Cardiff player ratings (3 Viewers)

[Tomh111]

You say the same thing even if we had Maldini and Cafu as our fullbacks.

They are league 1 talents.

I would if Maldini and Cafu kept getting trapped high up the pitch, giving the ball away and not stopping a fucking cross coming into the box.

Sent from my SM-S911B using Tapatalk

 

---

[JoeCCFCPUSB]

I would if Maldini and Cafu kept getting trapped high up the pitch, giving the ball away and not stopping a fucking cross coming into the box.

Sent from my SM-S911B using Tapatalk

I see ur point, but our centre backs just are not good enough

 

[Para1140]

Can only guess he's shithousing a move back home

Missing O’hare

 

[AOM]

Really poor today, that second half was the worst I've seen us play at home this season I think.

Not sure if Collins had any chance for either goal from where i was sitting, but he looks so nervous at times. Cardiff knew they could shoot from distance and we'd be under pressure.

Very few positives. Thought Simms looked okay, and was more suited to occupying three of their defenders at once than Bassette. Good goal from EMC as well.

Think we need to go back to Kitching and Thomas as the CB pairing

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

Collins spills basically everything. No wonder teams just shoot on sight

 

[Colin Steins Smile]

Collins 3. Doesn’t move his feet
MVE 3 Poor today
Binks 5
Thomas 5
DaSilva 1 Every team targets him says everything. He’s a liability.
Eccles 4 Sloppy
Sheaf 6 Tidy
Tats 5
Rudoni 5
Mason Clark 5 Worked hard
Bassette 4 Needs to improve heading

Subs
Torp 5
Thomas Assente 5
Simms 5

Overall poor defensively and slow predictable attacking

 

[Johhny Blue]

Missing O’hare

Not a bit

 

[SIR ERNIE]

Binks and Thomas are left woefully exposed by their fullbacks, consistently. That is our problem at the back, rather than the centre halves themselves.

Spot on and they're also getting no protection from the DMs in front of them.
They're exposed from all directions as soon as the opposition attack.

 

[fatso]

Worst home performance of the season by a mile.

Only player who looked any good was Binks.

Da Silva can fuck off, useless.

Sent from my SM-S911B using Tapatalk

Binks Great wind up mate

 

[torchomatic]

Didn't think Sheaf went hiding but agree with the rest

Sheaf is piss poor. Overrated garbage. If we can get any money for him then I'd gladly see the back of him. Eccles is twice the player.

 

[torchomatic]

He has a nice left foot on him and that seems to fool many. Doesn’t communicate and was bullied today. Shite. Nowhere near good enough.

Binks has one trick, to hit the ball as hard as he can, usually to no one.

 

[Monty]

Collins. 3
MVE 3
Dasilva 3
Thomas 4
Binks 3
Eccles 3
Sheaf 3
Rudoni 4
EMC 6
Bassette 4
Sakamoto 4

Torp 5
BTA 3
Simms 4

 

[stupot07]

Collins 4
Milan 2
Thomas 4
Binks 3
Dasilva 3
Eccles 4
Sheaf 5
Rudoni 5
Sakamoto 6 bonus point for the assist
Bassette 5
EMC 6 bonus point for the goal

Subs
Torp 6
Simms 5
BTA 6

 

[fatso]

Cheer up guys, it could be worse, at least we still have M.R.

 

[rob9872]

Collins 0
MVE 3
JDS 0
Thomas 5
Binks 4
Sheaf 5
Eccles 5
Rudi 5
Tats 5
Ephron 7 motm
Bassette 5

Torp 6
Simms 6
BTA 5

 

[shepardo01]

MVE was dreadful, what has happened to him?

He has nothing in front of him. First half his only outlet was Saka.
Rudoni has nothing in the #10 position and kills a lot of our forward momentum and EMC, when on the right in front of him in the 2nd half kept running away and cutting off any potential passing exchange that could take place.

 

[Calista]

Collins 0
MVE 3
JDS 0
Thomas 5
Binks 4
Sheaf 5
Eccles 5
Rudi 5
Tats 5
Ephron 7 motm
Bassette 5

Torp 6
Simms 6
BTA 5

I can't agree with some of your extreme low marks, but glad to see you've recognised the contribution from EMC. He's a good player and I really don't understand some of the harsh criticism he's been getting.

 

[rob9872]

I can't agree with some of your extreme low marks, but glad to see you've recognised the contribution from EMC. He's a good player and I really don't understand some of the harsh criticism he's been getting.

He's been good when he came on last couple of games too. Biggest issue is his best position is left of a front 3 which is the same as Wright. I really like both and would ideally like them both in, but playing players in their proper position is half the battle and why EMC looked better since Hajis injury.

 

[Ccfcisparks]

I can't agree with some of your extreme low marks, but glad to see you've recognised the contribution from EMC. He's a good player and I really don't understand some of the harsh criticism he's been getting.

he did nothing outside the goal.

 

[stupot07]

I can't agree with some of your extreme low marks, but glad to see you've recognised the contribution from EMC. He's a good player and I really don't understand some of the harsh criticism he's been getting.

I thought he was pretty average apart from the goal (as we're most of the team) but happy he finally got off the mark.

 

[Osabisa3256]

Sheaf is piss poor. Overrated garbage. If we can get any money for him then I'd gladly see the back of him. Eccles is twice the player.

What a load of rubbish you talk Eccles not fit to lace sheafs boots.he’s slow has no idea how to pass and move just throws his arms around all game and committing silly fouls.He will get found out by lampard and hopefully dumped from the team he’s one of the main reasons the midfield are struggling

 

[rob9872]

he did nothing outside the goal.

3 excellent crosses in the first half and was effective I'm the second with a couple of nice tricks until he had to switch wings when BTA came on and then his game petered out.

 

[rob9872]

What a load of rubbish you talk Eccles not fit to lace sheafs boots.he’s slow has no idea how to pass and move just throws his arms around all game and committing silly fouls.He will get found out by lampard and hopefully dumped from the team he’s one of the main reasons the midfield are struggling

Why does it have to be either or? I disagree strongly with Torch on Sheaf, but if you think Eccles has been poor this season I don't know what to say. He's been far our most consistent player and improved massively the past season.

 

[Osabisa3256]

Why does it have to be either or? I disagree strongly with Torch on Sheaf, but if you think Eccles has been poor this season I don't know what to say. He's been far our most consistent player and improved massively the past season.

League one player at best just another Shipley

 

[Ccfcisparks]

League one player at best just another Shipley

Worst take on this forum ever

 

[rob9872]

League one player at best just another Shipley

Ok so you're trolling. Who's second account is thus one Nick?

 

[covboy9]

I cannot believe how poorly we played, no energy listless going forward, shaky at the back. As a team performance it was painful allover the pitch

 

[stevefloyd]

Load up the turd reactions.

But Sakamoto is a one trick pony bag of shite. Absolute fanny.

Consistently out of position. Panics unless he’s got 5 seconds to get the ball under control to do his little trick, and if the time isn’t there feeds the ball back into whoever passed it to him leaving them in trouble.

Never know if you're being serious

 

[stevefloyd]

That’s my worry with Simms. Imagine being a striker who’s just won a penalty and then let’s someone else take it. That’s what sets players like Gyokeres apart, he’s grabbing that ball and there is no one that can stop him. Simms needs some of that attitude.

To be absolutely brutally fair I wouldn't put money on him hitting the target

 

[stevefloyd]

Binks has one trick, to hit the ball as hard as he can, usually to no one.

I don't know he hit 1 great ball crossfield today....straight to the ball boy

 

[skyblueelephant76]

Rudoni 7 is absolutely mental. Game of opinions I know but thought he was terrible.

Doesn’t offer enough and seems to just stand in positions he can’t get the ball. We need three in the middle to protect our abysmal defence - Rudoni is a passenger at times.

He was decent first half and picked up some great positions in between their midfield and defence. Second half he hid on the left and did nothing.

 

[stevefloyd]

League one player at best just another Shipley

I am no Eccles fan but he is way above Shipleys talent

 

[Calista]

he did nothing outside the goal.

Simply untrue

 

[Jarvo87]

Thoroughly atrocious performance. Another Saturday afternoon to question my sanity. All of the starting XI way off the standard required for Championship football, against a poor Cardiff side but at least they had some fight about them.

We were One paced, no movement/creativity. 62% possession acc to BBC stats!, a fair chunk it simply passing between the CB’s or backwards.

Can’t really be arsed to rate them but:
Keeper and back four no more than 2, apart from Thomas who was a 4 for me.

Their No 3 bossed the midfield; Rudoni did ok first half, surprised Eccles came out for the second half, Sheaf way off it all game.

Bassette started slowly but got into the game; EMC the only one with pace, spark and energy and took his goal well, my MOM, Saka awful other than the assist for the EMC goal.

Torp took the pen well, thought BTA was ok, Simms didn’t really impose himself.

Crowd really flat all game.

Lampard has got a tough gig on his hands based on today and Burnley.

 

[clint van damme]

League one player at best just another Shipley

League one troll at best, just another skybluedom