Match Thread Norwich City - Coventry City Match Thread - Saturday 3rd Feb (1 Viewer)

[Hertsccfc]

Score goals, it doesn’t matter what contribution he makes as long as he does that.

I don't agree. It is a real problem that Simms doesn't do much aside from the goals. He doesn't hold onto the ball or challenge the defenders. He is pretty much like Godden in this respect and he doesn't score as many goals as Godden.

 

---

[Old Warwickshire lad]

Palmer and Thomas?

Kitching?

As much as I want our players to stick up for themselves, it’s about doing it in the right way and making decisions that don’t lead to an unnecessary sending off. Bobby Thomas did it yesterday after the second foul on Sakamoto, went and had a word without raising his hands etc.

Well you saw more than I did, you don’t do it in ones you do it in twos and threes so you don’t get booked. It’s called intimidation, something we need to learn.

 

[stupot07]

Because he ultimately delivered nothing

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

I've just had a look at all his league goals,

1 Vs Blackpool first goal we then went on to lose 2-1
1 Vs Norwich at 3-1 down to make it 3-2 lost 4-2
1 Vs huddlesfield, already 1-0 up, to make it 2-0
This season 3rd against Sunderland already 2-0 up to make it 3-0.

He doesn't even score big goals at key moments.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

 

[Offhegoes]

Amazing people criticising Palmer. He was very lively when he came on and their keeper made a good save from him. He did far more in his short period on the pitch than many players who started. I would say he was one of the top performers yesterday and I hope he starts in Tuesday.

It is really quite ridiculous how much he is picked on by certain elements.

Agreed. He should have started, and the chance he had, he made himself and got it on target. Hardly a miss. Also the flack Simms is getting…He wasn’t great yesterday but Wright, Saka , MVE and Bidwell weren’t either. He led the line brilliantly at Leeds, and scored an equaliser midweek.

 

[covcity4life]

Amazing people criticising Palmer. He was very lively when he came on and their keeper made a good save from him. He did far more in his short period on the pitch than many players who started. I would say he was one of the top performers yesterday and I hope he starts in Tuesday.

It is really quite ridiculous how much he is picked on by certain elements.

It's a pattern mate

 

[AiS86]

Two really poor finishes from great positions, both far too close to the keeper. I'd put money on O'Hare and Sakamoto scoring the there.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

Two good reaction saves. Wright has pressure on both shoulders after creating the chance himself and has to get the shot away when he does. Low and just to the keepers side is sometimes harder for the keeper to deal with than a bit wider which they can get down to. Palmer's, the ball is going across his body from a quick passing move, the keeper is moving to his left to cover the near post, if Palmer puts it there, it's probably a save, he goes back across the goal, and it's a great reaction from Gunn. Both good attempts producing good saves.

 

[usskyblue]

Palmer coming on was the reason our 10 men looked more likely to score. He was by far the best player on the pitch at that point.

The still picture of his shot doesn’t show the whole picture. The keepers positioning was perfect, he covered the near post while being far enough off his line to also cover enough of the far post (defenders covered a shot to the far corner) Palmer placed the shot in the opposite direction of the keeper’s movement and Gunn had to make a reaction save.. which we’d be lording up if it were Collins.

The only issue for me with Palmer is his final ball, he needs to work on that.

 

[MikeyMoo]

Agree was about to post - final ball and he had more chances. Whole team can still have a massive run in here!

 

[usskyblue]

Wright’s shot needed more power and a little height. When you place a shot across a keeper and they’re going to ground, the ball needs to be elevated on the leg side.

 

[PVA]

Amazing people criticising Palmer. He was very lively when he came on and their keeper made a good save from him. He did far more in his short period on the pitch than many players who started. I would say he was one of the top performers yesterday and I hope he starts in Tuesday.

It is really quite ridiculous how much he is picked on by certain elements.

It's the same people over and over again.

Apparently now playing well and being a threat but with poor final ball is worse than playing badly and having poor final ball.

I bet if you asked Norwich fans at full time they'd rather have faced any of Wright/Simms/Sakamoto for 90 minutes than Palmer.

And before anyone says, no I'm not saying he's better than those players.

 

[Flying Fokker]

[

It's the same people over and over again.

Apparently now playing well and being a threat but with poor final ball is worse than playing badly and having poor final ball.

I bet if you asked Norwich fans at full time they'd rather have faced any of Wright/Simms/Sakamoto for 90 minutes than Palmer.

And before anyone says, no I'm not saying he's better than those players.

I’ve seen these comments from The Pinkun. Given that we are playing below par I think this is a positive:

Sakamoto a cry baby.

I thought that (Leeds apart) Coventry were easily the best team at FCR this season. They played positive, bright attacking football and it was only that lack of cutting edge that edged them out of what was a really entertaining match. Gunn made two blinding saves which denied them at least a point so from that point of view they can feel a bit hard done by. The sending off was a 100% cert though so he can have no complaints on that!

 

[mmttww]

Simms and Wright haven’t had games like that, they’ve had 1 or 2 (if we’re lucky) big chances in a game.

This. Really feel for Simms most games. He's where he should be and gets nothing played where he needs it. Needs to compete more for aerial crosses but otherwise, he's getting scraps.

 

[stupot07]

It's a pattern mate

Going down the racism route again?

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

 

[Hertsccfc]

It's the same people over and over again.

Apparently now playing well and being a threat but with poor final ball is worse than playing badly and having poor final ball.

I bet if you asked Norwich fans at full time they'd rather have faced any of Wright/Simms/Sakamoto for 90 minutes than Palmer.

And before anyone says, no I'm not saying he's better than those players.

Amazing the negative remarks on Palmer from certain sections but no comment in how poor Allen and Bidwell were. I am not saying they aren't decent players but they were poor yesterday.

I think most people would say Palmer was one of our best players yesterday for the period he was on, but some will always criticise him no matter what. Probably only Torp and O'Hare come out of that match with more credit than Palmer.

 

[Mucca Mad Boys]

I haven't seen any recent stats, but to my memory Godden has missed quite a few chances this season that I'm sure he would have finished in previous seasons (including 2 penalties). While pace has never been his thing, he nevertheless also appears to have lost a yard in pace and seems very easily beaten to the ball this season. Wright has also fluffed quite a few one on ones that I remember, while Simms hasn't really got started.

The assists list you have put up would also look significantly different if our forwards had taken the chances they should have. I'm not having it that the fault lies with the likes of O'Hare, Saka & Sheaf.

Penalties aside, I can’t think of a chance where Godden has missed that was gilt-edged. Same with Simms too.

Our creativity has come from our midfield and they’ve been very good at creating things for themselves - some of Sakamoto’s and COH have been brilliant individual efforts, for example.

So for me, the problem isn’t the strikers per se, it’s the lack of chances they generally have.

 

[Mucca Mad Boys]

Amazing the negative remarks on Palmer from certain sections but no comment in how poor Allen and Bidwell were. I am not saying they aren't decent players but they were poor yesterday.

I think most people would say Palmer was one of our best players yesterday for the period he was on, but some will always criticise him no matter what. Probably only Torp and O'Hare come out of that match with more credit than Palmer.

Missed chances are going to frustrate people. Palmer looked really good yesterday, until it came to the final pass or finish. Unfortunately for him, he won’t be starter until that improves. I hate to admit it, but @Grendel’s ‘nearly man’ label is not unfair.

As for Allen, he had a decent game, but his final ball was lacking too. His final ball to Palmer, ironically, was perfect. That was MR’s assessment too.

COH deserves the plaudits for a fantastic goal and Torp was very good defensively and on the ball - he just isn’t fully match fit to last 90m at this stage.

People have been saying Bidwell was poor so I don’t get that comment.

 

[Nuskyblue]

My heads gone! I thought the black haired fella who scored was Sargeant that Sainz looked a good threat. Now I know who Sargeant is I thought he did the ugly part of a striker well which is what we need from Simms at times.

Sainz can't half leather a ball. That wasn't even his best goal this week!

 

[Tommo1993]

Missed chances are going to frustrate people. Palmer looked really good yesterday, until it came to the final pass or finish. Unfortunately for him, he won’t be starter until that improves. I hate to admit it, but @Grendel’s ‘nearly man’ label is not unfair.

As for Allen, he had a decent game, but his final ball was lacking too. His final ball to Palmer, ironically, was perfect. That was MR’s assessment too.

COH deserves the plaudits for a fantastic goal and Torp was very good defensively and on the ball - he just isn’t fully match fit to last 90m at this stage.

People have been saying Bidwell was poor so I don’t get that comment.

Bidwell also guilty of fluffing some easy passes too. Looked very leggy on the recovery too.

 

[Nuskyblue]

Bidwell also guilty of fluffing some easy passes too. Looked very leggy on the recovery too.

2 or 3 on the bounce he's been this way. Shame JDS is no great shakes defending

 

[Macca]

They didn't really want to. They had to sell Simms & Cannon to help with FFP. He's scored goals everywhere else he's been & there was a queue of Championship clubs trying to sign him.

Ah I didn’t know that, fair enough

 

[SkyBlue_Bear83]

Sorry Palmer is rubbish, people saying he has the most skill in the team is absolute crap.

 

[Calista]

Yeah it was a good save for Wrights too, but it was an easier chance than Palmer's and he really had to score it. Very bad miss.

Wright's effort reminded me of the one Harry Kane failed to score in the World Cup SF a few years ago. Not that I've ever brought myself to watch it again.
Slight difference in the stakes mind you.

 

[Chris1987]

Sorry Palmer is rubbish, people saying he has the most skill in the team is absolute crap.

What is it that makes him rubbish ?

 

[junglej13]

I've just had a look at all his league goals,

1 Vs Blackpool first goal we then went on to lose 2-1
1 Vs Norwich at 3-1 down to make it 3-2 lost 4-2
1 Vs huddlesfield, already 1-0 up, to make it 2-0
This season 3rd against Sunderland already 2-0 up to make it 3-0.

He doesn't even score big goals at key moments.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

Exactly this. Compare this to Jamie Allen's contribution last season. It is night and day. Palmer is clearly twice as skilful and has far more ability. I'm sure he's the best player in training every day. Come match day his impact on the result of a game is absolutely nothing.

Don't really know what I would do with him if I was coach. If you watched one of our games you could be fooled into thinking he is out best player. For balance, I used to be very critical of O'Hare - his end product has improved unbelievably since his return from injury. Really hope Palmer can do the same.

 

[wingy]

What is it that makes him rubbish ?

Final ball pass?

 

[fernandopartridge]

Sorry Palmer is rubbish, people saying he has the most skill in the team is absolute crap.

I disagree, he's not rubbish and clearly has a lot of technical skill. That's what makes him so frustrating, he does one thing brilliantly and then next thing fluffs his lines.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

 

[Mucca Mad Boys]

Exactly this. Compare this to Jamie Allen's contribution last season. It is night and day. Palmer is clearly twice as skilful and has far more ability. I'm sure he's the best player in training every day. Come match day his impact on the result of a game is absolutely nothing.

Don't really know what I would do with him if I was coach. If you watched one of our games you could be fooled into thinking he is out best player. For balance, I used to be very critical of O'Hare - his end product has improved unbelievably since his return from injury. Really hope Palmer can do the same.

Why don’t we compare Allen and Palmer on this season’s contributions?

 

[PVA]

I disagree, he's not rubbish and clearly has a lot of technical skill. That's what makes him so frustrating, he does one thing brilliantly and then next thing fluffs his lines.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

With the way O'Hare, Sheaf, Hamer, Gyokeres improved under the coaching staff I'm confident/hopeful they can do the same with Palmer.

 

[SkyBlue_Bear83]

What is it that makes him rubbish ?

Doesn't score goals and doesn't assist goals for others and for most his time here struggled to play a full 90 minutes due to his fitness.

He would never be able to produce the goal he scored against Oxford in a big moment because he hasn't got the mentality for it.

His technique doesn't hold up when he's put under pressure, he's not a fantastic passer of the ball or striker of the ball for someone allegedly with so much skill.

He's basically similar to O'Hare when he had no end product but without the stamina or energy levels of O'Hare and more of a tendency to go missing in matches.

 

[PVA]

Doesn't score goals and doesn't assist goals for others and for most his time here struggled to play a full 90 minutes due to his fitness.

He has the most assists per 90 minutes of anyone in the squad this season (bar Torp and his very small sample size!).

And if you do it on goals and assists per 90 he's behind O'Hare, Wright and Sakamoto only.

 

[Grendel]

Amazing people criticising Palmer. He was very lively when he came on and their keeper made a good save from him. He did far more in his short period on the pitch than many players who started. I would say he was one of the top performers yesterday and I hope he starts in Tuesday.

It is really quite ridiculous how much he is picked on by certain elements.

Hes hardly picked ok. He’s a highly paid player who over his whole career has failed to establish himself as a regular starter and that’s to him

 

[Grendel]

It's a pattern mate

I’ve actually reported you for making racism a joke and I urge other posters to do the same

 

[SkyBlue_Bear83]

He has the most assists per 90 minutes of anyone in the squad this season (bar Torp and his very small sample size!).

And if you do it on goals and assists per 90 he's behind O'Hare, Wright and Sakamoto only.

So he's second last out of our attacking midfielders and wingers? Only ahead of Allen

 

[shmmeee]

I disagree, he's not rubbish and clearly has a lot of technical skill. That's what makes him so frustrating, he does one thing brilliantly and then next thing fluffs his lines.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

All our forwards TBH

 

[PVA]

So he's second last out of our attacking midfielders and wingers? Only ahead of Allen

You said he doesn't score or assist. I showed you that actually he has assisted more than anyone this season.