Interesting take. I agree with a lot of it but not all
A friend of a friend wrote this. Very powerful words pertaining to hopeful peace and de escalation.
A very well considered explanation by my friend Shingles Barbarossa.
Thanks for the clarity fella. Peace n love. What is happening in Ukraine is abysmal. Nothing can defend Russia's chauvinistic violence towards a sovereign state and I firmly believe Putin has reached peak insanity. I feel terrible for the people of Ukraine and the advance on Kyiv is a crime. The police crackdown on anti-war protesters in Moscow is equally appalling.
It is however, important to take note of the conditions and events that led to this catastrophe.
What's currently unfolding is not simply because Putin is a nasty man who wants to 'take over the world', nor is it because the West failed to 'stand up to Putin'. The crisis in Ukraine is the result of years and years of geopolitical interference between competing foreign powers in the country's affairs. There was immense US involvement in the Ukraine coup of 2014, which helped give power to several ultra far-right nationalist groups who now hold a substantial level of power in Ukraine's government and military. The coup was soon followed by the Russian annexation of Crimea and everything became more unstable from then on.
Many could rightly argue that Putin's disregard of international law has only been encouraged and abetted by the constant breaking of it by those who claim to uphold it. The invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan by Britain and the US, Israel's continuing bombardment of Gaza and the West Bank, NATO's brutal onslaught against Libya and the never ending arming of Saudi Arabia's war in Yemen are just the tip of the iceberg. Perhaps the relentless NATO bombing of Yugoslavia in the late 90s is the most appropriate example, the bombing campaign went ahead without UN authorisation and was considered by most to be a breach of international law, hundreds of civilians in Belgrade were killed. The majority of Western leaders condemning Russia today seem to have forgotten this even happened. The ongoing legacy of these imperialist disasters should not be brushed under the carpet, they have played a direct role in the development of what we are seeing today.
The Western powers have a long history of breaching the sovereignty of nations that goes back a good few hundred years. But just to give some modern examples over the last 70 years, democratically elected governments have been overthrown by right-wing CIA backed operations in Chile, Bolivia, Iran, Argentina, Egypt, Brazil, Uganda, DRC, and yes, Ukraine. None of this overlooks Russia's share of brutality either. The Soviet invasions of Hungary, Czechoslovakia, and Afghanistan were equally destructive and unlawful, as was Russia's bloodthirsty war against Chechnya in the 90s and 00s, which reduced entire cities to rubble.
Putin's chauvinistic ambitions aside, Russia's security concerns regarding NATO'S expansion are not unjustified. Since the collapse of the USSR, every former Warsaw Pact country and three ex-Soviet states have joined the alliance. For years, there has been an increased build-up of US troops in the Baltic states on Russia's border. if Russia had troops in Mexico there would be an outrage. This is another factor that needs to be taken into account.
Whilst NATO is appearing not to intervene in Ukraine directly, there has still been keen talk amongst western officials wishing for direct conflict with Russia. A particularly disturbing example was given by Ben Wallace on Wednesday when he claimed that the UK had 'kicked Russia's backside in the past and will do it again'. This reference and celebration of the Crimean War of the 1850s is a keen endorsement of British imperialism and shows a hunger for direct warfare.
If NATO did decide to intervene directly against Russia then it'll be a direct conflict between two heavily armed nuclear powers. That's nothing to joke about.
I know it's easy to be confused at such an unsettling time, but before people start lining up behind the war drums in the drive towards a larger conflict against Russia, it's important to remember that ultimately this conflict has emerged as a result of the crises within imperialism and global capitalism. Western domination is under threat, Covid has pushed global capitalism to a breaking point, we're experiencing the results of the collapse of an extremely contradictory system. Perhaps Putin's increased violence and recklessness is out of fear of his own failing rule coming under threat from his own people. The conditions that led to this crisis will not be solved by sanctions, NATO intervention or expansion, identity politics, or nationalism because these factors helped create these conditions to begin with.
Nevertheless, what Russia is doing is abhorrent. This is a horrible situation for the people of Ukraine and the results from this conflict will be horrific, no matter who wins. My thoughts go out to them.