Walker (1 Viewer)

[Evo1883]

I said last season I didn't rate sheaf , turns out he's a good player .

I put up the PPG of the team with Sheaf in the starting 11 and it's the lowest of him Allen and hamer .. basically we have a higher PPG without him

People were using that argument to slander godden , those same people are on here defending walker .

This forum is full of people who know nothing about football

 

---

[Grendel]

I said last season I didn't rate sheaf , turns out he's a good player .

I put up the PPG of the team with Sheaf in the starting 11 and it's the lowest of him Allen and hamer .. basically we have a higher PPG without him

People were using that argument to slander godden , those same people are on here defending walker .

This forum is full of people who know nothing about football

No one “slandered” Godden. This is a tired debate but the main issue was extending an aging forwards contract beyond next season which is utterly pointless.

Walker hasn’t really played any game time for us this season and was axed after scoring in consecutive games which is hardly a confidence builder

His goal scoring record is prior to that very good. He has reasonable ability with his back to goal and in the air - he’s quicker than the other forwards excluding Gyokeres - and he’s prior record is strong

Fans for whatever reason haven’t taken to him - and they haven’t as we also see with Bidwell - so it’s an uphill struggle

We should keep him and see what he does next season

 

[Evo1883]

No one “slandered” Godden. This is a tired debate but the main issue was extending an aging forwards contract beyond next season which is utterly pointless.

Walker hasn’t really played any game time for us this season and was axed after scoring in consecutive games which is hardly a confidence builder

His goal scoring record is prior to that very good. He has reasonable ability with his back to goal and in the air - he’s quicker than the other forwards excluding Gyokeres - and he’s prior record is strong

Fans for whatever reason haven’t taken to him - and they haven’t as we also see with Bidwell - so it’s an uphill struggle

We should keep him and see what he does next season

You said had we played godden we'd have not been in with a chance of the playoffs ..
You've said several times we win more without him .


These same arguments can be now used to sheaf using the same logic , which we all know is nonsense after all

These are YOUR own arguments grendel ..well , yours and 3 or 4 others

 

[SlowerThanPlatt]

With Walker on Pompey’s bench and the news of Hilssner’s ACL injury the room to maneuver in the summer isn’t looking good. Kelly and Waghorn are meant to be among the highest earners too…

 

[Deleted member 5849]

You said had we played godden we'd have not been in with a chance of the playoffs ..
You've said several times we win more without him .


These same arguments can be now used to sheaf using the same logic , which we all know is nonsense after all

These are YOUR own arguments grendel ..well , yours and 3 ir 4 others

Don't equate everybody however. It's perfectly possible to think Walker's a decent striker, yet also appreciate Godden has his merits, has shown punch in front of goal this season, and not be too worried about a three year deal (what pace does he have to lose, after all?).

 

[Evo1883]

I don't care after all .. walker isn't here because his workrate and attitude don't fit .. and it also doesn't fit at pompey ..

So is it coventry that need to change or Tyler walker ?

I'd suggest the latter

 

[Grendel]

You said had we played godden we'd have not been in with a chance of the playoffs ..
You've said several times we win more without him .


These same arguments can be now uses to sheaf using the same logic , which we all know is nonsense after all

Again this argument starts again.

I don’t think if we’d played godden against Fulham we’d have won as I think he’d have started and Gyokeres wouldn’t.

It isn’t really the point though - Walker has scored only 19 less league goals in his career than godden and he’s 5 years younger - stats are a funny thing

 

[Grendel]

With Walker on Pompey’s bench and the news of Hilssner’s ACL injury the room to maneuver in the summer isn’t looking good. Kelly and Waghorn are meant to be among the highest earners too…

And AN Other whose not in the first team apparently

 

[Evo1883]

Again this argument starts again.

I don’t think if we’d played godden against Fulham we’d have won as I think he’d have started and Gyokeres wouldn’t.

It isn’t really the point though - Walker has scored only 19 less league goals in his career than godden and he’s 5 years younger - stats are a funny thing

Godden is a superior striker , i don't think that's in any doubt at all

 

[Grendel]

Godden is a superior striker , i don't think that's in any doubt at all anymore

i think it is as it’s only this season that’s ever been the case

 

[Evo1883]

i think it is as it’s only this season that’s ever been the case

He's also 80 league goals behind godden

 

[SlowerThanPlatt]

And AN Other whose not in the first team apparently

Not in the 11 I would think that’s Kane at the time

 

[Evo1883]

i think it is as it’s only this season that’s ever been the case

And the season he was at Lincoln godden scored the same league goalsin less games you really have no argument here

 

[Grendel]

He's also 80 league goals behind godden

Is he? Not according to soccerbase?

 

[Evo1883]

Is he? Not according to soccerbase?

The same soccer base that has godden as 0.56 goals per game and Walker 0.28 ?

Well using soccer base its still 70 goals

 

[Grendel]

The same soccer base that has godden as 0.56 goals per game and Walker 0.28 ?

Well using soccer base its still 70 goals

Aren’t you including Ebbsfleet dartford and Tamworth?

 

[Evo1883]

Aren’t you including Ebbsfleet?

Oh god here we go , give me 5 minutes

 

[Grendel]

Matty Godden | Football Stats | Charlton Athletic | Age 33 | Soccer Base

Matty Godden. (Born 29 Jul, 1991) Forward for Charlton Athletic. Current season & career stats available, including appearances, goals & transfer fees.

www.soccerbase.com

 

[Evo1883]

Matty Godden | Football Stats | Charlton Athletic | Age 33 | Soccer Base

Matty Godden. (Born 29 Jul, 1991) Forward for Charlton Athletic. Current season & career stats available, including appearances, goals & transfer fees.

www.soccerbase.com

Matty godden

86 professional goals in 16123 minutes

Goal every 187 minutes

Tyker Walker

57 professional goals in 12211 minutes

Goal every 214 minutes


Moving on ??

 

[Grendel]

Matty godden

86 professional goals in 16123 minutes

Goal every 187 minutes

Tyker Walker

57 professional goals in 12211 minutes

Goal every 214 minutes


Moving on ??

he’s only scored 19 more than Walker in the league and is 5 years older

fact or fiction?

Also that argument is counter productive as Walker was playing as a teenager cameo appearances for Forest - it’s like saying Callum Wilson hardly scored in his early years

Anyway 19 goal gap is the difference - yes or no?

 

[Evo1883]

he’s only scored 19 more than Walker in the league and is 5 years older

fact or fiction?

What does that have to do with ability grendel ? Absolutely nothing


Godden beats him in every metric

Goals per game , per minute , per grendel post

 

[Evo1883]

This is an argument you can't win really , there is no metric where walker wins

You are arguing about a striker that can't score in league 1 anymore

 

[Evo1883]

Did you say that because of PPG we are better without godden ..

Using this logic grendel does that mean you apply it to Ben sheaf too , and we are a better team without him ?

 

[Evo1883]

And also grendel , are you going west brom today ?

 

[Grendel]

This is becoming almost like my Martin Keogh moment on GMK

I don’t know why this is such a debate.

it’s a difference of opinion and that’s it really

 

[Deleted member 5849]

This is becoming almost like my Martin Keogh moment on GMK

Martin Keogh's website | Martin Keogh's website

?

 

[Evo1883]

This is becoming almost like my Martin Keogh moment on GMK

I don’t know why this is such a debate.

it’s a difference of opinion and that’s it really

It is , only because you realise you can't get the better of me on the argument .. I'd imagine it would be going on and on if I was let's say , Danny Thomas

 

[Grendel]

And also grendel , are you going west brom today ?

No and I’m not sure what that has to do with anything

 

[Evo1883]

No and I’m not sure what that has to do with anything

Nor me , its just something you use against Danny Thomas that I'm using against you as if it makes you're opinion less meaningful

 

[Grendel]

Nor me , its just something you use against Danny Thomas that I'm using against you as if it makes you're opinion less meaningful

well I’m not in Dundee either

 

[usskyblue]

I’m not going either if that makes either of you feel better

 

[Grendel]

I’m not going either if that makes either of you feel better

i doubt Matty Godden is either

 

[Tommo1993]

Who the fuck is Martin Keogh?

 

[Grendel]

Who the fuck is Martin Keogh?

sorry Richard Keogh

 

[Evo1883]

I’m not going either if that makes either of you feel better

I doubt I would be too if I was in the US, it wasn't the point though , it was in jest