tisza
Well-Known Member
Would be a big U-turn from his talks with Macron and Scholz. But can't see him stopping without getting something he can sell to the world ( not just Russian public) as a win
USSR invades Ukraine. (9 Viewers)
- Thread starter Alan Dugdales Moustache
- Start date
If he gets Donestk, Luhansk and Crimea recognised as Russian will that be enough?
The war is going badly with huge losses, the economy is fucked, the rest of the world won't trade with them. Might be a case of get out while you can and let's be honest no matter how little they gain, they'll be able to sell it as a win to the domestic audience.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
There is zero chance - he will rather obliterate Ukraine - there is zero chance of Russia climbing down
Sick Boy
Super Moderator
I agree, unfortunately. It’s not like they’ve shown they can be trusted, have they?
Grendel
Well-Known Member
ironically I think at the beginning the annexation of the east of Ukraine into Russian hands would probably have been acceptable
Crimea itself has been such a problem area for centuries
I can’t see Ukraine agreeing it anyway and now how would it ever work they’d always by the threat of Russia moving back into those terrorise that would remain with Ukraine - Russia would insist on “peace keeping” forces policing the capital to protect Russian citizens
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Time Magazine has paid tribute to the American journalist and filmmaker Brent Renaud, who was killed earlier by gunfire in the Ukrainian town of Irpin.
Renaud, 50, was in Ukraine working on a Time Studios project focused on refugees, the company confirmed on Sunday.
In a statement Time editor-in-chief and CEO Edward Felsenthal and Ian Orefice, the president and chief operating officer of Time and Time Studios, said they were "devastated by the loss".
"As an award-winning filmmaker and journalist, Brent tackled the toughest stories around the world often alongside his brother Craig Renaud," the statement said. "Our hearts are with all of Brent’s loved ones."
Felsenthal and Orefice added that it is "essential that journalists are able to safely cover this ongoing invasion and humanitarian crisis in Ukraine".
Earlier on Sunday US National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan accused Russia of "targeting journalists" and said the US would impose "appropriate consequences".
Really not good
Think I need to reevaluate my life as I’m over 50 and I’m thinking what have I done
Renaud, 50, was in Ukraine working on a Time Studios project focused on refugees, the company confirmed on Sunday.
In a statement Time editor-in-chief and CEO Edward Felsenthal and Ian Orefice, the president and chief operating officer of Time and Time Studios, said they were "devastated by the loss".
"As an award-winning filmmaker and journalist, Brent tackled the toughest stories around the world often alongside his brother Craig Renaud," the statement said. "Our hearts are with all of Brent’s loved ones."
Felsenthal and Orefice added that it is "essential that journalists are able to safely cover this ongoing invasion and humanitarian crisis in Ukraine".
Earlier on Sunday US National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan accused Russia of "targeting journalists" and said the US would impose "appropriate consequences".
Really not good
Think I need to reevaluate my life as I’m over 50 and I’m thinking what have I done
SIR ERNIE
Well-Known Member
The only audience that matters to Putin is the 140m Russian citizens and the vast majority of them support what he’s doing because they only hear the state propaganda. So by that measure the war isn’t going badly, it’s going well and Mother Russia will prevail…and every new sanction and western weapon sent to Ukraine is more proof that the west are the enemy and justification of the invasion..
‘The rest of the world won’t trade with them’…simply wrong. EU countries continue to throw billions into the Russian coffers every week for energy at ever increasing prices, China continue to buy gas and oil, India signed a massive trade deal in December for gas, oil, wheat and more and Imran Khan openly met with Putin a few days ago to do exactly the same for Pakistan even against the backdrop of the invasion.
EU and US are cutting down on Russian oil and gas. India and Pakistan aren't going to make up for the rest of the world are they? Not even close. Yeah they can keep exporting oil and wheat to China, India and Pakistan. But what about all the machinery, parts, supplies, materials, they need. Ships and planes won't land/dock, they're out of SWIFT.
You grossly underestimate the number of, and effect of, all the sanctions and all the companies that are withdrawing.
Last edited:
duffer
Well-Known Member
Not a NATO base mate, 5 miles from Poland and within Ukraine.
Apparently used for training and storage, I'd guess it's where some of the munitions that are crossing the border are received.
I think if Putin hit anywhere within Poland then NATO would be duty bound to retaliate. Of course, Putin would try to muddy the water by claiming it was a Ukrainian false flag operation or something...
duffer
Well-Known Member
I know exactly where you're coming from, Pete, but if you're not careful this is the kind of thinking that leads to a messy divorce, a new trophy wife, and a two-seater sports car.
Hmm... there's probably a down side that I'm not seeing...
I never said he did. Doesn't alter the fact that India and Pakistan aren't going to replace the US, EU and the rest of the world in trade.
Well, whatever, that's irrelevant too. There is nothing false about my original statement: 'The war is going badly with huge losses, the economy is fucked, the rest of the world won't trade with them'
India/Pakistan and not caring about sanctions on Russian people is irrelevant to the statement above.
Oh shit, good point! How could I forget!
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
That’s war
Sky_Blue_Dreamer
Well-Known Member
That annexation may have been acceptable to Putin (and Putin alone) for five minutes. Then, emboldened by that win he pushes his agents further in and does the same again. And again. And again. Until someone stops him.
The fact that you think he'd just accept that and stop is just mind-blowingly naive. The same was said when he took Crimea. Instead he just increased operations in Luhansk and Donetsk. Genuinely, look at Hitler and see just how similar the gameplans are. Then see when Hitler decided to stop pushing for more. CLUE: He didn't.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
You really are utterly clueless. Hitler abs Putin comparisons are moronic
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Would you let Putin take any non NATO country without resistance?
D
Deleted member 9744
Guest
Why?
jimmyhillsfanclub
Well-Known Member
Ukraine: Eight arrests at oligarch's London mansion after balcony protest
Protesters wanted the property, believed to be owned by Oleg Deripaska, to house Ukrainian refugees.
www.bbc.co.uk
Marvellous......They should change the locks & move a load of Ukranian Refugees in.....(once they've jumped through all our hoops at calais of course)
Alan Dugdales Moustache
Well-Known Member
You're the ultimate pretender, be it
black, Catholic, Muslim , Russian Orthodox or a one legged, gender fluid, shrew.
How's the resistance fighting going ?
Alan Dugdales Moustache
Well-Known Member
Save face isn't something he understands. I wouldn't be surprised if he bombs refugee camps just over the border into Poland. He's immune to basic human sense of empathy and compassion. A total bastard .
Great post. Hope it’s correct, if so, Russia’s ability to fight and take control of cities will continue to reduce. unfortunately that might lead to more indiscriminate bombing in the short term. Longer term they’ll be struggling
Grendel
Well-Known Member
He has not got the resource. The notion he's going to be marching through Eastern Europe with some kind of Hitler type of domination is just never happening - he also knows there would be a limit China would tolerate - the West have made it clear what it will take to have a military response and Ukraine is not it
Alan Dugdales Moustache
Well-Known Member
The Russians cannot win a battle fighting hand to hand on the streets of kiyv. History shows that massive bombardment is the tactic that is used initially to try and wear down the resistance and break the opposition but, ultimately, they will have to fight street by street, block by block. That's where the battle is ultimately won or lost.
skybluetony176
Well-Known Member
According to US intelligence Russia has approached China for military aid. Could be a measure of how Russia is struggling, could be an attempt by Russia to drag China into it, could be both.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Im asking what your line would be. Am I right in reading your position that as Ukraine isn’t NATO we shouldn’t get involved?
Sky_Blue_Dreamer
Well-Known Member
Although Grendel won't believe it, sounds very reminiscent of Germany approaching Russia WWII. I don't think at this stage Putin would be crazy enough to make them an enemy if he was rebuffed but given how completely mad his actions over the past few months have become it's a niggling doubt.
I'm really starting to believe that Putin has had some massive event happen to him recently to affect his thinking. He always seemed quite patient but he just seems to be going all-out all of a sudden. Maybe it's to do with how much he has cut himself off recently due to Covid removing any semblance of dissent or the pandemic has put his own mortality and how long he might have left to achieve his aims into his mind , but I am really wondering if he's found out, or at least suspects, that he is seriously or terminally ill.
tisza
Well-Known Member
It's a relationship of mutual convenience rather than some great friendship.
As long as China's eyes on being the dominant influence in Asia they'll co-exist.
Could easily come a stage when China gets so powerful Russia will get paranoid about them and the huge border they share.