Transfer Rumour Palmer to Norwich (1 Viewer)

Finham

Well-Known Member
Dec 17, 2019
2,266
1,838
213
I struggle to believe Robins has sanctioned an almost £2m signing on a player who doesn’t fit our system and will be “shoehorned” into either attacking midfield or a wingback. He’s clearly going to compete to start in one of those spots.
I didn't say he won't compete for AMC but he's certainly no natural there. He's patently a wide man and most of his game is taking men on and getting a cross in. He can do that a bit at AMC, but it's hardly "central" to the role (ho-ho). It's a puzzling signing to a degree, but it seems that we spotted a gem and thought "get him in and sort out what to do with him later". We might play wingers soon, who knows!

PS 1.5m is not "almost 2m".
 

Matt smith

Well-Known Member
May 12, 2022
5,325
3,244
313
I struggle to believe Robins has sanctioned an almost £2m signing on a player who doesn’t fit our system and will be “shoehorned” into either attacking midfield or a wingback. He’s clearly going to compete to start in one of those spots.
I don’t really get the sakamoto signing he doesn’t fit our system at all
 

BlueSkiesForever

Well-Known Member
Aug 23, 2023
826
586
143
I’m sorry but IMO Palmer is not worth anymore than £750k
He is too injury prone to be worth anymore than that. Has some nice touches but not a reliable player that’s gunna play 40 matches a season.
Over the last few years his career has been start stop, you can see there’s something there but it’s not firing all cylinders

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
It’s all personal opinion but I think Palmer is worth way more than £750K, I know there’s probably more to come from the likes of Simms and MVE etc but in terms of going forward Palmer was the only one trying to create anything in the last game. I realise his end product isn’t great but I felt that no one else in that game was making decent runs or trying to get into positions for him to lay the ball off so he almost had no choice but to take the shots on himself.
Maybe an estimation of £5 million is a bit high but seriously anything less than £3 mil would be an insult, when you think what you can get for £3 mil these days it isn’t much, especially someone who’s got proven experience in the championship and is a good personality to have around your club.
 

SBT

Well-Known Member
Sep 14, 2012
8,394
10,631
263
He’s so electrifying, I just hope he can start to add Goals and Assists to his game because that’s where Palmer has one over on him currently.
O’Hare made more assists in the league than Palmer last season, despite playing about 20 fewer games.

Ben Wilson has scored more goals than Palmer in the last six months.
 

Bad Boy

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2012
952
1,036
193
I struggle to believe Robins has sanctioned an almost £2m signing on a player who doesn’t fit our system and will be “shoehorned” into either attacking midfield or a wingback. He’s clearly going to compete to start in one of those spots.
Get yourself up to Ryton and tell him to his face that he's signed a wrong un.

Clearly you know so much more than he and his staff will ever know.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2011
82,388
36,734
813
Rumoured by Grendel

It was reported at the time of the signing - palmers wages at Bristol and the contract arrangement arent a secret
 

Torquay Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2021
1,142
1,247
213
For the right price I'd sell him. Concentration issues resulting in bad distribution. There's a player in there, but I fear we'll always be saying that.
Strangely enough, my Bristol City mate said the same thing.
 

skybluecam

Well-Known Member
Apr 25, 2015
2,861
3,197
163
Get yourself up to Ryton and tell him to his face that he's signed a wrong un.

Clearly you know so much more than he and his staff will ever know.
Not what I was saying at all, I’m saying Robins will have a plan for him and since MVE looks like he’ll be our first choice at RWB that plan surely involves plenty of playing time in attacking midfield.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bad Boy

Bad Boy

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2012
952
1,036
193
Not what I was saying at all, I’m saying Robins will have a plan for him and since MVE looks like he’ll be our first choice at RWB that plan surely involves plenty of playing time in attacking midfield.
I get that but MR did say a few weeks ago there was to be no more round pegs in square holes.

I trust in what he's trying to do.
 

slowpoke

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2015
8,620
5,773
263
Robins is obviously re-building the first team squad top to bottom, as new ones come in established players could well be pushed out, I think Palmer could come into that category. I like him, his bursts forward with the ball get you on the edge of your seat, but the end product let’s be honest isn’t the best.
Wouldn’t be surprised if he moves on but it’s a little late in the day transfer window wise.
Will obviously depend who if any come in this week.
It’s another case of in Robins we trust.
 

The Philosopher

Well-Known Member
Jan 16, 2014
2,692
2,317
213
Didn’t Palmer cost Bristol £3.5m from Chelsea?

Every player has a price.

If Norwich bid £10m then he’s off. £1m maybe not.

Someone thought Palmer worth £3.5m not too long ago.

Just saying.

£2.5m plus McCallum would be good business.

(I know SM hasn’t set the world on fire at NCFC but he seems to do well here. Some players suit certain clubs; see Martyn Waghorn for details.)
 

covcity4life

Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2010
35,038
17,008
313
Didn’t Palmer cost Bristol £3.5m from Chelsea?

Every player has a price.

If Norwich bid £10m then he’s off. £1m maybe not.

Someone thought Palmer worth £3.5m not too long ago.

Just saying.

£2.5m plus McCallum would be good business.

(I know SM hasn’t set the world on fire at NCFC but he seems to do well here. Some players suit certain clubs; see Martyn Waghorn for details.)
My gut feeling would be any fee offered is similar to what we paid. Not anywhere near 10m for example.
 

Boicey

Well-Known Member
Aug 12, 2023
654
589
143
Robins has favourites. That includes Palmer and Godden and Allen.
They will be amongst his first picks when fit.
Palmer's going nowhere. And Sakamoto and/or Simms, Wright will be having a lot of bench time.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Sick Boy

slowpoke

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2015
8,620
5,773
263
Didn’t Palmer cost Bristol £3.5m from Chelsea?

Every player has a price.

If Norwich bid £10m then he’s off. £1m maybe not.

Someone thought Palmer worth £3.5m not too long ago.

Just saying.

£2.5m plus McCallum would be good business.

(I know SM hasn’t set the world on fire at NCFC but he seems to do well here. Some players suit certain clubs; see Martyn Waghorn for details.)
We can do better than McCallum was a good lad here, but Norwich haven’t been the best the last two seasons and McCallum has not exactly been pulling up trees there has had at leat two managers as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skybluebaz

SlowerThanPlatt

Well-Known Member
Dec 16, 2011
22,302
14,022
313
Herefordshire/Coventry
Robins has favourites. That includes Palmer and Godden and Allen.
They will be amongst his first picks when fit.
Palmer's going nowhere. And Sakamoto and/or Simms, Wright will be having a lot of bench time.
He doesn’t have “favourites”, he may though appreciate more than a fan a quality a player has in a functioning team
 

Sick Boy

Well-Known Member
Sep 29, 2008
28,088
20,636
313
Verona, Italy
This isn’t a loaded question but what percentage of games since he signed has Palmer played 90 mins in? Not only games he’s played in but the total games.
 
Last edited:

Esoterica

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2013
8,111
13,443
313
Czech Republic
This isn’t a loser question but what percentage of games since he signed has Palmer played 90 mins in? Not only games he’s played in but the total games.
Someone with more time than me will work it out, but my guess would be around 10%. Something like 5 full 90s in 55ish games.

46 league games, 3 playoff games, 4 league games this season and a few cup games.
 

SBT

Well-Known Member
Sep 14, 2012
8,394
10,631
263
This isn’t a loser question but what percentage of games since he signed has Palmer played 90 mins in? Not only games he’s played in but the total games.
He’s played the full 90 minutes on eight occasions since joining us in all competitions - that’s 22% of his games for us, and 14% of our total games since he joined.
 

RegTheDonk

Well-Known Member
Aug 17, 2011
3,976
2,178
213
The Palmer story is almost certainly a plant by his agent to see if there is a chance of a move for him this week. Norwich denied any interest almost as quickly as the story came out. It could as easily be a ploy to get a pay rise as well.
I'm no doubt over reacting but this sort of thing annoys me. The Norwich reply says there is NO interest, so presume agent is BS rather than having some insider knowledge. But it don't end there ... there's still a potential knock on effect of uncertainty, destablisation, dressing room moans over wages, generating interest from other parties. Obviously goes on but I'd love one of these agents (or their sources) to have their arses sued by the club for creating a falsehood.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Terry_dactyl

Matt smith

Well-Known Member
May 12, 2022
5,325
3,244
313
The Palmer story is almost certainly a plant by his agent to see if there is a chance of a move for him this week. Norwich denied any interest almost as quickly as the story came out. It could as easily be a ploy to get a pay rise as well.
He doesn’t deserve a pay rise

he’s hardly done enough to warrant one
 
  • Like
Reactions: SeaSeeEffCee

Sick Boy

Well-Known Member
Sep 29, 2008
28,088
20,636
313
Verona, Italy
I'm no doubt over reacting but this sort of thing annoys me. The Norwich reply says there is NO interest, so presume agent is BS rather than having some insider knowledge. But it don't end there ... there's still a potential knock on effect of uncertainty, destablisation, dressing room moans over wages, generating interest from other parties. Obviously goes on but I'd love one of these agents (or their sources) to have their arses sued by the club for creating a falsehood.
Never going to happen because players would end up being majorly pissed off. It makes me laugh that people actually think players don't instruct their agents to do this kind of stuff and it's all down to the big bad agents.
 

iflynno

Active Member
Mar 27, 2017
53
30
118
Someone with more time than me will work it out, but my guess would be around 10%. Something like 5 full 90s in 55ish games.

46 league games, 3 playoff games, 4 league games this season and a few cup games.
He played 90 mins 6 times last season in Champ and so far only Leicester this season. Made around 29 appearances in total in the league.

3 Goals and 2 Assists last season, most of which came within a week at the end of October.
 

covcity4life

Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2010
35,038
17,008
313
Never going to happen because players would end up being majorly pissed off. It makes me laugh that people actually think players don't instruct their agents to do this kind of stuff and it's all down to the big bad agents.
Have zero proof Palmer has asked him to do it though. Dangerous game to just assume and have a go at him isn't it?
 

covcity4life

Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2010
35,038
17,008
313
Where have I had a go at him?
I'm talking about players in general, not just Palmer.
I'm not saying you did. I'm just saying as fans we can't assume he's asked for this to happen that's all. Were in the dark as obsessed as we are.
 

RegTheDonk

Well-Known Member
Aug 17, 2011
3,976
2,178
213
Never going to happen because players would end up being majorly pissed off. It makes me laugh that people actually think players don't instruct their agents to do this kind of stuff and it's all down to the big bad agents.
Yes absolutely get that mate, it's playing the game. Though if I was Norwich I'd consider taking Palmer to task via his agent IF there's nothing in it.
 

Cov98

Well-Known Member
Apr 29, 2017
376
361
163
I swear you lot watch a different game most weeks. 750k for Palmer? That's insane.. is he worth 15m like Gus? Obviously not but he's worth a couple of mill for sure.
Fitness wise I agree, he could be and probably needs to be better but since the start of the season he's looked way more like the player he needs to be. Like it or not, he's our most creative player at the minute with Gus gone and all of our injuries. Ayari looks good but you can tell he's still a bit raw and he's also not permanent, so no use selling Palmer and ending up with fuck all come January if Brighton want to recall him, although that would be unlikely.
Most of the good against Sunderland came through Palmer and I see a lot of Kasey "almost" Palmer inside here but he is probably one of the only players in the squad at the minute who's willing to try a forward ball or an outrageous pass. Eccles and Sheaf aren't going to be looking for the same passes and are definitely not going to drive forward like Palmer does.
Until O Hare comes back and (if) we get a Gus replacement in, he's going to be the main man in midfield most weeks because who else do we have other than Ayari?
 

Users who are viewing this thread