SkyblueDad
Well-Known Member
Hyam was sold because another sale was scuppered because the player concerned told the club he was going nowhere, there had been an inquiry for Hyam turned down but then rekindled by us and it became a buyers market.
The dom hyam sale (6 Viewers)
- Thread starter Evo1883
- Start date
This season yes clearly.
But last season it was the bloke ranked statistically amongst the best in the division and who is now captaining the team at the top of the league.
Blackburn wouldn't swap Hyam for MacFadzean (even if Fadz was 5 years younger)
Mild-Mannered Janitor
Kindest Bloke on CCFC / Maker of CCFC Dreams
All about balancing the books, when Blackburn first asked, we were saying no as the club clearly expected the books to be balanced from one of the 3 recognised stars we all thought would go, when those deals fell apart, we had to balance with a fire sale late on which is never a good bargaining position.
Wish him well, he has developed way beyond I first thought he would, I thought he lacked pace and would not be able to improve that enough and he has, like all at this level, has fantastic games but will also get caught out at times and have the odd howler.
Move on, he’s gone, we can enjoy or not, what we have now but longing for that ex is a strange and weird torment
Wish him well, he has developed way beyond I first thought he would, I thought he lacked pace and would not be able to improve that enough and he has, like all at this level, has fantastic games but will also get caught out at times and have the odd howler.
Move on, he’s gone, we can enjoy or not, what we have now but longing for that ex is a strange and weird torment
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Well that’s the point isn’t it.
Blackburn have conceded a lot of goals this season - we conceded 4 of our goals with Hyam in the team in 2 games - we won League 1 with Shipley in midfield - he’s not the best player in League 1
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Our good run to the L1 title really started once McFadz settled down and found his feet, he's never looked back since
Grendel
Well-Known Member
And the season before that
He's obviously better than Doyle or Rose.
He's been one of the first names on the team sheet since promotion, clearly ahead of Rose in the pecking order so why would he not get ahead of Rose now?
We all know you were massively wrong on Hyam, embarrassingly so, so I don't think your opinion on him is worth a lot to be honest.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
“We all know” - yet your not getting an abundance of support on the claim he’s been our best defender.
So if he was here and injured since game two he’s straight back?
Rose has started 74 league games despite a string of injuries so the pecking order statement isn’t factually accurate
What planet are you on, of course it it's factual.
In the two seasons in the Championship Rose has been on the bench 31 times. Hyam has been on the bench 3 times.
How is it not factually accurate that Hyam was above Rose in the pecking order? That's fucking wild even for you.
Calista
Well-Known Member
But our miserly defence also includes Panzo, who you said is nowhere near good enough.
It’s clear that our recent string of clean sheets is mainly down to a change of tactics, a pragmatic approach well executed by the manager. Boring football, but much needed in the circumstances.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
So Hyam has missed 74 games? They played together
Biamou was ahead of Gyokeres at one point was he better (actually let’s not go there)
Anyway You are refusing to answer if he’s fit would he be straight in
You also haven’t now admitted he wasn’t our best defender - which no one on this thread seems to agree with do they? Though you seem to be backtracking
Grendel
Well-Known Member
The point is without Mcfazdean we struggle - he’s head and shoulders above Hyam - Hyam leading the back 3 would not be a favourable outcome
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Would you rather Hyam than Rose or Panzo?
Have you had a bang to the head?
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Not really. I think as ex players go he’s forgettable - Panzo isn’t a great defender but I doubt it’s going to make much difference
Do you understand numbers? Do you know that 31 is higher than 3?
In my opinion Hyam has been our best defender in the last 2 seasons. Hence why he was signed by the team currently top of the league. This is not a slight on McFadzean, I think he's been excellent.
That is subjective, a matter of opinion.
Hyam being above Rose in the pecking order for the last 2 seasons is factual. It's just bizarre to try and argue otherwise.
Well who knows it could have been 6 clean sheets in 6 with Hyam. It could have been zero clean sheets. Nobody knows.
But what we do know is Hyam is better than Rose, hence being picked over him for the last 2 seasons, so of course he gets in the team.
Would you keep picking Allen over O'Hare?
D
Deleted member 9744
Guest
Yes
This you?
Not like you to change the narrative to fit whatever argument you're losing at the time.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
We scored 2 from open play in 6 games so let's bin off Gyo
Do you think we’d be able to sell Rose for £1.5m then? Sounds like a good deal to me.
But you think we'd get a similar fee for Rose, is what you're saying?
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
No on is saying he wasn't a great player but our defence has been far better since he left.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
I would argue it's since we sacrificed quality of football for being solid defensively.
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
Fine by me!