Referee (1 Viewer)

[PUSB-We_are_going_up]

It that's a foul then the Bradley tackle against Real Madrid should have been a sending off.

Beautiful challenge

 

---

[shmmeee]

Beautiful challenge

Are we sure? Has anyone checked on Mbappe?

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

Yep, I don't mind it not being given & I know that's what fans would like, but I guarantee 95% of referees would say that's a foul. Unfortunately, most fans just see "wins ball". The game has changed, the tackler is now directly responsible for his opponents welfare as well.

Hence why refs at grassroots are fucked

 

[PUSB-We_are_going_up]

Are we sure? Has anyone checked on Mbappe?

He went to see his chiropractor

 

[Nick]

Did I imagine it or did one of their players yesterday just go lunging in, wipe out our player and the ref didn't even speak to him? I think it should have been his second booking too.

 

[fatso]

Simple rule for goalkeeper shithousery, if the goalkeeper goes down without any forced contact then the Referee ensures the trainers come the field to him and then after the goalkeeper decides he is fit to carry on the Referee should ask the captain to nominate an outfield player to leave the field of play for 30 seconds!

Make the keeper go off the pitch for treatment while play continues.

End of problem.

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

Make the keeper go off the pitch for treatment while play continues.

End of problem.

What if they’re injured

 

[fatso]

What if they’re injured

An outfield player puts the gloves on!

It's not like they are an endangered species.

 

[shmmeee]

What if they’re injured

Then you substitute them.

 

[MusicDating]

I’d like to hear the explanation there’s no need for the aggression in the tackle and he clearly endangers the safety of the opponent
I know you and the person making the video will say he got the ball but that’s not the only consideration

My boy's just done his ref course and is starting to referee games and we certainly view decisions with a different perspective now.

With this one, I can see where you're coming from Pete as Rice (I think) is off the ground as he makes the challenge -




However, he's not endangering an opponent at this point. My issue is that Emerson endangers himself by moving his leg to 'shield' the ball in an unnatural position. Look where his right leg is above compare to -



And the other angle shows it more clearly, he's nowhere near the ball that he's supposed to be shielding -




So in my view, he's bought the foul by where he's planted his leg, but Rice hasn't helped himself by the leap into the challenge. Also Taylor is too close to really see what's happened.

 

[Para1140]

The problem with that is instead of the keeper going down it will be an outfield player that just sits down faking injury. Just like yesterday

 

[Tommo1993]

Put a ban on players going over to the dugout when the keeper mysteriously goes down. Put them all in the centre circle.

 

[shmmeee]

The problem with that is instead of the keeper going down it will be an outfield player that just sits down faking injury. Just like yesterday

Substitute them. Honestly at this point forget the physios etc. Players can come off at a stoppage for “treatment” or they can be subbed if they’re too injured to do that.

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

Then you substitute them.

Just to get treatment

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

My boy's just done his ref course and is starting to referee games and we certainly view decisions with a different perspective now.

With this one, I can see where you're coming from Pete as Rice (I think) is off the ground as he makes the challenge -

View attachment 39949


However, he's not endangering an opponent at this point. My issue is that Emerson endangers himself by moving his leg to 'shield' the ball in an unnatural position. Look where his right leg is above compare to -

View attachment 39950

And the other angle shows it more clearly, he's nowhere near the ball that he's supposed to be shielding -


View attachment 39951

So in my view, he's bought the foul by where he's planted his leg, but Rice hasn't helped himself by the leap into the challenge. Also Taylor is too close to really see what's happened.

I think he does win the foul

 

[SBT]

Put a ban on players going over to the dugout when the keeper mysteriously goes down. Put them all in the centre circle.

Yeah just ban the players from going over to the sideline during any injury stoppage, book any players/send off any coaches who don’t comply. Might make coaching harder during legitimate stoppages, but that’s not the ref’s problem - it’s their own fault for abusing the system.

You can’t really do too much to disincentivise players from going down in case you end up exacerbating a genuine injury.

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

My boy's just done his ref course and is starting to referee games and we certainly view decisions with a different perspective now.

With this one, I can see where you're coming from Pete as Rice (I think) is off the ground as he makes the challenge -

View attachment 39949


However, he's not endangering an opponent at this point. My issue is that Emerson endangers himself by moving his leg to 'shield' the ball in an unnatural position. Look where his right leg is above compare to -

View attachment 39950

And the other angle shows it more clearly, he's nowhere near the ball that he's supposed to be shielding -


View attachment 39951

So in my view, he's bought the foul by where he's planted his leg, but Rice hasn't helped himself by the leap into the challenge. Also Taylor is too close to really see what's happened.

Also agree about Taylor being too close

he’s the best ref in our game though

 

[Sky_Blue_Dreamer]

The problem with that is instead of the keeper going down it will be an outfield player that just sits down faking injury. Just like yesterday

But an outfield player has to go off and come back on. When a keeper does that there is no such penalty. So an outfield player should have to go off instead and wait 30seconds or so before they are allowed back on.

 

[shmmeee]

Yeah just ban the players from going over to the sideline during any injury stoppage, book any players/send off any coaches who don’t comply. Might make coaching harder during legitimate stoppages, but that’s not the ref’s problem - it’s their own fault for abusing the system.

You can’t really do too much to disincentivise players from going down in case you end up exacerbating a genuine injury.

How much of a problem was exacerbating injuries before this happened? It’s a player by player thing anyway, some roll around and scream for the magic sponge and some just crack on. I’m not a physio but how many injuries are there you can actually treat pitchside and how much is just giving it a rub and waiting for the pain to subside?

 

[SBT]

How much of a problem was exacerbating injuries before this happened? It’s a player by player thing anyway, some roll around and scream for the magic sponge and some just crack on. I’m not a physio but how many injuries are there you can actually treat pitchside and how much is just giving it a rub and waiting for the pain to subside?

I don’t know, I don’t claim to have any sports physio insight. But on a basic/common sense player welfare level I don’t think you can implement a rule that would make a player think twice or feel they were at risk of being punished and/or hurting their team if they were genuinely injured.

 

[shmmeee]

I don’t know, I don’t claim to have any sports physio insight. But on a basic/common sense player welfare level I don’t think you can implement a rule that would make a player think twice or feel they were at risk of being punished and/or hurting their team if they were genuinely injured.

If they’re genuinely inured they can be subbed at the next break in play. I don’t see the issue TBH. Clubs can assess pitchside if there’s doubt. I really don’t see a need to constantly stop the game for “treatment”.

Would be good to get an actual physios view tho.

 

[Johhny Blue]

It’s easy. If a keeper stops play. The game is restarted with a corner. If it was a corner beforehand a free kick on the corner of the box

 

[David O'Day]

I’d like to hear the explanation there’s no need for the aggression in the tackle and he clearly endangers the safety of the opponent
I know you and the person making the video will say he got the ball but that’s not the only consideration

clearly my arse

awful decision by a dogshit ref

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

clearly my arse

awful decision by a dogshit ref

Says a non referee

 

[Terry Gibson's perm]

Hopefully when the new breed of ex player refs arrive sense will prevail, unfortunately to have got to a high standard now you have to give up playing early.

 

[JimmyHillsbeard]

Anyone want to praise yesterday’s ref for the excellent decision to come back for a free kick to us after a foul and the ball squirmed through to a player in an offside position?

Seemed absolute common sense. And therefore almost certainly wrong.

He also got the Cardiff goal right - no interference with the keeper, and obvs the penalty (after a good while).

 

[Frostie]

Anyone want to praise yesterday’s ref for the excellent decision to come back for a free kick to us after a foul and the ball squirmed through to a player in an offside position?

Seemed absolute common sense. And therefore almost certainly wrong.

He also got the Cardiff goal right - no interference with the keeper, and obvs the penalty (after a good while).

He was good yesterday yes. Robertson was incredibly fortunate not to get booked much earlier than he did but other than that, couldn't really fault him.

 

[shmmeee]

Keeper should have been off for two yellows tbh but would have taken a brave ref.

 

[stupot07]

Anyone want to praise yesterday’s ref for the excellent decision to come back for a free kick to us after a foul and the ball squirmed through to a player in an offside position?

Seemed absolute common sense. And therefore almost certainly wrong.

He also got the Cardiff goal right - no interference with the keeper, and obvs the penalty (after a good while).

Yeah he was decent, let the game flow and didn't make any bizarre decisions.

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

Keeper should have been off for two yellows tbh but would have taken a brave ref.

Pretty sure he yellow carded the keeper after the game

 

[robbiekeane]

It that's a foul then the Bradley tackle against Real Madrid should have been a sending off.

that is a fucking work of art. if i could frame that i would

 

[robbiekeane]

Substitute them. Honestly at this point forget the physios etc. Players can come off at a stoppage for “treatment” or they can be subbed if they’re too injured to do that.

completely agree with this.
Assuming genuine injuries:

Scenario 1) You are injured and need some magic spray or whatever magically fixes you mid game. You make your way to the sideline for treatment either immediately or when the ball next goes out. The game does not wait for you.

Scenario 2) You are genuinely so fucked you cannot make it to the sideline yourself. Substitution must be made, no excuses.


The only sticking points comes in when people have ACLs or leg breaks but that falls under scenario 2 anyway.

 

[SBAndy]

completely agree with this.
Assuming genuine injuries:

Scenario 1) You are injured and need some magic spray or whatever magically fixes you mid game. You make your way to the sideline for treatment either immediately or when the ball next goes out. The game does not wait for you.

Scenario 2) You are genuinely so fucked you cannot make it to the sideline yourself. Substitution must be made, no excuses.


The only sticking points comes in when people have ACLs or leg breaks but that falls under scenario 2 anyway.

But quite often you’ll have players that are in no way medically trained basically self-certifying that they are fit. That’s no good to anyone. I seem to recall after O’Hare did his ACL he tried running it off.

Don’t get me wrong, there’s a loophole that needs closing but it ain’t easy. One thought was that you let the physio enter the field of play during play, like in rugby, but I feel football moves too quickly for that to be worthwhile.

 

[ovduk78]

Pretty sure he yellow carded the keeper after the game

Keeper was booked before penalty was taken for saying something to Torp

 

[shmmeee]

But quite often you’ll have players that are in no way medically trained basically self-certifying that they are fit. That’s no good to anyone. I seem to recall after O’Hare did his ACL he tried running it off.

Don’t get me wrong, there’s a loophole that needs closing but it ain’t easy. One thought was that you let the physio enter the field of play during play, like in rugby, but I feel football moves too quickly for that to be worthwhile.

Then you take them off for five minutes to assess. You just don’t stop the game for it.