How's This Going To Help The English Game? (4 Viewers)

japandy · May 8, 2014

It's funny they say the reason to do this is because the loan system isn't working, but having check the England national teams current squad more than half have been out on loan during their career. The reason we have a below standard national team is because most Premier clubs do not have a scouting system in this country. If you ask any of the ten clubs if they have ever been to a non-league game or even Div 1 or 2 may be only Rodgers has done so. If Graham Carr was held in such high esteem for finding up and coming British players rather than all french ones they would have an arguement. The top managers totally neglect British football.

CCFC PimpRail · May 8, 2014

Why don't those clubs who want a B team "adopt" a lower club...? Man U could adopt CCFC and take over the Ricoh lease, it'd mean fans would have less far to travel from London to home games, and Cov is full of Man U fans anyway...

ccfcway · May 8, 2014

CCFC PimpRail said:
Why don't those clubs who want a B team "adopt" a lower club...? Man U could adopt CCFC and take over the Ricoh lease, it'd mean fans would have less far to travel from London to home games, and Cov is full of Man U fans anyway...

havent spurs pretty much adopted Swindon this season ?

SunZoomSpark · May 8, 2014

I don't get this....so a prem team has a b team....the b team win league 2 but the prem team get relegated ... So is there then no b team?.. Is there no promotion for the b team?...And where who takes over that prem teams b league place?...makes a mockery of the entire league....

Brighton Sky Blue · May 8, 2014

Evans1883 said:
To help the english game it should be mandatory that every club must start a match with 4-6 british players in the starting 11 , which would mean every club would need 8-10 british players in their squad

England isn't Britain.

Brighton Sky Blue · May 8, 2014

Grendel said:
I still believe this would be a restraint of trade. If a player has played a very high percent of internationals over a period of time it would be challenged.

Anyway Dyke is an opportunist fool. He is getting his day in the sun, ignore him and he will go away soon.

Well, yes. He isn't going to be around when the aims of this plan are supposed to be realised so he can suggest as many bold and stupid things as he likes fully in the knowledge that he won't be accountable when nothing good comes of them. The Germans have a solid national team for a lot of reasons but having B teams play in the league system isn't one of them, especially as below their third division the leagues are amateur.

Neutral Fan · May 8, 2014

Evans1883 said:
To help the english game it should be mandatory that every club must start a match with 4-6 british players in the starting 11 , which would mean every club would need 8-10 british players in their squad

Neutral Fan · May 8, 2014

How would Britidh players help the English game? They might all be Scots or Welsh. No use at all to England.

Jack Griffin · May 8, 2014

CCFC PimpRail said:
Why don't those clubs who want a B team "adopt" a lower club...? Man U could adopt CCFC and take over the Ricoh lease, it'd mean fans would have less far to travel from London to home games, and Cov is full of Man U fans anyway...

I thought that the real plan was to propose something outrageous & later fall back to the real goal, which is lower league feeder clubs for the big boys..

Sorry, but IMHO that is also unacceptable..

Chez78 · May 8, 2014

What an absolute joke this country's game has become, they want to know what's wrong with the English game just take a look at the commission itself the bloke running it is former head of the bbc if it was Germany it would be a former playing legend such as Beckenbauer. They want to to really start changing the the game for the better start to by clearing the FA of all the lords and toffs and start appointing the likes of hoddle, Robson and other retired pros who truly know what it takes to make it and have seen all the bad sides of the English game up close and personal.

The game in this country was built on passion and a desire to achieve the impossible as a team fans and players United as one, now we're reduced to blaming the poor for the failures of the rich. It's a plain and simple fact that the year before the premier league we reached the semi final of a World Cup with legends of the game such as waddle, garza, platt, lineker, shilton, walker and many others and the reason we did.......our league had to rely on good coaching not money and cheap foreign import.

And breath rant over

oldskyblue58 · May 9, 2014

Comment from the Conference leagues - seems they haven't even been consulted

http://nonleague.pitchero.com/news/...gue&utm_source=twitterfeed&utm_medium=twitter

The Football Conference Board at its meeting today had its first opportunity to see the 80 page England Commission Report which has just been published. It has noted that in its efforts to “diagnose” the problems addressed in the report that the Commission heard the views of 650 people allegedly “across all levels of the game”.

Whilst the Commission contains in some detail proposals deeply affecting the Football Conference, neither its chairman nor any other members of the Board of that particular competition were in any way consulted nor were their views sought directly or indirectly.

The Conference absolutely believes in the principle of introducing measures to improve the England national team and although it has not had the opportunity to analyse the report in detail it does feel able to comment on some of the resultant media reports and speculation.

1. We agree that future England players need to be given the opportunity to play more competitive football but we believe that experience should be at the highest levels of the game.

2. We agree there should be more home grown talent playing at those highest levels and fully support measures to increase those numbers to at least 50% with 10% being U21 players.

3. We would like to see The FA extend its coaching programme by providing more financial support, in order to enhance the skills of its existing and future coaches to a higher standard, in order to compete with countries like Spain who have an abundance of more qualified coaches compared to those in England.

The last point we wish to make at this stage is that the English pyramid system is unique, having evolved over 100 years. It has supported the growth of football into a league system that has become the envy of the world. The foundation is that in every community, throughout the UK, ordinary individuals engage in the financing, support and participation of teams which one day can reach the pinnacle of the top of the Premier League. It is built on a dream that every single football supporter has bought into.

In view of the length of the Executive Summary and the number of major issues contained therein it would be wrong to comment further at this stage before an in depth consideration.

We, as a competition, together with all other leagues who make up the structure beneath the Premier League and the Football League, should have the opportunity to meet, with some urgency, to reflect on the issues contained therein.

It is important in these proposals to remember the heritage of the English game, which has over a century of participation, been the rock on which the modern game currently exists so it is right we should consult with our partner competitions before making a full response.

We, like all supporters, wish to see the national team successful on the world stage but not to do it in a manner which threatens the whole existence of the Pyramid, on which the solid base of our whole game is dependent. The report will no doubt be viewed with much scepticism, surely players who seek to wear the Three Lions shirt in the future MUST be enhancing their skills and ambitions at the highest level of our game

stupot07 · May 9, 2014

Greg Dick knows FA

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors

Jack Griffin · May 9, 2014

stupot07 said:
Greg Dick knows FA

He's been taking a good old battering on Twitter.. :slap:

pw362 · May 9, 2014

Martin Samuel of the Daily Mail believes the FA commission's plan for a B-team league is doomed to fail.

Writing in his column, he says: "The Premier League B teams would include players earning far in excess of the norm for the competition and have financial structures that bear no relation to those of the standard lower league club.

"For the bottom line is that Manchester United B do not really exist. Not as a real club with a board and an independent revenue stream, and sponsors and advertisers, supporters and a gate and salaries that conform to the limitations of League Two.

"So to expect Accrington Stanley to be tied to Football League regulations on expenditure, while playing against a striker earning £25,000 a week whose owners are not party to the same rules, is entirely unfair."

Sutty · May 9, 2014

2011: EPPP is introduced - "OK, we've decided that Premier League clubs should be able to take the best football league youngsters at a bargain price. Probably less than it actually cost to develop that player in the first place. Is that alright? Oh, and if it isn't you'll lose your solidarity payments."

*Feeding frenzy ensues*

2014: "OK, pretty awkward, but... we've kind of got too many young players now and we're not quite sure where to put them haha. Mind if we just make a team out of them and shove them into your league system?"

stupot07 · May 9, 2014

Brendon Rodgers has backed the plans....what a surprise Liverpool will never get relegated to a level where it directly impacts them and will only benefit as they will be guaranteed to be one the 10 clubs with a B side.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors

Frostie · May 9, 2014

stupot07 said:
Brendon Rodgers has backed the plans....what a surprise Liverpool will never get relegated to a level where it directly impacts them and will only benefit as they will be guaranteed to be one the 10 clubs with a B side.

Just seen your latest post on the subject on gmk Stupot, some brilliant ideas there. Send them to that clueless t*@t at the FA would you? Although the more cynical among us may suggest of course that his ideas aren't really to do with improving the state of English football & more to do with £££..? :thinking about:

BrakesFan · May 9, 2014

http://www.change.org/en-GB/petitions/the-football-association-say-no-to-b-teams

Please sign and share the petition against this ludicrous idea.

How's This Going To Help The English Game? (4 Viewers)

japandy

New Member

CCFC PimpRail

New Member

ccfcway

Well-Known Member

SunZoomSpark

New Member

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member

Neutral Fan

Member

Neutral Fan

Member

Jack Griffin

Guest

Chez78

New Member

oldskyblue58

CCFC Finance Director

stupot07

Well-Known Member

Jack Griffin

Guest

pw362

Well-Known Member

Sutty

Member

stupot07

Well-Known Member

Frostie

Well-Known Member

BrakesFan

New Member

Users who are viewing this thread

How's This Going To Help The English Game? (4 Viewers)

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Member

Member

Jack Griffin

Guest

New Member

CCFC Finance Director

Well-Known Member

Jack Griffin

Guest

Well-Known Member

Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency