cometh at Patrick's Day lots of English people pretend they're Irish. Always makes me laugh.
 

The coventrian

Well-Known Member
Haha. Cometh at Patrick's Day lots of English people pretend they're Irish. Always makes me laugh.

Plastic dave does it full time. He says hes Irish but he wasn't born or has never lived there lol. Apparently he was brought up Irish in willenhall in Coventry in England.

Identify crisis. I wonder if he puts the accent on and sups Guinness when he's there. If he ever goes there that is.
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Plastic dave does it full time. He says hes Irish but he wasn't born or has never lived there lol. Apparently he was brought up Irish in willenhall in Coventry in England.

Identify crisis. I wonder if he puts the accent on and sups Guinness when he's there. If he ever goes there that is.

Is nationality defined by being born somewhere or your parents both having that nationality? Is my missus Scottish because she was born there or English because her parents are? What a bizarre tangent
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Plastic dave does it full time. He says hes Irish but he wasn't born or has never lived there lol. Apparently he was brought up Irish in willenhall in Coventry in England.

Identify crisis. I wonder if he puts the accent on and sups Guinness when he's there. If he ever goes there that is.

You don't have to have been born or lived somewhere to be of that nationality. You don't even have to have ever visited there.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Is nationality defined by being born somewhere or your parents both having that nationality? Is my missus Scottish because she was born there or English because her parents are? What a bizarre tangent

She’s British
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Plastic dave does it full time. He says hes Irish but he wasn't born or has never lived there lol. Apparently he was brought up Irish in willenhall in Coventry in England.

Identify crisis. I wonder if he puts the accent on and sups Guinness when he's there. If he ever goes there that is.

He was probably conceived after a gallon of Guinness
 

Alan Dugdales Moustache

Well-Known Member
Is nationality defined by being born somewhere or your parents both having that nationality? Is my missus Scottish because she was born there or English because her parents are? What a bizarre tangent
Shouldn't you be knee deep in school work ?
 

Ring Of Steel

Well-Known Member
.....whenever that is !

I've never understood the Patricks Day animosity- on St Georges Day nobody cares and nobody pretends they're English, on St Patricks Day the whole world turns green, everyone is suddenly Irish & you're subjected to the absolute worst music on planet earth all day, and some get all bent out of shape about it like its treason. Can only assume its a historical thing and a heritage thing- Patricks Day in Ireland itself is nowhere near as much of a party as it seems to be elsewhere. Its a bigger deal to hold onto that heritage when you are living away I guess. But ultimately its only an excuse for a day on the piss, a big party, its not some kind of xenophobic statement- who really cares?
 

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
I was born in England to Irish parents but spent half of my early childhood in Ireland and didn’t get a British passport until quite late.
I consider myself both but identify more as Irish, especially outside of England, maybe because of living there when younger.
 

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
I've never understood the Patricks Day animosity- on St Georges Day nobody cares and nobody pretends they're English, on St Patricks Day the whole world turns green, everyone is suddenly Irish & you're subjected to the absolute worst music on planet earth all day, and some get all bent out of shape about it like its treason. Can only assume its a historical thing and a heritage thing- Patricks Day in Ireland itself is nowhere near as much of a party as it seems to be elsewhere. Its a bigger deal to hold onto that heritage when you are living away I guess. But ultimately its only an excuse for a day on the piss, a big party, its not some kind of xenophobic statement- who really cares?
St Patrick’s day in the UK is utter shite.
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
I've never understood the Patricks Day animosity- on St Georges Day nobody cares and nobody pretends they're English, on St Patricks Day the whole world turns green, everyone is suddenly Irish & you're subjected to the absolute worst music on planet earth all day, and some get all bent out of shape about it like its treason. Can only assume its a historical thing and a heritage thing- Patricks Day in Ireland itself is nowhere near as much of a party as it seems to be elsewhere. Its a bigger deal to hold onto that heritage when you are living away I guess. But ultimately its only an excuse for a day on the piss, a big party, its not some kind of xenophobic statement- who really cares?
Admittedly I don't get why we ignore St George's Day so much either - just allows a space for the racists to take it over, really.
 

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
I've never understood the Patricks Day animosity- on St Georges Day nobody cares and nobody pretends they're English, on St Patricks Day the whole world turns green, everyone is suddenly Irish & you're subjected to the absolute worst music on planet earth all day, and some get all bent out of shape about it like its treason. Can only assume its a historical thing and a heritage thing- Patricks Day in Ireland itself is nowhere near as much of a party as it seems to be elsewhere. Its a bigger deal to hold onto that heritage when you are living away I guess. But ultimately its only an excuse for a day on the piss, a big party, its not some kind of xenophobic statement- who really cares?

This hits the nail on the head. You could have the biggest Patrick's Day you like but no alcohol allowed and no-one would turn up.
 

Ring Of Steel

Well-Known Member
Plastic dave does it full time. He says hes Irish but he wasn't born or has never lived there lol. Apparently he was brought up Irish in willenhall in Coventry in England.

Identify crisis. I wonder if he puts the accent on and sups Guinness when he's there. If he ever goes there that is.

I remember in Italia '90 most people I knew were supporting Ireland, not England, Cov has one of the biggest proportions of Irish of any city in the country, I think I saw it was estimated at 10% having Irish heritage.

I don't see the problem or why it matters.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
I hate it- the music is just terrible for a start, I can't stand it. That day and Halloween- stay inside and pretend nobody is at home.

But you don’t live here and have renounced your citizenship
 

Ring Of Steel

Well-Known Member
Admittedly I don't get why we ignore St George's Day so much either - just allows a space for the racists to take it over, really.

There is probably some historical & psychological reason behind it, anyway its probably a good thing as I couldn't handle a day of Morris Dancing & folk music just a few weeks after a full day of Irish music blasting out of everywhere.
 

Alan Dugdales Moustache

Well-Known Member
If you were born in one country and have that on your birth certificate, move to another at a young age, pick up the language , culture, etc then you are more than likely to feel a sense of belonging and association to it. You're birth certificate may say different, but it's your life's experiences that determine what you actually feel about where you are from .
I do think if you have absolutely no recollection of your country of birth and grow up elsewhere it would be difficult to feel much sense of being of the nationality that might be on you're birth certificate.
 

skybluetony176

Well-Known Member
I went to Turkey once I think I'll identify as a turk from now on.
That’s you and Boris then who identify as Turkish. Well, audience depending when it comes to Boris. Although Boris did spend large parts of his childhood being raised in Belgium too. So we have an American, Belgian, Turkish PM who invented the character Boris as you know him some time during his university years. What’s your problem again with David identifying as Irish?
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Another two weeks off for Boris incoming?

What with a few hours work PMQs yesterday it's been a busy week for him, so he is probably worn out and ready for a rest.

"But the spokesman did not go as far as saying that he was confident that Johnson would not be asked to self-isolate if Sharma tested positive. Asked if Johnson would comply if he were asked to self-isolate, the spokesman said: “We would follow the advice given by the medical experts.” "
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top