Israel - Palestinian Conflict (1 Viewer)

[duffer]

Let's just say for once, that the IDF are telling the truth (this bearing in mind that it's an organisation with a long and proven history of misinformation), then there's still a massive amount of hypocrisy in their approach.

If you watched the BBC last night, the IDF spokesman was outraged at Jeremy Bowen for even suggesting it might be an Israeli strike. Outraged that he thought they might even do such a thing.

Basically what he was saying was that the IDF doesn't bomb hospitals because they know that deliberately targeting civilian infrastructure isn't something civilised democracies can do.

Obviously in the meantime though, the IDF and the Israeli state is preventing water, power, and medical supplies from getting to hospitals - so they are clearly and openly preventing civilians from receiving urgently needed medical care.

Personally, I can't see this as much different to dropping a bomb on them, the inevitable deaths and suffering will just take a bit longer.

To me, it's a war crime in progress, plain and simple, and much as we should support Israel's right to defend itself from terrorism, we can't support that defence in itself becoming an even larger act of terror.

 

---

[duffer]

wtf is that?

Genuinely do you know what you are posting? Even Israel admits there was a massive explosion with massive loss of life, it's just that thhey say it wasn't them that caused the explosion.

Also you seem to contradicting yourself, you are posting about how Hamas have the weaponry to make and explosion that size and then you post tweets from crackpots claiming there wasn't really an explosion?

You are all over the place on this.

Shotgun trolling. Not worth the effort to engage, imho.

 

[Fysnkysc]

wtf is that?

Genuinely do you know what you are posting? Even Israel admits there was a massive explosion with massive loss of life, it's just that thhey say it wasn't them that caused the explosion.

Also you seem to contradicting yourself, you are posting about how Hamas have the weaponry to make and explosion that size and then you post tweets from crackpots claiming there wasn't really an explosion?

You are all over the place on this.

Yea no I'm not, I stick with the failed missile story.

I've shown enough evidence that backs up what I believe, as for a massive explosion fuel causes an explosion and rockets contain fuel.

 

[Fysnkysc]

Shotgun trolling. Not worth the effort to engage, imho.

In otherworld you know I'm right and it's coming to light that it was really a failed missile not a 2000lbs jdam bonb that people are claiming.

As for cutting off water you realise that water wasn't flowing anyway after hamas dug up the water pipes?

 

[Fysnkysc]

In otherworld you know I'm right and it's coming to light that it was really a failed missile not a 2000lbs jdam bonb that people are claiming.

As for cutting off water you realise that water wasn't flowing anyway after hamas dug up the water pipes?

Your evidence.

 

[David O'Day]

Yea no I'm not, I stick with the failed missile story.

I've shown enough evidence that backs up what I believe, as for a massive explosion fuel causes an explosion and rockets contain fuel.

you are though Kieran, you are using people saying there was no rocket attack to back you a theory you have. you probably need to check what you post and understand it first

until then there's not point in engaging with you as you are clearly struggling

 

[David O'Day]

Your evidence.

you do realise when people talk about water shortages they are talking about bottled and emergency supplies?

once again I ask that you go away and really try and understand what you are trying to say

it's probably bedtime for you

 

[Fysnkysc]

you do realise when people talk about water shortages they are talking about bottled and emergency supplies?

once again I ask that you go away and really try and understand what you are trying to say

it's probably bedtime for you

You think they're not able to get water in from iran? You realise they have a airport

 

[Fysnkysc]

Done anyway you guys clearly can't accept facts and other people's arguments so no point
It's like walking into a brick wall.

 

[jimmyhillsfanclub]

You think they're not able to get water in from iran? You realise they have a airport

Israel bombed the airport & runway donkeys years ago.....

...its been out of use ever since...... keep up

 

[jimmyhillsfanclub]

Done anyway you guys clearly can't accept facts and other people's arguments so no point
It's like walking into a brick wall.

Cheerio.

 

[Evo1883]

Biden says Israel didn't do it , not sure where anybody goes from there in terms of western leaders I mean .. nobody will go against America

 

[skybluetony176]

You think they're not able to get water in from iran? You realise they have a airport

Been closed for over 20 years . Israel ripped up the runway in 2002 having bombed it the previous year. Breaking the Oslo accords in the process .

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Cheerio.

...again.

Less cunting this time, mind

 

[clint van damme]

Biden says Israel didn't do it , not sure where anybody goes from there in terms of western leaders I mean .. nobody will go against America

It's going to be the accepted narrative in the west no matter what anyone else says or what evidence is presented to the contrary.

 

[fernandopartridge]

Biden says Israel didn't do it , not sure where anybody goes from there in terms of western leaders I mean .. nobody will go against America

The implications for conceding otherwise are massive. What a depressing place the world is at the moment.

 

[David O'Day]

The implications for conceding otherwise are massive. What a depressing place the world is at the moment.

to be fair to sunak even he has just said at pmqs they aren't going to blame anyone yet which is about as good as it will be with the west

biden is just well an old bloke who says weird stuff these days

 

[David O'Day]

You think they're not able to get water in from iran? You realise they have a airport

see this is another example of you not getting to grips with the subject you are talking about

 

[clint van damme]

The implications for conceding otherwise are massive. What a depressing place the world is at the moment.

And of course even if they can provide cast iron proof it was Jihadists it won't be believed in the Arab world so the shit show is just going to escalate.

I don't think this will end well for the hostages though I hope I'm wrong.

 

[SkyBlueCharlie9]

Our local MP's struggle to put enough pressure on people to make sure the fucking bins are collected on the right day I wouldn't hold out much hope for anything else from them

What is it with far right and their obsession with bins getting collected. (TBC - not alleging you are far right Saddlebrains!)

 

[Saddlebrains]

What is it with far right wingers and their obsession with bins getting collected.

Far right winger . I don't believe in religion and think changing pronouns is a mental disorder, I'm hardly Tommy Robinson bro

 

[clint van damme]

Far right winger . I don't believe in religion and think changing pronouns is a mental disorder, I'm hardly Tommy Robinson bro

Bet you put food water in your blue top, facist!

 

[Saddlebrains]

Bet you put food water in your blue top, facist!

I also flick the kettle off just before it boils because im impatient

 

[clint van damme]

I also flick the kettle off just before it boils because im impatient

That is wrong

 

[Nick]

Who did it then?
Who am I "standing with"?

 

[TomRad85]

Far right winger . I don't believe in religion and think changing pronouns is a mental disorder, I'm hardly Tommy Robinson bro

Exactly what someone who was hanging around with the EDL at Leicester Sq Wetherspoons would say.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Who am I "standing with"?

The innocent and helpless victims?

 

[wingy]

That is wrong

Should be a directive on that, committee point of order.

 

[duffer]

Biden says Israel didn't do it , not sure where anybody goes from there in terms of western leaders I mean .. nobody will go against America

Unless there's strong independent evidence, I suspect Arab countries will just take this as another example of America (and the West) taking Israel's side, right or wrong.

Regardless, it doesn't really change the rest of the situation, where Israel is in effect brutally punishing the entire civilian population of Gaza for the actions of terrorists.

 

[Macca1987]

I'm not a religious believer, too many other things in this solar system and beyond that can't be explained, but I don't try and promote my non beliefs on anyone, this is where religion differs, it's got to be this or it's got to be that. Why can't we all just think there is good and bad everywhere in the world. I can't 100% say who did this atrocity as I have not delved deep enough into it to form an opinion, but just to say it's always the innocents who end up paying the price

 

[Nick]

The innocent and helpless victims?

Well yeah. If only people used that.

Although reading online in general (amongst all the shouting) it's OK if you are on X or Y side to blow innocent people up rather than just them both being cunts.

 

[clint van damme]

I'm not a religious believer, too many other things in this solar system and beyond that can't be explained, but I don't try and promote my non beliefs on anyone, this is where religion differs, it's got to be this or it's got to be that. Why can't we all just think there is good and bad everywhere in the world. I can't 100% say who did this atrocity as I have not delved deep enough into it to form an opinion, but just to say it's always the innocents who end up paying the price

They're not fighting over differences in the Koran and the Torah, they're fighting over land, same as Russia and Ukraine who are both nominally Christian countries.

 

[duffer]

Who did it then?
Who am I "standing with"?

My line on it mate, I can't tell you who to stand with, but don't get too distracted by a single, contested incident. So personally, I'd say...

Stand against those who murdered innocent civilians and children in Israel.

Stand against those who are doing the same to the innocent civilians and children in Gaza.

 

[Macca1987]

They're not fighting over differences in the Koran and the Torah, they're fighting over land, same as Russia and Ukraine who are both nominally Christian countries.

I agree in someways, but that land has been at the centre of struggle for thousands of years by many religions

 

[duffer]

Genocide in Gaza? That's what the legal scholars are saying...

Public Statement: Scholars Warn of Potential Genocide in Gaza

On 15 October 2023, over 800 scholars and practitioners of international law, conflict studies and genocide studies signed a public statement warning of the possibility of genocide being perpetrate…

twailr.com