ATs got his badges (22 Viewers)

[Grendel]

Yet despite all of this the majority of fans still support him.

There must be a pretty damn good reason for this!

Rubbish. The majority are apathetic and would just shrug their shoulders if he was sacked tomorrow.

 

---

[Gaz]

We were odds on to go down before we even kicked a ball this season.
That to me shows that outsiders could see quite clearly that our squad wasn't good enough for our league.
But lets get real, it's all Thorns fault, he wanted to sell our top scorer in January didn't he, it was his master plan all along to cut the playing squad back that much that it would hide the fact he is a poor manager who is just after a pay packet.
After all he just worships the Sisu dollar doesn't he.

Did you know that Ice Cream sales in the UK decline as the sale of umbrellas increase? Why is that do you think? One may make an assumption it is to do with the seasonal impact on both products. In other words the two facts are not related.

You put together a list of facts as to why the club is struggling - namely financial adversity. These neither make Thorn a good manager or a bad one. I think he's a bad manager and the surrounding circumstance prop him up.

Do you honestly think a new investor would really keep him as manager. Name me a new owner of any football club with sizeable investment that keeps a manager (unless its Wenger or Ferguson). Get real.

 

[Gaz]

What are you going on about ?

Do you even know yourself ??

I can handle it, laddie...what were the **** representing?

Yes, you are right, though, going to the games is very much tripe and doesn't count...:facepalm:

As for your 'even if I don't go to the games, my opinion is just as important'....if you have that opinion, then I can understand you accepting the 'tripe' served by Teflon...as you don't pay to endure it.....:thinking about:

 

[Grendel]

We were odds on to go down before we even kicked a ball this season.
That to me shows that outsiders could see quite clearly that our squad wasn't good enough for our league.
But lets get real, it's all Thorns fault, he wanted to sell our top scorer in January didn't he, it was his master plan all along to cut the playing squad back that much that it would hide the fact he is a poor manager who is just after a pay packet.
After all he just worships the Sisu dollar doesn't he.

4th favourites this season to be promoted?:thinking about::thinking about:

 

[dongonzalos]

If you place so much stock on what the bookies say...they have us as fourth favourites for this league.

So by your misguided view if Teflon guides us to lower than 4th he has failed...is that what you are saying????

Or is the point where you realise the considerable flaws in your argument.....

Maybe it is worth waiting to see our odds at the end of the summer. I dont think we were odds on favourites for relegation last season till a few days before the season started and the bookies got to see the SISU effect

http://forum.punterslounge.com/threads/130390-England-gt-Antepost-gt-League-One-2012-2013?p=2170352

(second post down makes good reading)

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

What was our run of results over the last 15 games before he took over over for the last ten?

Why choose just those games? Let's look at the first 10 games of the season...15 points, one more than the great man himself, and where every game counted, not when half of our opponents had nothing to play for or were trying to avoid injuries,.....

 

[Gaz]

Ah right... My opinion being different from yours proves I don't go to the games.

Well done.

Jeez...that comment proves that you haven't been to a game under Teflon's tenure if you think that his failure to motivate and organise has '...not been proved...'.

Try this to help you, sonny....

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/eng_div_1/table/default.stm

If your next post is 'what does that prove'....I deplore you not to post it as it really will embarrass you and show a total lack of understanding of one of the key fundamentals of the game...WINNING FOOTBALL MATCHES....:wave:

 

[dongonzalos]

Rubbish. The majority are apathetic and would just shrug their shoulders if he was sacked tomorrow.

Agree however if they blamed Thorn you would hear about it.

Even when you have a poll on here the majority support him

People blame SISU and you hear about it.

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

4th favourites this season to be promoted?:thinking about::thinking about:

3rd in some places, jeez, I hope the course was good, Teflon's been put under some pressure by gaz.....:claping hands:

 

[dongonzalos]

Why choose just those games? Let's look at the first 10 games of the season...15 points, one more than the great man himself, and where every game counted, not when half of our opponents had nothing to play for or were trying to avoid injuries,.....

Because it was those games that had us plummenting down the table heading for relegation.

Because when he joined us Colchester fans said he will have a good first half of a season with you. Then the teams who have played you once will work out the long ball tactic and block it. Then you will have a crap second half of the season. He will have no other plan.

The seemed to be right.

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

Ah right... My opinion being different from yours proves I don't go to the games.

Well done.

That's a mature way to progress the argument.

What about your 'bookies say' argument?

What about 'his lack of motivation/organisation has not been proving as a failure'....any further argument to persuade us otherwise that Teflon has failed.

That is the point of a forum after all, isn't it ****....

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

Because it was those games that had us plummenting down the table heading for relegation.

Because when he joined us Colchester fans said he will have a good first half of a season with you. Then the teams who have played you once will work out the long ball tactic and block it. Then you will have a crap second half of the season. He will have no other plan.

The seemed to be right.

As opposed to AT who gave us a shite season throughout.

As for AB, I think Northampton are a knocking bet for promotion next year.

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

Ah right... My opinion being different from yours proves I don't go to the games.

Well done.

You need to learn to read posts...and understand them.

Ask your teacher next week, ****.....:wave:

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

The **** are kisses by the way, gaz.....

 

[Gaz]

What that shows to me is that the bookies last season had us down to struggle
Next season then expect us to be challenging to go up.

But hey, let's not twist things to help support our quest to blame the manager and get a new one in.

It's so obvious that changing the manager helps you improve.
I mean Ccfc are a great example of this.

If you place so much stock on what the bookies say...they have us as fourth favourites for this league.

So by your misguided view if Teflon guides us to lower than 4th he has failed...is that what you are saying????

Or is the point where you realise the considerable flaws in your argument.....

 

[dongonzalos]

As opposed to AT who gave us a shite season throughout.

As for AB, I think Northampton are a knocking bet for promotion next year.

Yes maybe he has found his level and maybe we will need him next year

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

You used the bookies argument to prove that there was nothing AT could do but fail last season.

Based on that premise, he should do well this season....the point here is that to use that as an excuse is flawed.

Are you having some cake and eating it, gaz?

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

It's so obvious that changing the manager helps you improve.
I mean Ccfc are a great example of this.

No, gaz, we are a great example of sticking with a bloke with a win record of 9 in 48 last year.

I really hope he succeeds, but what have you REALLY seen as evidence that this is likely to happen????:thinking about:

 

[SkyBlue_Bear83]

Are you sure?:thinking about:

Just checked, he took them up and then he left them when they were bottom of the table in January to manager Preston. Peterborough were relegated and then he took them back up again from league 1.

So I was nearly right

 

[Gaz]

Based on that premise, he should do well this season....the point here is that to use that as an excuse is flawed.

Are you having some cake and eating it, gaz?

How is that flawed ?
Have we already failed to go up ?
Funny, I didn't even know this season had kicked off yet.

 

[dongonzalos]

:jerkit::jerkit:

ahhh thats not nice, what a shame

 

[SkyBlue_Bear83]

All manager debates are meaningless unless you can suggest someone better who we can attract, afford and willing to work with the current board an owners.

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

But by your logic, we should finish in the top 3 or 4 as that is what the bookies say?

Isn't that what you posted, based on the season just gone...'we did shite, but that was expected as the bookies said so, so that proves that we can't have a go at Teflon'?

Then your strange 'prayer' post, hopefully not sinister, just tried to deflect from your pointless argument.....

Face it, sonny, Teflon has to carry some of the blame...to do otherwise is just avoiding the harsh reality of his significant failures....:facepalm:

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

All manager debates are meaningless unless you can suggest someone better who we can attract, afford and willing to work with the current board an owners.

So we stick with the failure we have in post?!

 

[Grendel]

ahhh thats not nice, what a shame

To be fair I meant the facepalm symbol - sorry about that.

 

[LeamingtonBootBoy]

Does AT give the senior players an easy ride?

Is that another reason for our pathetic showing last season?

 

[Gaz]

I really hope he succeeds, but what have you REALLY seen as evidence that this is likely to happen????:thinking about:

Well how can I have seen any evidence, as you have already "proved" that I havn't gone to any games .... Remember.

Or was you just being being silly then ?

 

[dongonzalos]

To be fair I meant the facepalm symbol - sorry about that.

Ha ha fair dues no worries, not seen you come out with that one before

 

[dongonzalos]

Seems like there is a big wheel.

Pro thorn =
He did well before he had players took off him that were not replaced sufficiently. What are the alternatives? How can you judge him ehrn he is never given a fair crack of the whip by the owners. The football is better to watch. He can spot a good player. He appreciates the fans. He seems genuine and honest. He did have a pop at SISU. SISU pretty much admitted they caused us to be relegated with their business plan

Anti Thorn.

The spell in which he did well was 10 games a honeymoon period. A good manager would still do well despite losing all those players. He actually likes SISU as anyone else would sack him. He lacks a plan B. He does not make subsitutions quick eneough. he is not experienced enough. He is too easy on the players. He does not come across well in the media. How can we do ok at home but not away that must be due to his managerial experience. He got Bell and Baker contract extensions.

Then we go round in circles debating all these points.

Is it fair to say if the club sign 7-12 (Depending on how many go out the door) experienced league one players with a mixture of decent premier league loanees then AT will have no excuse and can be judged purely on results as he will have a squad that is good enough to compete and should compete.

If however it is Murphy, Clarke, Bell, Cody, Baker, Hussey, Cameron, Dunn, Sheff and a further 19 players under the age of 20 then would it be fair to say that it is going to be pretty hard to judge AT and avoiding relegation would be a job well done?

 

[Gaz]

What I posted was that the bookies had us down for relegation before the season had started.
Clearly this was based on the squad we had.

For this season coming we are one of the favourites to go up.
Now as long as the squad is good enough to compete for promotion in league one, then I fully expect us to make the play offs.
If we don't then that would be a fail.
Big question is if the squad will be good enough to compete for promotion though.

Not sure how this view of mine is flawed as you say but hey keep talking about teachers if that in someways helps you.....

But by your logic, we should finish in the top 3 or 4 as that is what the bookies say?

Isn't that what you posted, based on the season just gone...'we did shite, but that was expected as the bookies said so, so that proves that we can't have a go at Teflon'?

Then your strange 'prayer' post, hopefully not sinister, just tried to deflect from your pointless argument.....

Face it, sonny, Teflon has to carry some of the blame...to do otherwise is just avoiding the harsh reality of his significant failures....:facepalm:

 

[Macca]

Nope.

And If I wanted to swear then I would have.

Hope this helps :wave:

Have you tried HRT ?

 

[cheever]

Well how can I have seen any evidence, as you have already "proved" that I havn't gone to any games .... Remember.

Or was you just being being silly then ?

Oh dear, someone doesn't know how to debate a point.....

Chill, gaz, man....you been done, innit!

 

[cheever]

What I posted was that the bookies had us down for relegation before the season had started.
Clearly this was based on the squad we had.

For this season coming we are one of the favourites to go up.
Now as long as the squad is good enough to compete for promotion in league one, then I fully expect us to make the play offs.
If we don't then that would be a fail.
Big question is if the squad will be good enough to compete for promotion though.

Not sure how this view of mine is flawed as you say but hey keep talking about teachers if that in someways helps you.....

I read it that you, gaz, used the bookies as an argument to defend Thorn's 'efforts' last season.
I believe that LBB, based on YOUR example, has stated that as we are 4th favourites Thorny should get this team to fourth place or higher.

It was your example being used, gaz. It seems that you wanted to use it to support Thorn's poor showing last season, possibly to hide behind/as an excuse, but when it is used to show how he should be performing in this season coming, you don't want to use it.

According to your barometer - the bookies - Thorn should have us in 4th place......:thinking about:

As an aside, I agree with you and think Thorny has been between a rock and a hard place, but I must admit that I did wonder about his tactics and motivational ability after watching every home game and some away games last season. Hopefully, now that he has his badges, we'll see a Plan B on the pitch, and a better trained squad of players?

 

[Astute]

I read it that you, gaz, used the bookies as an argument to defend Thorn's 'efforts' last season.
I believe that LBB, based on YOUR example, has stated that as we are 4th favourites Thorny should get this team to fourth place or higher.

It was your example being used, gaz. It seems that you wanted to use it to support Thorn's poor showing last season, possibly to hide behind/as an excuse, but when it is used to show how he should be performing in this season coming, you don't want to use it.

According to your barometer - the bookies - Thorn should have us in 4th place......:thinking about:

As an aside, I agree with you and think Thorny has been between a rock and a hard place, but I must admit that I did wondier about his tactics and motivational ability after watching every home game and some away games last season. Hopefully, now that he has his badges, we'll see a Plan B on the pitch, and a better trained squad of players?

You are LBB Unless you share a PC that is

 

[oldskyblue58]

As someone with some FA qualifications I think what the badges should give AT are alternative ways of thinking...... particularly ways of thinking as a coach or manager not an ex player..... there is a difference and not all players can or should be managers.

In particular it should help with the psychology of coaching and the ways he can consistently get the best out of all his players not just some. He will need to be adaptable, clear, focused and able to communicate well. Getting your badges is less about tactics and running around the training pitches ...... it is all about understanding the psychology and physiology in order to maximise performance. Yes AT is experienced but up until last year he was an experienced ex player with some scouting skills........ he still has a lot to learn before he is anywhere near an experienced coach or manager.

Assuming we do finally get some players in to have a decent League 1 squad in quality and numbers then for me if we struggle at the bottom of the division then sorry but AT is not the man to take us forward. Given that assumption then he has no where to hide this coming season.

just my opinion